Which 36-year-old striker would you rather have?

[Safeway]

Scott McGleish: Proven goalscorer at every club he's played for, passionate, fans' favourite

Nicky Forster: Hands transfer request in on the morning of a game, argues with manager and team-mates, can't score at home

 

[Simster]

pmsl.


3) Leon Knight. Scores a sackful at division 3 level, including the winner at Cardiff to ensure the club is promoted and unlike his strike partner, does not f*** off to Germany a month later for a better pay cheque.

 

[Fourteenth Eye]

pmsl.


3) Leon Knight. Scores a sackful at division 3 level, including the winner at Wembley to ensure the club is promoted and unlike his strike partner, does not f*** off to Germany a month later for a better pay cheque.

Cardiff

 

[les dynam]

let's not go overboard on forster.

we don't know what has happened, how he's been treated, what he's been told. he's been our best player since he joined and still is. when we signed him loads of other clubs were after him. he's scored shedloads of goals, never complained when managers came and went, plus he's had to play alongside some truly woeful players.

he deserves better than appearing on the same poll as scott mcgleish

 

[8ace]

Kevin Phillips.

 

[Acker79]

Forster has scored at home.

 

[Gerbil]

Mcgleish, he proballly won't want to be treated like god here either.

 

[User removed 4]

Cardiff

some fan eh simster !!

 

[Philzo-93]

Honestly, it is disgraceful to even CONSIDER seeing Scott McGleish as an Albion player

What the f*** happened to common sense people!?

Scott McGleish = A muggy little ass of whom I want gone vanished and beat the living shit out of.

He is also a ****.

Obviously this guy wasn't at the game saturday!

 

[Husty]

I'd rather have mcgleish assuming he doesnt hand in transfer requests at very important times because he (rightly) isnt getting another year

 

[Husty]

Honestly, it is disgraceful to even CONSIDER seeing Scott McGleish as an Albion player

What the f*** happened to common sense people!?

Scott McGleish = A muggy little ass of whom I want gone vanished and beat the living shit out of.

He is also a ****.

Obviously this guy wasn't at the game saturday!

Were you? Or on tuesday come to think of it?

 

[Simon Morgan]

Forster is a better player than McGleish, who is effective at this level, but wouldn't do much were Orient to ever get promoted. Forster, on the other hand, would be quite at home in the Championship. Its a difficult one. As people have said, no one truly knows the ins and outs of what Fozzy did, but I'm not ready to turn on him just yet.

 

[Husty]

Forster is a better player than McGleish, who is effective at this level, but wouldn't do much were Orient to ever get promoted. Forster, on the other hand, would be quite at home in the Championship. Its a difficult one. As people have said, no one truly knows the ins and outs of what Fozzy did, but I'm not ready to turn on him just yet.

You really think so? I'd say he is far too slow, looked very out of sorts at Villa where their pacey centerbacks had the best of him all game, murray looked much more at home.

 

[El Turi]

Forster is a much better player. Has McGleish ever played at a higher level than league 1?

 

[murraymints4brighton]

You really think so? I'd say he is far too slow, looked very out of sorts at Villa where their pacey centerbacks had the best of him all game, murray looked much more at home.

Last time I checked Villa were near the top of the premier league, not in the championship. Forster was poor throughout the villa game, however STILL managed to score. Forster is also quicker than Murray and has scored more goals.

He is one of our best players, would be next year and the problem should be resolved. Oh and Mcgleish is a couple of levels below Forster and is in turn a twat.

 

[SeagullofKent]

pmsl.


3) Leon Knight. Scores a sackful at division 3 level, including the winner at Cardiff to ensure the club is promoted and unlike his strike partner, does not f*** off to Germany a month later for a better pay cheque.

i didnt realise knight was 36

 

[BensGrandad]

If the question was who would we rather have for the rest of this season it would have to be McGleish as he is a proven goal scorer at this level, whether he could do it in the Championship is immaterial. When he left Wycombe last year I would love us to have signed him, even as a back up striker, far better than anything we have on the bench.

The mind goes back to Fred Binney who was a brilliant goalscorer at this level but never made it any higher.

 

[Safeway]

Obviously this guy wasn't at the game saturday!

I was actually, and found his celebration quite amusing.

I was also at THAT game. Were you?

 

[thealbionfan]

Kevin Phillips.

Agreed...sign 'im up!!!!

 

[Horsham Gull]

hes only 29 but............