the full harris
New member
- Feb 14, 2004
- 3,212
Knight might stay with us if we give him this award so I'll vote for him!
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Player of the season?
- Thread starter El Presidente
- Start date
- Thread starter
- #23
Amazed that Butters is walking away with it. He has done reasonably well against Division 2 strikers, but he should hold his own at this level having played all of his career at Prem/Div 1 level. The reason I go for Chippy is that he has done his best to hold the midfield together all season depsite the injuries to Rodger/Oatway the dips in form of Hart and the loss of Brooker.
I would vote for Leon as number 2. He does have skills at this level that no other player in the squad (or division for that matter) does not possess. He has not helped himself with the diving accusations, but has been the difference between points earned and lost in many matches
I would vote for Leon as number 2. He does have skills at this level that no other player in the squad (or division for that matter) does not possess. He has not helped himself with the diving accusations, but has been the difference between points earned and lost in many matches
- Jul 7, 2003
- 47,498
Knight has undoubtedly scored the goals to be a contender, but many people feel his attitude isn't what it could be.
Butters is never going to be a world class defender, but you have to give him credit for what he's achieved this season. People are voting for Cullip, but he's only recently come into form- personally I think Cullip has been below his usual impeccable standards for a fair amount of this season, whereas Butters has at least been consistent, and you can't fault his attitude or application.
I think it's fair to consider him (and no I don't feel guilty at all).
Carpenter has recovered from a crap start to be our best midfielder by far lately. OK, it's not exactly a crowded field, but you've still got to do the job, and he's done it.
They have to be the top three, though in what order is anyone's guess. My prediction: 1. Butters 2. Knight 3 Carpenter
(and for the Seagulls Club player of the year: 1. Knight 2. Hart 3. McPhee)
Butters is never going to be a world class defender, but you have to give him credit for what he's achieved this season. People are voting for Cullip, but he's only recently come into form- personally I think Cullip has been below his usual impeccable standards for a fair amount of this season, whereas Butters has at least been consistent, and you can't fault his attitude or application.
I think it's fair to consider him (and no I don't feel guilty at all).
Carpenter has recovered from a crap start to be our best midfielder by far lately. OK, it's not exactly a crowded field, but you've still got to do the job, and he's done it.
They have to be the top three, though in what order is anyone's guess. My prediction: 1. Butters 2. Knight 3 Carpenter
(and for the Seagulls Club player of the year: 1. Knight 2. Hart 3. McPhee)
Last edited:
Knightsworld
Well-known member
Butters, just for his consistency throughout the season (so far)
Seagullmatt
New member
Butters, he's overcome adversity to become a solid, dependable part of the first team.
Beach Hut
Brighton Bhuna Boy
Has to be the big man for me - a vast improvement of last season
Lammy
Registered Abuser
I can't believe Butters is getting so many votes? Are you really saying he's the best player we've had this season?
This isn't a vote for the most improved player. In which case he would definitely get my vote!
This isn't a vote for the most improved player. In which case he would definitely get my vote!
Lammy
Registered Abuser
He consistantly hoofs the ball up the field?
Blackadder
Brighton Bhuna Boy
Had to vote for the divison's highest scorer!