Reinelt12
Sick Note
Any ratings for us exiles please?
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Player Ratings - Charlton H
- Thread starter Reinelt12
- Start date
bhamex1901
New member
- Dec 20, 2010
- 679
Ankegren - 7
Calderon - 3
Greer - 7
El-Abd - 8 (MOM)
Painter - 6
Bennett - 8
Sparrow - 4
Dicker - 6
Bridcutt - 6
Murray - 8
Wood - 6
Calderon - 3
Greer - 7
El-Abd - 8 (MOM)
Painter - 6
Bennett - 8
Sparrow - 4
Dicker - 6
Bridcutt - 6
Murray - 8
Wood - 6
bhamex1901
New member
- Dec 20, 2010
- 679
Ankegren - 7
Calderon - 3
Greer - 7
El-Abd - 8 (MOM)
Painter - 6
Bennett - 8
Sparrow - 4
Dicker - 6
Bridcutt - 6
Murray - 8
Wood - 6
Calderon - 3
Greer - 7
El-Abd - 8 (MOM)
Painter - 6
Bennett - 8
Sparrow - 4
Dicker - 6
Bridcutt - 6
Murray - 8
Wood - 6
deletebeepbeepbeep
Well-known member
- May 12, 2009
- 21,636
Ankergren - 7
Calderon - 1 (stupid)
Greer - 7
Abd - 8
Painter - 6
Bennett - 8
Sparrow - 5
Dicker - 7
Bridcutt - 7
Murray - 8 (MOM)
Wood - 5
Barnes/Kishishev - not on long enough.
Calderon - 1 (stupid)
Greer - 7
Abd - 8
Painter - 6
Bennett - 8
Sparrow - 5
Dicker - 7
Bridcutt - 7
Murray - 8 (MOM)
Wood - 5
Barnes/Kishishev - not on long enough.
Casper 8
Calde - 7 (at least, that's the number of minutes he played)
Greer - 7
Adam - 9.5 he was emmense
Painter - 7
Dicker - 7
Sparrow - 7.5
Bridcutt - 8.5 had a good game
Bennett - 8.5 worked so hard
Wood - 7 I wish he could score in open play
Murray - 9.6 somehow manged to shade Adam to MoM.
Calde - 7 (at least, that's the number of minutes he played)
Greer - 7
Adam - 9.5 he was emmense
Painter - 7
Dicker - 7
Sparrow - 7.5
Bridcutt - 8.5 had a good game
Bennett - 8.5 worked so hard
Wood - 7 I wish he could score in open play
Murray - 9.6 somehow manged to shade Adam to MoM.
clippedgull
Hotdogs, extra onions
Ankegren - 6
Calderon - 1
Greer - 6
El-Abd - 7
Painter -5 (Marked down for giving away the penalty)
Bennett - 6
Sparrow - 5
Dicker - 6
Bridcutt - 6
Murray - 7
Wood - 5
Calderon - 1
Greer - 6
El-Abd - 7
Painter -5 (Marked down for giving away the penalty)
Bennett - 6
Sparrow - 5
Dicker - 6
Bridcutt - 6
Murray - 7
Wood - 5
Last edited:
Ankergren - 7 - couple of great saves. Generally sound. Incredibly not tested very often.
Calderon - 3 - couldn't see the tackle clearly, but seems it was two footed. Shame - we'd have won with 11 men
Greer - 7 - strong at the back. Couple of slips covered nively by his mates
El-Abd - 8 - huge game. This man has done a deal with the devil because he is not the same player as a couple of years ago.
Painter - 7 - quiet and efficient. Effortless defending
Bennett - 8 - played as two men for 83 minutes. What a hero.
Bridcutt - 7 - was everywhere. Not always accurate when forcing the game, but snuffed out the little Charlton tried to build in midfield.
Sparrow - 6 - good game. Dispossessed too easily early on. Grew into the game.
Dicker - 6 - hot and cold. Gave the ball away that led to the penalty but can see a pass like no one else.
(Kishishev 86) - 7 - did what he had to for a few minutes. Thought he'd scored at the end. Great substitution by Gus.
Wood - 6 - played for a long time with his back to goal. No real threat apart from one header but isolated. Not as good in the air as you'd think.
Murray - 8 - won almost every header. Brought players into the game. Lovely passing (esp to Kish at the end of the game after his run at Charlton). MOM for me.
Calderon - 3 - couldn't see the tackle clearly, but seems it was two footed. Shame - we'd have won with 11 men
Greer - 7 - strong at the back. Couple of slips covered nively by his mates
El-Abd - 8 - huge game. This man has done a deal with the devil because he is not the same player as a couple of years ago.
Painter - 7 - quiet and efficient. Effortless defending
Bennett - 8 - played as two men for 83 minutes. What a hero.
Bridcutt - 7 - was everywhere. Not always accurate when forcing the game, but snuffed out the little Charlton tried to build in midfield.
