that Scumhampton player who got sent off yesterday

[Marc]

surely worthy of more than a 3 game ban? absolutely ridiculous challenge, could've easily snapped both legs of the B'Muff player

 

[BrickTamland]

Easily. Horrible challenge.

 

[FaganBHA]

Good josh !! ^^

 

[Napper]

Incredible tackle. Not sure the bloke had a clue where he was when flying through the air. Pretty comical

 

[sir albion]

Actually i thought he was unlucky as he was caught in two minds,any need for another southampton thread

 

[tonymgc]

It looked like something from Streetfighter, Idiot deserves having the book thrown at him.

 

[Bwian]

Actually i thought he was unlucky as he was caught in two minds,

What, to break one or two legs?

 

[matt_32510]

Horrible challenge

 

[Sheebo]

I agree with Claridge etc in the studio - he seemed to not realise what he'd done and just seemed to get a little confused. Was an awful tackle though.

 

[Lady Whistledown]

Was a crap challenge, and can't argue with the card, but also quite clearly just one of those ill-judged ones where he's committed himself and found it too late to abort by the time he's realised he's nowhere near the ball. Never going to break any legs as the Bournemouth player was in the air.

I genuinely think this was an innocent cock-up, as opposed to a pre-meditated bit of nastiness. You could see from his reaction that he was pretty mortified. No need for any further punishment IMHO.

 

[Sheebo]

Was a crap challenge, and can't argue with the card, but also quite clearly just one of those ill-judged ones where he's committed himself and found it too late to abort by the time he's realised he's nowhere near the ball. Never going to break any legs as the Bournemouth player was in the air.

I genuinely think this was an innocent cock-up, as opposed to a pre-meditated bit of nastiness. You could see from his reaction that he was pretty mortified. No need for any further punishment IMHO.

Agreed. I did feel a tiny bit sorry for him after seeing his reaction. It was like 'did i really just do that?!' type thing

 

[severnside gull]

would never have broken the guys legs
































................his ribs maybe but never his legs

 

[Foolg]

Was a crap challenge, and can't argue with the card, but also quite clearly just one of those ill-judged ones where he's committed himself and found it too late to abort by the time he's realised he's nowhere near the ball. Never going to break any legs as the Bournemouth player was in the air.

I genuinely think this was an innocent cock-up, as opposed to a pre-meditated bit of nastiness. You could see from his reaction that he was pretty mortified. No need for any further punishment IMHO.

This.
Don't often agree with Steve Claridge, but on this issue i certainly did.

 

[Safeway]

No need for any further punishment IMHO.

But he's a SOUTHAMPTON player, therefore a life ban is the only appropriate action. Anything less and we should be lobbying the Football League.

 

[Marc]

he could've done some very serious damage, 5 game ban minimum regardless of what team he plays for.