Hudders v Sheff Wed

[Arthur]

Calderon's was two footed. Kilbane's wasn't

Was it?

 

[mcshane in the 79th]

It was a dangerous lunge, and therefore a red.

Disagree. Yellow card was spot on. If everyone who complained about Calderon's red card saw one of our players get a red for that they'd explode in a rage.

 

[klaaturberada]

A draw, but with Weds conceding more, to damage their goal difference.

LOLtastic post of the day - surely?

 

[mcshane in the 79th]

Was it?

A photo of him after he has landed, pointless

 

[JBizzleBeard]

Are we doing this again? Fo real? Shiiiiiiiiiiii...................

 

[jezzer]

A photo of him after he has landed, pointless

Rubbish, Calde got the ball, he approached the player with a too-footed launch but corrected himself and put his left leg on the floor just before he connected, as is clearly shown in the photograph, go on the bbc website and watch it again and it quite clearly shows that, it was not two footed, it was debatable it was a foul as calde`s reaction shows when the ref blows up then when the red card comes out he`s apoplectic and rightly so, 3 match ban for this is a joke, we should have appealed. Excellent photograph by the way.

 

[Brian Fantana]

Was it?

He went in with two feet for sure, maybe only one made contact with the player?

You can see from the photo that both feet are pretty much off the ground. If you go into a tackle like that you are going to get a red card. No complaints.

 

[Arthur]

A photo of him after he has landed, pointless

But his other foot is no where near the ball so how can it be a two footed challenge??

 

[sydney]

referee looks a bit wet.......killbane could easily have gone, top strike by pilkington........still hoping for an all in which could well happen if the ref keeps turning a blind eye ie....keeper taking out mellor,purse taking out keeper

 

[JBizzleBeard]

Maybe just agree to disagree people, the second half is a coming.

 

[deletebeepbeepbeep]

Lets not go into this again, gawd.

 

[Tricky Dicky]

Rubbish, Calde got the ball, he approached the player with a too-footed launch but corrected himself and put his left leg on the floor just before he connected, as is clearly shown in the photograph, go on the bbc website and watch it again and it quite clearly shows that, it was not two footed, it was debatable it was a foul as calde`s reaction shows when the ref blows up then when the red card comes out he`s apoplectic and rightly so, 3 match ban for this is a joke, we should have appealed. Excellent photograph by the way.

Two-footed, dangerous, red card, end of. Name one player that isn't "surprised" when they get shown a red. Move on - it's gone, doesn't matter any more.

 

[mcshane in the 79th]

Why didn't we appeal it then?

 

[mcshane in the 79th]

Maybe just agree to disagree people, the second half is a coming.

Can't predict this one, could go either way

 

[deletebeepbeepbeep]

I'm gonna go with 2 nil Huddersfield.

 

[Arthur]

Why didn't we appeal it then?

Because it was a sending off!?!

 

[Brian Fantana]

Because it was a sending off!?!

I thought you were arguing that it wasn't a sending off.

 

[deletebeepbeepbeep]

Great finish, great decision.

 

[bhamex1901]

Disallowed goal for offside from Sheffield Wednesday. Looks like they may get back into this

 

[Arthur]

I thought you were arguing that it wasn't a sending off.

Where did I say that?

I said the tackle in the first half was as bad if not worse than Calderon's and that I thought the ref bottled the decision.