Sparrow - 6 - good game. Dispossessed too easily early on. Grew into the game.
Dicker - 6 - hot and cold. Gave the ball away that led to the penalty but can see a pass like no one else.
(Kishishev 86) - 7 - did what he had to for a few minutes. Thought he'd scored at the end. Great substitution by Gus.
Wood - 6 - played for a long time with his back to goal. No real threat apart from one header but isolated. Not as good in the air as you'd think.
Murray - 8 - won almost every header. Brought players into the game. Lovely passing (esp to Kish at the end of the game after his run at Charlton). MOM for me.
I think it was Painter that gave away the penalty
clippedgull
Hotdogs, extra onions
I'm sure it was El-Abd, the BBC text seemed to suggest it was, but if it was Painter then fair enough!
The Argus says Painter!
Blackadder
Brighton Bhuna Boy
Blimey, looking at those scores, were BHAMAN and Clipped Gull at the same match?
BHAMAN think you are tad generous there.
Was it EL-ABD that gave away the pen? (I'm not sure)
BHAMAN think you are tad generous there.
Was it EL-ABD that gave away the pen? (I'm not sure)
deletebeepbeepbeep
Well-known member
- May 12, 2009
- 21,636
To be honest, it looked to me that Ankergren took him down but was given little choice due to a sleepy defence.
CliveWalkerWingWizard
Well-known member
Ankergren 7.5 solid - one great save
Painter 6 - not as good as usual
Calde 5 - do not know if he was at fault
ElAbd 7 - Solid
Greer 7 - Solid
Bridcutt 6 - very lively but gave away possession far too often
Bennett 6 - A big ask to do 2 jobs
Dicker - 7
Sparrow 7
Murray - 9 immense
Wood 5 could have pressured more - no pace and poor first touch
Painter 6 - not as good as usual
Calde 5 - do not know if he was at fault
ElAbd 7 - Solid
Greer 7 - Solid
Bridcutt 6 - very lively but gave away possession far too often
Bennett 6 - A big ask to do 2 jobs
Dicker - 7
Sparrow 7
Murray - 9 immense
Wood 5 could have pressured more - no pace and poor first touch
Ankergren - 7. Couple of times I get worried but all round solid.
Calde - 3. Looked like a foul, just wasn't happy that the ref appeared to change his mind a few seconds after the foul
El-Abd - 9. He is superb
Greer - 9. Same as above
Painter - 8. Solid as normal
Bennet - 8. A few missed placed passes but does such a great job at right-back when needed
Dicker - 8. Whatever missed placed passes he made don't matter because he was part of the 3 man midfield that kept us in it
Sparrow - 7. A bit quiet but always seems to be in the right place
Bridcutt - 8. He is always in the right place, earned us a point with a superb goal-line clearance
Wood - 6. He could have easily scored with that header and just didn't run around enough for a team down to 10
Murray - 9. When he plays like that he is Championship quality, easily
Calde - 3. Looked like a foul, just wasn't happy that the ref appeared to change his mind a few seconds after the foul
El-Abd - 9. He is superb
Greer - 9. Same as above
Painter - 8. Solid as normal
Bennet - 8. A few missed placed passes but does such a great job at right-back when needed
Dicker - 8. Whatever missed placed passes he made don't matter because he was part of the 3 man midfield that kept us in it
Sparrow - 7. A bit quiet but always seems to be in the right place
Bridcutt - 8. He is always in the right place, earned us a point with a superb goal-line clearance
Wood - 6. He could have easily scored with that header and just didn't run around enough for a team down to 10
Murray - 9. When he plays like that he is Championship quality, easily
FalmerforAll!**
NSC's Most Intelligent
Re-read that for a second, and consider that we didn't make a sub until the last ten minutes. To me it seemed as though Gus had deliberately told him not to bother chasing after the back four knocking it between each other in order to not tire himself out, which paid off in the end as I think he had one of his better games for the time he was on.
Murray - 11
Awesome
Awesome
samtheseagull
Well-known member
- Sep 15, 2010
- 1,600
its mad how the ratings are so different!
TrueFan
New member
Am I the only person who thought Greer's passing was shocking? His early way ward pass allowed Charlton to gain possesion, win a penalty, and score.
Lord Bracknell
On fire
Give Bridcutt a bonus point for the coolest goal-line clearance I have EVER seen.
Jimmy Grimble
Well-known member
Casper 7
Calderon - n/a
El Abd - 8
Greer - 7
Painter - 6
Elliot - 8
Sparrow - 6
Bridcutt - 7
Dicker - 6
Murray - 9
Wood - 7
Calderon - n/a
El Abd - 8
Greer - 7
Painter - 6
Elliot - 8
Sparrow - 6
Bridcutt - 7
Dicker - 6
Murray - 9
Wood - 7