Mark McGhee - In or Out?

[Yorkie]

But seriously, who could do a worse job?

Bob Booker, who would take over if MM was sacked today.

It would take approx 3 weeks to appoint a new manager and who's to say he can do any better (whoever he is)

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Another reason why the whole coaching staff should be cleared out, with the exception of Hinsh and Wilkins.

 

[Yorkie]

Another reason why the whole coaching staff should be cleared out, with the exception of Hinsh and Wilkins.

Hinsh. Mmmmm Now what did everyone say about him?

 

[Rougvie]

It would take approx 3 weeks to appoint a new manager and who's to say he can do any better (whoever he is)

Just by lifting the GLOOM over a club with an underacheiving manager can often turn things round in the short term.

I often think as well that we seem to overlook what potential we actually have, who's to say that Butters or Dodd wouldnt make good managers ?

The McGhee 'in' followers seem to be the ones who are more negative about the potential we have than the McGhee outers.

 

[Yorkie]

Just by lifting the GLOOM over a club with an underacheiving manager can often turn things round in the short term.

I often think as well that we seem to overlook what potential we actually have, who's to say that Butters or Dodd wouldnt make good managers ?

The McGhee 'in' followers seem to be the ones who are more negative about the potential we have than the McGhee outers.

I think Butters would make an excellent manager but he's got to get his coaching badges first.

 

[Barrel of Fun]

Another reason why the whole coaching staff should be cleared out, with the exception of Hinsh and Wilkins.

They did a pretty good job getting us up here, and staying here. The division never gets easier. It can get harder! Other teams strengthen with a superior budget. Leeds/Ipswich etc. The teams that come down from the Premiership are generally just as strong as the ones that get promoted.

 

[bellsize seagull]

no one can change anyhing now so lets see if he can dig us out otherwise i think it may be time to go...holloway in

 

[Yorkie]

no one can change anyhing now so lets see if he can dig us out otherwise i think it may be time to go...holloway in

Funnily enough on the football frenzy website there are a couple of QPR fans who are glad to get rid of him for constantly changing the team and playing players out of position.....

 

[Lammy]

Sack him. The season is now over. Let's get the new man in ASAP so that he can find his best team now rather than wait for pre-season. Some thing which McGhee is still yet to find!

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

Funnily enough on the football frenzy website there are a couple of QPR fans who are glad to get rid of him for constantly changing the team and playing players out of position.....

At least they are safe from relegation. QPR PLAYER for PLAYER are Really no better than ourselves.

But the have a decent work ethic and up until recently a decent coach who can motivate and inspire players.

 

[sully]

I'm sure that the Millwall supporters are now glad that McGhee was sacked from their club. After all, they've done so much better since he left, haven't they.


I really think McGhee is a good manager, but has struggled to get a team together that can play well for 90 minutes this year. At times we have seen some excellent football, but the inexperience throughout the squad is found out time and again and there's not a great deal McGhee can do about that in the short term. At least all our youngsters are gaining valuable experience at this level which will hopefully serve them well in the future.

I'm still firmly in the "IN" camp, and think that next season will see a marked improvement in performances, whatever division we find ourselves competing in.

I do accept that some of McGhee's decisions do seem to be odd at times, but I think it's often due to the limited options available to him.

 

[Woodchip]

 

[Yorkie]

I'm sure that the Millwall supporters are now glad that McGhee was sacked from their club. After all, they've done so much better since he left, haven't they.

It was mutual agreement but I agree with the rest of your post.

 

[Barnet Seagull]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Mark McGhee - In or Out?

Whose job is it to inspire the players ?
The Coaching Staff - The fans - The Manager

Whose job is it to instruct the players ?
The Coaching Staff - The Manger

Whose job is it to train the players ?
The Coaching Staff - The Manager

Whose job is it to bring the best out of players ?
The Coaching Staff - The Manager

Whose job is it to select the players to play ?
The Coaching Staff - The Manager

We all know the answers to the above.

Here's the questions in reverse - it's not as clear cut

Do the players lack insipration? - IMO, no.
Are the players given poor instructions? - IMO, no.
Are the players training effectively? IMO, yes.
Are the players motivated and performing to the best of their ability? IMO, no - but it's difficult to get motivate when you've forgotten how to win games.
Are the right players being selected? IMO, given the strength of the squad, pretty much Yes.

 

[n1 gull]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Mark McGhee - In or Out?

Whose job is it to inspire the players ?
The Coaching Staff - The fans - The Manager

Whose job is it to instruct the players ?
The Coaching Staff - The Manger

Whose job is it to train the players ?
The Coaching Staff - The Manager

Whose job is it to bring the best out of players ?
The Coaching Staff - The Manager

Whose job is it to select the players to play ?
The Coaching Staff - The Manager

We all know the answers to the above.

Here's the questions in reverse - it's not as clear cut

Do the players lack insipration? - IMO, no.
Are the players given poor instructions? - IMO, no.
Are the players training effectively? IMO, yes.
Are the players motivated and performing to the best of their ability? IMO, no - but it's difficult to get motivate when you've forgotten how to win games.
Are the right players being selected? IMO, given the strength of the squad, pretty much Yes.

One point I think you've missed out is, who's job is it to bring new players in, to get the best team?

Chairman - Manager.

Have they done the above well? imo NO.

McCammon, Turienzo, CKR, no left back all season and a weak midfield.

 

[Deleted member 2719]

I have never wanted a manager to be sacked as much as MM - he must be sacked now so we can build some confidence for next season.

Mark Mc gee please leave us now.

 

[Dick Knights Mumm]

What Barnet said.

 

[Barnet Seagull]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Mark McGhee - In or Out?

One point I think you've missed out is, who's job is it to bring new players in, to get the best team?

Chairman - Manager.

Have they done the above well? imo NO.

McCammon, Turienzo, CKR, no left back all season and a weak midfield.

Agreed

To give em' their dues, they've tried. But imo No

 

[vulture]

How much longer can the lardo jock clown hold on.
Mcghee out