OK then, you pick the team

[Storer68]

As we all know better than MM (win rate is 12% at the moment!) about what is the best XI we can put out, it is time to put up or shut up.

You have to chose from players that are currently under contract to brighton & Hove ALbion FC and are available for selection (so that's no players that we have out on loan to other clubs, injured etc)

 

[Uncle Buck]

Henderson

RWB Reid
LWB Mayo

CB Butters
CB McShane (El-Abd on Saturday)
CB Hinsh

CM Carpenter
CM Hammnond
CM Carole

FW CKR
FW Gatting / Hart / Robinson

 

[TrevorDove]

Henderson (GK)

El Abd (RB)
McShane (CB)
Butters (CB)
Lynch (LB)

Carpenter (DM)
Hammond (CM)
Reid (CM)

Carole (AM - L& R)
Kazim Richards (CF)
Gatting (CF)

Thank me at the end of the season if you are reading this Magoo.

 

[blockhseagull]

Henderson

Hinsh McShane Butters Lynch

Carole Hammond Nicolas Frutos

CKR Gatting


Martin
Mayo
Carpenter
Hart
Robinson

 

[Dave the OAP]

.................................Kuipers ( I would get him back now)

...........Hinchelwood.......Butters........Mcshane...........

El Abd...........................................................................Reid


.................Frutos................Nicholas..........Carole

.................CKR.............................Turienzo


Subs .........McCammon, McPhee, Robinson, Hammond, That bloke from hastings, who if he is not going to play him what the f*** is he doing on the payroll

 

[Gazwag]

Re: Re: OK then, you pick the team

That bloke from hastings, who if he is not going to play him what the f*** is he doing on the payroll

Maybe he thought he was signing the contract of a firm of builders to make a extra room in his roof at home

 

[SULLY COULDNT SHOOT]

Every team list so far suffers from the same problem... lack of goals up front.

So not much improvement then.....

 

[saltash seagull]

------------------------henderson------------------------

--------------mcshane--butters--hinch----------------

hart-------------------------------------------fruity

---------------hammond------mayo--------------

----------------------carole-----------------------

--------------ckr---------------gatting----------

subs

martin
lynch
reid
chippy
robinson

but as ogh and mcahane are both suspended i would play in defence

reid--------elabd-----butters---hinch-----lynch

 

[blockhseagull]

Fruity can't defend though !!!

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

MM Saturday morning : "Bob?...Bob? Have you seen my velvet bag anywhere, I need to pick the team today"

 

[Gazwag]

Henderson

.............Hinchelwood....Butter....McShane

El Abd ...................................................... Hart/Lynch

..............Reid.........Frutos..........Hammond/Hart

.................CKR.....................Gatting

 

[Dave the OAP]

looks like I am not the only one thinking we should play three across the back and two wingbacks then?

 

[blockhseagull]

looks like I am not the only one thinking we should play three across the back and two wingbacks then?

I would maybe agree if we had the players to do it

 

[dwayne]

Henderson

RWB Reid
LWB Mayo

CB Butters
CB McShane (El-Abd on Saturday)
CB Hinsh

CM Carpenter
CM Hammnond
CM Carole

FW CKR
FW Gatting / Hart / Robinson

I agree with this and reckon our formation should have changed weeks ago. WHY continue with the attacking formation if it's not producing goals? Surely we should rethink completely, tighten the ship (we have the personnel to do this) and try and nick a goal here or there...or would this change entail arrogant Mcghee admitting he was wrong?

 

[Uncle Buck]

I would maybe agree if we had the players to do it

Well in the centre back roles you can have any 3 of Butters, McShane, Hinsh, El-Abd, Lynch and Tommy Elphick.

Mayo in the past has looked comfortable at wing back, I guess having an extra defender covering him helps and as Reid likes to get forward, I would have thought right wing back will suit him.

 

[Seagullible]

It's not just about team selection but also motivation, tactics, man amanagement etc which are things I question about MM

 

[Schrödinger's Toad]

(3-5-2)
Hendo

Frutos
-
Butters
McShane
Hinsh
-
Reid

Nicolas
Hammond
Chippy

Kazim-Richards
Turienzo.


But then, I wouldn't have fallen out with our best striker ...

 

[Storer68]

Re: Re: OK then, you pick the team

.................................Kuipers ( I would get him back now)

...........Hinchelwood.......Butters........Mcshane...........

El Abd...........................................................................Reid


.................Frutos................Nicholas..........Carole

.................CKR.............................Turienzo


Subs .........McCammon, McPhee, Robinson, Hammond, That bloke from hastings, who if he is not going to play him what the f*** is he doing on the payroll

No you cant have Kuipers or McCammon - they're both elesewhere

and who is Hinchelwood?

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

It's not just about team selection but also motivation, tactics, man amanagement etc which are things I question about MM

Ahh but thats down to wages, stadium, facilities

The squad is good enough to compete. Player for player we are no worse than Stoke or QPR or Plymouth or Hull but we have the wrong man in charge.

 

[Dave the OAP]

Mr Toad...do you believe that is our best Midfield .

I would respectfully suggest that the latter two is one of the main reasons we are where we are!