If Cardiff offered £1.5m for Noone, would you?

[B.W.]

we r struggling to sign the player/s we want already...bit simplistic to think he can be replaced just like that

This...

 

[cloud]

He has flashes of genius but does give the ball away quite easily. Also he seems to get a bit star-struck in the bigger names, though that's quite endearing.

 

[LamieRobertson]

He is a good player, but his end product was shocking last night... if Cardiff were scouting him last night, then their bid would be more like £1.50 than £.5M!

but then i'd hope no one judged a player on just the one performance be it good or bad

 

[Worthingite]

No, I think he's worth more to us in terms of having a player that genuinely loves being here, and loves the fans. He's still young too, and on his day is certainly capable of stepping up a level.

 

[Gritt23]

No, I wouldn't take it.

Truth is, we have a couple of slightly injury-prone wingers in Buckley and KLL, and I think playing with some genuine width is an important part of our game.

Everyone makes it sound so easy to "go out and get a replacement" despite all the evidence to the contrary. Noone offers us plenty, and while some of his crossing was wayward last night, a lot of the time, I couldn't see the man he was supposed to be picking out. Are we really saying the gameplan is to put it on Vicente's head? When he did put it into a good area, we simply diudn't have anyone there.

 

[One Love]

disagree..he hasnt been the same since he picked up an injury

Yes wingers are very fragile. We've got 3 of them like that.

 

[tottenhamseagull]

No, its a squad game, keep him, work on his final ball. He'll get better.

 

[Marshy]

ABSOLUTELY NOT !

people need to get a grip on here.

Noone is very much up to quality, we need 3 wingers, One or two are always injured for starters !

He had a poor game last night, bloody hell, lets bin the lot of them then shall we.. madness on here at times

 

[Paris]

Noone will turn it round.

Keep le faith.

 

[marshy68]

There is a touch of the Wright-Phillips about him. He can probably beat anyone but his delivery is poor. His best cross was when he looked like putting it in the air and then cut it back along the ground, totally foxing the defenders.

If you were TB/GP now would you take £1.5m or even £500k?

they did and we didnt - HUGE mistake.

 

[El Presidente]

So do we base the value of players now on JUST the last game they play?

Well, this is NSC!

 

[marshy68]

No, I think he's worth more to us in terms of having a player that genuinely loves being here, and loves the fans. He's still young too, and on his day is certainly capable of stepping up a level.

I would love to play for the albion and i would love the fans - can i have contract please?

 

[Quagmire]

100% yes.

 

[somerset]

he seems to b the one peeps r picking on ...as i hav sed everyone seems to lik a scapegoat ...whilst his crossing was poor i didnt see much happening in the box ..no one making any runs etc and we know thers almost zero chance someone is going to score with there head

Noooooo, don't say that, someone might think you are suggesting AB has some sort of football deficiency...... tricky topic that.

 

[dragonred]

a winger that cannot cross a ball to save his life and who can dribble around 3 players and then completely fail to do anything with it that's positive after that? Defenders know it, he doesn't scare them one iota....That's pretty much what he did almost all of last year in every game he played in and so its hardly a surprise stays this year the same. I've no idea what his play looks like from side on but from behind the goal it was the above every time and the groans every time he failed to have an end product said it all.... nice guy, just not good enough for this league or above and £500+ would be great business.

 

[JBizzleBeard]

Yep I would be happy to let him go for that.

 

[PILTDOWN MAN]

Noone will turn it round.

.

Maybe but will he cross it?

 

[Icy Gull]

I haven't read the thread, suffice it to say nobody will be offering 1.5 million

 

[HastingsSeagull]

1.5M yes of course. Anything less than 1 they could get stuffed. He's our back-up sure but LuaLua and Buckley are injury prone so he's an important player. Couldn't just go out and find a free transfer as good as him could we! Also he's a good lad, happy in that role, play both sides, and will only get better with his age.

 

[kevtherev]

I'd take £1.50p after last nights performance. A winger who can't cross the ball is about as much good as a nymphomaniac at a monastery.