Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Team for Cardiff?











Questions

Habitual User
Oct 18, 2006
25,294
Worthing
Couldn't agree more - probably the one competition we could actually win, but top level football these days dictates that you shouldn't have such ambitions.

I think it is a (sporting) tragedy that so few clubs take any pride in entering this competition. Let's have a go - and qualify for Europe.

You old romantic you.
 


Perkino

Well-known member
Dec 11, 2009
6,036
Scherpen
Tsoungi, Veltman, Roberts
Karbownik, Caceido, Alzate, Moder
Mwepu, Zeqiri, Richards
 




GT49er

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Feb 1, 2009
48,506
Gloucester
The U18s are available - they haven't got a match until Saturday. Let's just get out of this winnable competition with a European place up for grabs as soon as possible, eh? Who wants a cup anyway? Not counting the Sussex county cup, we haven't won a cup for over a hundred years - surely we can be patient for another hundred years or so for a bit of silverware?

Yes, you've probably guessed it - I hate putting out a team to lose!
 


Simster

"the man's an arse"
Jul 7, 2003
54,760
Surrey
I'd like to see some fringe players but not too many. I accept that we have to wrap some of them in cotton wool because the league is so valuable these days, but equally the dividend for being a EPL also-ran should be to have a real chance in the cups. Therefore I hope we play a team that looks a bit unfamiliar but still on paper looks slightly too good for Cardiff.

Sanchez, Dunk, Bissouma and Maupay should be nowhere near Cardiff, but equally nor should fringe players who aren't knocking on the door of the EPL match day squad.
 


Wardy's twin

Well-known member
Oct 21, 2014
8,719
Could potentially see Richards playing as our man up top, he's mobile and has an eye for goal (10 in 41 for Doncaster in EFL last year) and he might find it difficult to break into our midfield but we clearly need options up front.
 




PILTDOWN MAN

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Sep 15, 2004
19,296
Hurst Green












Hugo Rune

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Feb 23, 2012
23,368
Brighton
—————————-Steele—————————-
———Turns———-Tsoungui—-Roberts——
Karbownik——Alzate——Caicedo——Moder
———————Richards——Leonard—————
——————————Zeqiri——————————
 




Swansman

Pro-peace
May 13, 2019
22,320
Sweden
Yes, it would. Most on here completely disagree, obviously - they are all advocating team line-ups to lose. Cardiff are a string Championship side, at home - we're never going to beat them with a cobbled up side. Can't understand why everbody is adamant that Karbownik should be in the team - he looked well off the pace in pre-season, and wasn't even on the bench on Saturday.
Resting playrs? Yes, OK, Lallana, possibly Bissouma and maybe one of the three CBs that started in Saturday. No more.

No one is "advocating team line-ups to lose". There's just huge disadvantages to playing the strongest team & big advantages to playing young/fringe players in this cup and thats why people, including Potter and pretty much every other PL manager, does it this way.
 


GT49er

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Feb 1, 2009
48,506
Gloucester
No one is "advocating team line-ups to lose". There's just huge disadvantages to playing the strongest team & big advantages to playing young/fringe players in this cup and thats why people, including Potter and pretty much every other PL manager, does it this way.

Most of the team line ups put forward as suggestions on this thread are teams set up to lose - and that's nothing to do with Potter, or what team Potter may or may not choose.
 


chaileyjem

#BarberIn
NSC Patron
Jun 27, 2012
14,565
This was the squad for the equivalent fixture last year v Pompey. They won 4-0.
5 or 6 starters and 9 of the squad if you include Molumby (who is likely to leave) have now left the club, 3 - a year later - started against Watford,
Probably only Roberts and Steele likely to start tonight.

Steele (first team squad)
Molumby (sold by end of window)
Veltman (first team injured)
Burn (first team injured)
Bernardo (sold)
Pröpper (sold)
Stephens (sold)
Jahanbakhsh (sold)
Groß (first team)
Mac Allister (first team)
Gyökeres (sold)

Substitutes

Sánchez (first team)
Sanders (sold)
Gwargis (sold)
Roberts (first team)
Cochrane (loan to SPL)
Yapi (sold)
Dendoncker (injured)
 
Last edited:


Swansman

Pro-peace
May 13, 2019
22,320
Sweden
Most of the team line ups put forward as suggestions on this thread are teams set up to lose - and that's nothing to do with Potter, or what team Potter may or may not choose.

In your opinion yes.

I believe the fringe/young players of this squad is capable of giving Cardiff a very good match and quite possibly win.
 




GT49er

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Feb 1, 2009
48,506
Gloucester
This was the squad for the equivalent fixture last year v Pompey. They won 4-0.
5 or 6 starters if you include Molumby (who is likely to leave) have now left the club, 3 started against Watford,

Steele (first team squad)
Molumby (sold by end of window)
Veltman (first team injured)
Burn (first team injured)
Bernardo (sold)
Pröpper (sold)
Stephens (sold)
Jahanbakhsh (sold)
Groß (first team)
Mac Allister (first team)
Gyökeres (sold)

Substitutes

Sánchez (first team)
Sanders (sold)
Gwargis (sold)
Roberts (first team)
Cochrane (loan to SPL)
Yapi (sold)
Dendoncker (injured)

Fair smattering of (at the time) first teamers in that line up - plus it was at home, and Portsmouth were much less of a threat than a Mick McCarthy managed Cardiff at their place!
Veltman, Burn, Bernardo (although not much lately), Pröpper, Stephens, Jahanbakhsh (just about), Groß and Mac Allister were all first team, so overall a pretty strong team. Didn't fanny about - got through. Hope Potter doesn't fanny about and put out a team too weak to beat Cardiff.
 


GT49er

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Feb 1, 2009
48,506
Gloucester
In your opinion yes.

I believe the fringe/young players of this squad is capable of giving Cardiff a very good match and quite possibly win.

Yes, some in the team - but not all at once, as many have suggested. Apart from youth and lack if experience, a centre midfield that have never played together - not good; a back three who have never played together - not good. Yet many blithely believe that they will roll over a strong Mick McCarthy side on their own patch!
 
Last edited:


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here