Half fit chippie or oatway?

[Kinky Gerbil]

On sat what would you rather have?

i still think a half fit chippie would be a beter option

 

[Uncle Buck]

Most definetly.

 

[Soton Seagull]

No contest. Put a leg brace on Chippy and make him play!

 

[Marc]

yeah thats right, play chippie and make his injury worse meaning he's out longer

Oatway for me, should never play half-fit players IMO

 

[Marshy]

Anyone not 100% shouldnt play.
So easy decision for me.
Has to be Oatway.

 

[the full harris]

yeah thats right, play chippie and make his injury worse meaning he's out longer

Oatway for me, should never play half-fit players IMO

same as what he said.

 

[saafend_seagull]

id rather have lee and reid in the middle to be honest

 

[Uncle Buck]

Anyone not 100% shouldnt play.
So easy decision for me.
Has to be Oatway.

So a couple of seasons back it was wrong to play a half fit Zamora at Peterborough?

 

[Marshy]

Didnt agree with that either.

 

[Uncle Buck]

Didnt agree with that either.

But he won us the game and the next day due to Reading choking we got promoted.

 

[Vankleek Hill Seagull]

If a players not 100% fit, they really shouldn't be playing. End of.

I think Charlie might do a decent job this time round. He's been in this division before, so he should know what's expected of him.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

If a players not 100% fit, they really shouldn't be playing. End of.

I think Charlie might do a decent job this time round. He's been in this division before, so he should know what's expected of him.

but he had played in div 2 before and he was not very good last year.

i agree with lee and reid in cm

 

[Normandy seagull]

Got to be Oatway, a half-fit chippie might get murdered by the scumbag sidwell

 

[Blackadder]

same as what he said.

ditto!!

Has to be a fit player!!

 

[London Irish]

Oatway is one of our few definite starters, so to all the Oatway knockers, can I just say a big

 

[Uncle Buck]

Oatway is one of our few definite starters, so to all the Oatway knockers, can I just say a big

Fine but he will be one of the weak links in our side and it makes me wonder that people seem blind to this at times.

 

[Trigger]

Charlie is a good tackler and ball winner but as soon as he's done that and has the ball at his feet it usually goes straight back to the other team leaving us back where we were...

 

[London Irish]

Fine but he will be one of the weak links in our side and it makes me wonder that people seem blind to this at times.

He was one of our best players in the play-off final and the only blindness around here is people who cannot understand and appreciate the skills of a destructive, defensive midfielder.

 

[Uncle Buck]

He was one of our best players in the play-off final and the only blindness around here is people who cannot understand and appreciate the skills of a destructive, defensive midfielder.

One game, fine he did well for one game. Other than the Plymouth home game I am struggling for other games where he was decent. He is the weak link in our side, the number of games where Chippy was having to do the work of 2 players was worrying and then people commented that Carpenter was playing poorly, well of course he is going to look poor when he is having to bail his partner out.

Oatway gets stuck in great, but then half the time he tackles the guy and the ball goes to their player anyway or he gets the ball and is caught in possesion.

Both Coppell and Taylor saw he was not good enough and hopefully the current incumbent will soon as well. It is all well and good he will try his hardest but his best is no longer good enough.

 

[berkshire seagull]

Rather have a one legged dog than oatway