Agreed. We went there for a birthday in October. VERY average food, overpriced and the place looks a bit like it's been furnished from an Ikea catalogue. The Jack and Jill at Clayton is also a complete rip-off.Ate at the Shepherd & Dog in Jan and it really was a disappointment. Food took a long time (on a not too crowded week day) and was seriously average. Really felt like we'd been done. Not one I'd walk to. I hear that the Royal Oak has come up a bit over the years (access from the bottom end of the Dyke).
I always quite liked the Frankland Arms at Washington but we were there the other week (having walked from Cissbury to Chanctonbury) and it had slipped a bit.
The sandwiches option is a good one, but then you do have to lug them with you unless you do a circular walk or get someone to meet you at the other end.