Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

McGhee Must Stay - Argus comment



bhaexpress

New member
Jul 7, 2003
27,627
Kent
How to ruin some people's day

From The Argus

McGhee must stay
by Andy Naylor

It has been a depressing season for Albion but this is a time for cool heads, rather than panic measures.

The last thing they need while the fight for Falmer rumbles on is more managerial upheaval.

They already have a safe pair of hands in Mark McGhee and they should stick with him.

Relegation from the Championship is disappointing but hardly surprising. It is no coincidence that the clubs with the lowest crowds and therefore smallest revenues - Albion, Crewe and Millwall - have filled the bottom three places.

The Seagulls have been punching above their weight at Withdean, against much bigger and wealthier clubs like Leeds and Wolves, since McGhee steered them to promotion two seasons ago.

They survived by the skin of their teeth last season but the summer sale of goalscorer Adam Virgo to Celtic proved to be a knockout blow.

Albion can become a Leeds or Wolves, maybe even a Wigan or Charlton, in a new stadium.

Until then they are destined to be a yo-yo club like Crewe, getting by on modest crowds with no money to buy new players, relying instead on producing their own.

Albion are producing more of their own young players now than at any other time in the club's history.

Dean Wilkins' kids reached the quarter-finals of the FA Youth Cup, beating Chelsea and Blackburn before losing on penalties at Newcastle.

Three of that team, Joel Lynch , Joe Gatting and Tommy Elphick, have already been given a taste of first team action by McGhee.

Developing a young squad takes time and patience. It also requires the support and understanding of the fans in the stands and the boardroom.

Three managers before him - Micky Adams, Peter Taylor and Steve Coppell - were driven away by the intolerable wait for a stadium worthy of Championship and possibly Premiership, football, which is bleeding the club dry.

McGhee has been prepared to work within the restrictions, to do the best job he can in trying circumstances. Such loyalty deserves a degree of loyalty in return.

Of course, he has made mistakes - what manager doesn't? A blame culture is inevitable when a team gets relegated but changing the manager now would be a knee-jerk reaction, change for change's sake.

What then? A search would begin for somebody with the experience and track record to lift Albion back up from League One next season.

Somebody perhaps who both played and managed at the highest level and has won promotion from League One for three different clubs.

Funny that. His name is Mark McGhee.

____________________________________________________

I can't help feeling that the anti Naylorites on here will se this as yet another example of Mr Naylor trying to undermine the club !
 










Squiggsy

New member
Oct 26, 2003
184
Worthing
Couldn't agree more, in fact I'd quite happily settle for mid-table comfort next year, winning a few more games and getting some of the kids established.

We have to bring them through to build something sustainable (or at least some chunky transfer money in), rather than just looking for seasoned pros to 'get us out of the division': -

a) I don't think those players are available / affordable to us
b) We'd just be looking relegation in the face again if we went up on that basis

Mid-table obscurity, a few decent games to watch and (please please please) a 100% irreversible Falmer yes would do me fine for next season.
 




tinx

Well-known member
Jul 6, 2003
9,198
Horsham Town
Have to agree, as much as MCGhee has made a few errors in tactics and such like this season, he does have a proven track record at getting teams out of that league including us so why can't he do it again.
 


bhaexpress

New member
Jul 7, 2003
27,627
Kent
Well its nice to see so many constructive comments about McGhee for a change. I have no personal opinions about Andy Naylor but I also think his article is right on the money.
 


Re: How to ruin some people's day

bhaexpress said:
I can't help feeling that the anti Naylorites on here will se this as yet another example of Mr Naylor trying to undermine the club !
When I read that piece out loud, it came out in a Scottish accent.
 




Icy Gull

Back on the rollercoaster
Jul 5, 2003
72,015
Most of the Magoo outers are lazy students and/or drug abusers who haven't got up yet, the backlash is gonna come very late this morning :jester:
 
Last edited:








bhaexpress

New member
Jul 7, 2003
27,627
Kent
Icy Gull said:
Most of the Magoo outers are lazy students and/or drug abusers who haven't got up yet, the backlash is gonna come very late this morning :jester:

Would this be a good time for another McGhee in or out poll ?
 




sussexfatboy

New member
Jan 4, 2005
106
Hastings
McGhee must stay
by Andy Naylor

It has been a depressing season for Albion but this is a time for cool heads, rather than panic measures.

The last thing they need while the fight for Falmer rumbles on is more managerial upheaval.

They already have a safe pair of hands in Mark McGhee and they should stick with him.

Relegation from the Championship is disappointing but hardly surprising. It is no coincidence that the clubs with the lowest crowds and therefore smallest revenues - Albion, Crewe and Millwall - have filled the bottom three places.

The Seagulls have been punching above their weight at Withdean, against much bigger and wealthier clubs like Leeds and Wolves, since McGhee steered them to promotion two seasons ago.

They survived by the skin of their teeth last season but the summer sale of goalscorer Adam Virgo to Celtic proved to be a knockout blow.

Albion can become a Leeds or Wolves, maybe even a Wigan or Charlton, in a new stadium.

Until then they are destined to be a yo-yo club like Crewe, getting by on modest crowds with no money to buy new players, relying instead on producing their own.

Albion are producing more of their own young players now than at any other time in the club's history.

Dean Wilkins' kids reached the quarter-finals of the FA Youth Cup, beating Chelsea and Blackburn before losing on penalties at Newcastle.

Three of that team, Joel Lynch , Joe Gatting and Tommy Elphick, have already been given a taste of first team action by McGhee.

Developing a young squad takes time and patience. It also requires the support and understanding of the fans in the stands and the boardroom.

Three managers before him - Micky Adams, Peter Taylor and Steve Coppell - were driven away by the intolerable wait for a stadium worthy of Championship and possibly Premiership, football, which is bleeding the club dry.

McGhee has been prepared to work within the restrictions, to do the best job he can in trying circumstances. Such loyalty deserves a degree of loyalty in return.

Of course, he has made mistakes - what manager doesn't? A blame culture is inevitable when a team gets relegated but changing the manager now would be a knee-jerk reaction, change for change's sake.

What then? A search would begin for somebody with the experience and track record to lift Albion back up from League One next season.

Somebody perhaps who both played and managed at the highest level and has won promotion from League One for three different clubs.

Funny that. His name is Mark McGhee.
 








bhaexpress

New member
Jul 7, 2003
27,627
Kent
Dougal said:
yes should stay , but the argus have it wrong. we could of easily survived this year

A highly subjective opinion somewhat weakened by the word 'easily'.
 






the Realist

New member
Feb 5, 2006
176
Re: Re: How to ruin some people's day

Lord Bracknell said:
When I read that piece out loud, it came out in a Scottish accent.


Absolutely

Naylor is McGhee's puppet - in effect he writes anything and eveything the manager tells him to. (They drink together, socialise together, play golf together, you could say that they are the best of pals)

I think we can take this as McGhee getting wind that his neck might be on the block and trying to sway public opinion ahead of the axe coming down


McGhee :wave:
 
Last edited:


CHAPPERS

DISCO SPENG
Jul 5, 2003
45,009
''McGhee has been prepared to work within the restrictions, to do the best job he can in trying circumstances. Such loyalty deserves a degree of loyalty in return. ''


Loyalty does not win football matches.
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here