bhaexpress
New member
To overshadow the mighty Danny says it all.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Would Butters be Player of the Season if...
- Thread starter Lush
- Start date
Marshy
Well-known member
Knight
Cullip
Carpenter
Roberts
Harding.
Ok so he may creep in at 5 if im generous.
Cullip
Carpenter
Roberts
Harding.
Ok so he may creep in at 5 if im generous.
Easy 10
Brain dead MUG SHEEP
Roberts ?Marshy said:
Harding ?
Chippys been ok this season, but I wouldn't have it down as one of his vintage seasons by any means. You can always make a case for Cullip and Leon though. Not much in it between Cullip, Leon and Butters, but the improvement Butters has shown should count for something.
Marshy
Well-known member
Nope, you cant give it to someone just because they improved on being terrible to mediocre.
Id be absolutely devasted if i was Knight, Cullip or Carpenter.
Id be absolutely devasted if i was Knight, Cullip or Carpenter.
You think Butters has been mediocre this season?!?
He has been remarkably consistent (and not consistently mediocre, before you say it). He's been a '7 out of 10' every time he's set foot on the pitch which and he's started more league games than any other player (Leon equals him on 42 starts).
No-one has been outstanding this year so it was always going to be a tough, and close, call. I have no objections with Butters getting it with it also signifying 'most improved player'.
He has been remarkably consistent (and not consistently mediocre, before you say it). He's been a '7 out of 10' every time he's set foot on the pitch which and he's started more league games than any other player (Leon equals him on 42 starts).
No-one has been outstanding this year so it was always going to be a tough, and close, call. I have no objections with Butters getting it with it also signifying 'most improved player'.
Marshy
Well-known member
I think we are just going to have to differ on this one.
How much longer has Guy got on his contract ?
How much longer has Guy got on his contract ?
Brighton Breezy
New member
I dont think he would have won it if he hadnt been so shit last year because it was a very noticable improvement.
Marshy
Well-known member
hoorah someone who agrees with me ! Wise words Richie.
Brighton Breezy
New member
I voted for Chippy who has been the most consistent and at a higher quality then Butters. Butters has been a solid defender this year, that is all. Nothing worth getting excited about.
Marshy
Well-known member
Agreed.
And Bozza I would suggest that leading the goal scoring charts by some considerable way all season is outstanding in my book ?
Yeah Yeah i know he can be lazy and look uninterested but that argument dosent wash with me, hes there to score goals and every other side in the division would swap there Number 9 for him.
Cullip and Knight in Div 2 side, I rest my case.
And Bozza I would suggest that leading the goal scoring charts by some considerable way all season is outstanding in my book ?
Yeah Yeah i know he can be lazy and look uninterested but that argument dosent wash with me, hes there to score goals and every other side in the division would swap there Number 9 for him.
Cullip and Knight in Div 2 side, I rest my case.
Marshy said:
I would not argue with you or your book at all. But the books of the Albion support at large voted for Butters - and it is you that is arguing with that.
For the record - I didn't vote. Due to general apathy, mainly, I haven't been to a huge number of games this season so find it difficult to think of anyone who has been outstanding. As I said above - I don't think anyone actually has been outstanding.
Soton Seagull
Well-known member
I voted for Carpenter. His performance on Saturady shows what he brings to the team. Howver, i voted for Butters in 2nd place, so I was not exectly disappointed when he won it.