Worst even loan player at the Albion

[Icy Gull]

Except Ashley Neal who was obviously the worst ever.

As per another thread my vote goes to that "special relationship" gem Valur Gislasson. Oh how they must have laughed in the Arsenal boot room as that one was finalised.

 

[Pot noodles for everyone]

O'Carrieul (or however he spells his name), Robbie Savage, that goalie we had against Orient and that goalie with a surname like Gay

 

[BensGrandad]

Sam Williams from Villa was pony

 

[Sir Sarcy]

Valur Gislasson was shit as was Damian Hilton but they are hard pushed to beat the mighty Ashley Neal

 

[Gwylan]

Except Ashley Neal who was obviously the worst ever.

As per another thread my vote goes to that "special relationship" gem Valur Gislasson. Oh how they must have laughed in the Arsenal boot room as that one was finalised.

Agreed. I can't think further than those two

 

[Wilka]

Who was the striker who played 30 minutes against Hull towards the end of the goldstone?!? He was really shit.

 

[Lankyseagull]

Michael Mahoney-Johnson

 

[Taybha]

savage

 

[strings]

O'Carrieul (or however he spells his name), Robbie Savage, that goalie we had against Orient and that goalie with a surname like Gay

Gay was a goalie we had on trail for pre-season - we never offered him a contract (I saw him paly in this game: Brighton v. Wolves pre-season friendly). I think the other two are a bit harsh, being that they actually made an impact on games (even though O'Cerrieul [sp] faded after a good debut against West Ham and Savage didn't do much).

I would like to nominate either Keith Lowe (loan from Wolves, never played) or Bagayogo (same, but from Milwall).

 

[RM-Taylor]

 

[Scotty Mac]

damien hilton or dave martin

 

[Mackenzie]

Damian Hilton was very bad.

 

[Spider]

Of course he wasn't near the worst, but in the spirit of pointing out players who have had a suprisingly good career since leaving here, I'd say Darius Henderson was pretty pony when he played a few games for us.

Sam Williams is truely the worst I can remember. He was just appalling.

 

[Fourteenth Eye]

Andy Petterson was rubbish

 

[hans kraay fan club]

Sam Williams actually PLAYED, and even scored. Surely he can't rank as bad as the ones who came on loan and never even got on the pitch [Lowe, Bagayoko, etc]

 

[Mendoza]

Joe Dolan

Mark McCammon for the fact that we loaned him, he was shit, we then signed him even though he was shit, and to make it worse, we stayed up and then had to pay Millwall even more money for "him" keeping us up

 

[ben andrews' girlfriend]

Damian Hilton was very bad.

Wasn't Damien Hilton actually signed to us?? I thought he was with us for quite a long time?

You can tell the recent fans on this board - labelling Savage the worst ever!!!!

 

[alex_brighton]

savage!

 

[e77]

I didn't think Savage was that bad, just not worth the rumoured 13k a week.

 

[NF9]

Sam williams a few seasons ago, he was f***ing gash failing that savage