If Cardiff offered £1.5m for Noone, would you?

[Poppett63]

There is a touch of the Wright-Phillips about him. He can probably beat anyone but his delivery is poor. His best cross was when he looked like putting it in the air and then cut it back along the ground, totally foxing the defenders.

If you were TB/GP now would you take £1.5m or even £500k?

 

[junior]

Hell yeah!

 

[HawkTheSeagull]

If £1 Million or more ? yes. - Less than that ? Probably not.

 

[Deleted member 18477]

1 million+... yes!

 

[peterward]

we all know how good Noone can be at this level, he was on fire start of last season, the club should be doing all they can to get him back to that level he is capable of

 

[Bra]

yes absolutely. would be better taking the money and using elsewhere on the team

 

[NickBHAFC18]

we all know how good Noone can be at this level, he was on fire start of last season, the club should be doing all they can to get him back to that level he is capable of

I agree and would love to see this,

but

1.5 Million is a lot, and I love Noone, probably one of the my favourite players for the Albion but even then I would probably take it.

 

[ditchy]

He needs to be worked on to improve his final ball .. Was similar to Steve Penny i think but with more pace.

 

[LamieRobertson]

yes absolutely. would be better taking the money and using elsewhere on the team

we r struggling to sign the player/s we want already...bit simplistic to think he can be replaced just like that

 

[LamieRobertson]

we all know how good Noone can be at this level, he was on fire start of last season, the club should be doing all they can to get him back to that level he is capable of

yep...and Noone will know that he hasnt delivered

 

[Janbha]

no , he is a game changer , yes he needs to work on his final ball and i would imagine he knows it more than anyone , the hard facts are if he had of got a few more of his crosses in good areas last night there were no bodies in those areas to hit in any case .

 

[Biscuit]

No chance.

One poor(ish) game in a cup tie, before the season has started doesn't make him a bad player. Let's remember this is the same player that was unbelievable against Chelsea. He'll get into his stride and find some form this season, and coming off the bench for Buckley he'll be vital for us this season.

 

[CHAPPERS]

I'd take 500k.

 

[Hillian1]

So do we base the value of players now on JUST the last game they play?

 

[Blackadder]

Anything over £750K and I would be happy for him to discuss terms.

 

[HawkTheSeagull]

To those saying its based on 1 game - it isnt.

He hasnt really been the same since Liverpool home game last season.

 

[B.W.]

He is a good player, but his end product was shocking last night... if Cardiff were scouting him last night, then their bid would be more like £1.50 than £.5M!

 

[LamieRobertson]

So do we base the value of players now on JUST the last game they play?

he seems to b the one peeps r picking on ...as i hav sed everyone seems to lik a scapegoat ...whilst his crossing was poor i didnt see much happening in the box ..no one making any runs etc and we know thers almost zero chance someone is going to score with there head

 

[Trigger]

I'd take 500k.

This, a winger with no end product can't justify much more... We really missed the boat when they offered last time.

 

[LamieRobertson]

To those saying its based on 1 game - it isnt.

He hasnt really been the same since Liverpool home game last season.

disagree..he hasnt been the same since he picked up an injury