Noone penalty appeal

[kevo]

Anyone get a clear view? Looked like a sure pen from where I was.

 

[LABHA]

5.5 i gave it

 

[Not Andy Naylor]

The replays made it look like a good shout. His leg was definitely caught.

 

[SeagullSongs]

I couldn't see whether it was a penalty or not, but the ref made a hash of it either way.
In my opinion it should've either been a penalty for us, or he should've booked Noone for diving. Instead he chose neither, incompetence.

 

[jackcgull]

wsu south was the perfect view - noone was stretching away from the defender and he caught his leg. pen. but we were never getting a pen today if the guy had speared him to the ground with cermonial javelins, burned his shorts then buried the nylon-heavy ashes in the centre circle

 

[00snook]

I couldn't see whether it was a penalty or not, but the ref made a hash of it either way.
In my opinion it should've either been a penalty for us, or he should've booked Noone for diving. Instead he chose neither, incompetence.

Yep. Ref gave a goalkick which means he felt that Nooney knocked it on (and eventually out).

If Noone knocked it on then fell over thats a blatent dive (and a yellow card)

If Noone knocked it on the was tripped over thats a blatent foul (and a penalty)

As it was the ref did nothing. Which is rather crap refereeing in my opinion.

 

[nomoremithras4me]

Surprised the ref didn't give a throw in down the opposite end, f@@king useless, East Brighton park for the officials tomorrow morning

 

[Woodchip]

wsu south was the perfect view - noone was stretching away from the defender and he caught his leg. pen. but we were never getting a pen today if the guy had speared him to the ground with cermonial javelins, burned his shorts then buried the nylon-heavy ashes in the centre circle

WSL block B and same opinion.

 

[terryberry1]

from the south you could even hear him being clipped.

 

[terryberry1]

Surprised the ref didn't give a throw in down the opposite end, f@@king useless, East Brighton park for the officials tomorrow morning

He is not worthy to walk to turf of east brighton park

 

[Caveman]

Yep. Ref gave a goalkick which means he felt that Nooney knocked it on (and eventually out).

If Noone knocked it on then fell over thats a blatent dive (and a yellow card)

If Noone knocked it on the was tripped over thats a blatent foul (and a penalty)

As it was the ref did nothing. Which is rather crap refereeing in my opinion.

Had the exact same conversation in the bar after.

 

[paul pring]

i was in the south stand in front of the tackle which was mistimed and was 100% penalty,but we was never going to get anything from that ref.i am sure i saw him outside the ground with a burnley shirt on.i think he lives in croydon.

 

[nomoremithras4me]

He is not worthy to walk to turf of east brighton park

Probably right Tel, maybe mile oak rec?

 

[kevo]

Yep. Ref gave a goalkick which means he felt that Nooney knocked it on (and eventually out).

If Noone knocked it on then fell over thats a blatent dive (and a yellow card)

If Noone knocked it on the was tripped over thats a blatent foul (and a penalty)

As it was the ref did nothing. Which is rather crap refereeing in my opinion.

Anyone also notice that about 2 mins after he booked a Burnley player for deliberate handball, there was another deliberate hand ball by Burnley in the middle of the pitch. Another free-kick, but this time, no booking. Why?!

 

[Barnham Seagull]

Anyone also notice that about 2 mins after he booked a Burnley player for deliberate handball, there was another deliberate hand ball by Burnley in the middle of the pitch. Another free-kick, but this time, no booking. Why?!

Because he is out of his depth. Totaly lost the plot.

 

[Deleted member 2719]

Noone tried to get to the line to cross the ball and defender caught him........... 100% pen from where i was sitting.

 

[dadams2k11]

Anyone get a clear view? Looked like a sure pen from where I was.

Was in South stand and was a clear Pen but like others have said we could of played till next Saturday and still would not of got a decision in our favor.. Poor Poor ref, if i made that many mistakes in one day at work i would get sacked. Shocking

 

[LamieRobertson]

wen nooney broke thru there defence earlier the decision was clearer as to a free kick...wel i say clear...to every man woman and child ..but the idiot in charge

he cudnt even get corners n goal kicks right twat....grrr

 

[kevo]

wen nooney broke thru there defence earlier the decision was clearer as to a free kick...wel i say clear...to every man woman and child ..but the idiot in charge

Was that when he was sent flying off the ball just as he was bringing it down the wing? That was as clear a foul as I've ever seen. When the ref waved play on I went apoplectic. Apologies to those around me in the East...