Gifton Noel Williams - do you want him here?

[Oscar]

In fact , what the hell, I would prefer McCammon to Gifltess Noel-Edmonds

Then you must be very, very stupid.

 

[Brighton Breezy]

If we can get someone better then no - but not much chance of that so I say keep him if we can.

 

[B.W.]

I don't think he's that great but I can't see us getting anyone better. If he came I wouldn't be to upset.

That just about sums it up... the big worry for me is his arthiritis (sp) in his knees... he was much, much better before his major injury a few year's back...

I vote "Yes"...

 

[Barrel of Fun]

We might well have survived if we had got him earlier. Pulis said that he would be in the premier league, if he did not suffer from an arthritic complaint. He showed that he can slow the game down for us. Hold up the ball and can play some great touches. He would be lethal in league one, I think.

 

[RM-Taylor]

No, try and sign a better striker.

 

[SI 4 BHA]

Would sign him only if on pay as you play basis, can't see him lasting a season with his injury problems so we'll be looking for someone else in a few months.

 

[Pavilionaire]

Tough one to call. He is a journeyman striker and you'd like to think we could attract better but, in reality, we probably can't at this stage.

He's better than McCammon and his record in League 1 is reasonable. We didn't think Iwelumo could do a job in the CCC but he's had a great season in League 1 with Colchester, so if that's any indication you'd probably sign GNW up.

 

[The Auditor]

Shipperley will be availiable...is he better than GNW

 

[Silent Bob]

Shipperley will be availiable...is he better than GNW

Not really no, the only reason I can see why anyone wouldn't want GNW is fitness doubts, but then why would you sign Shipperly? Plus Shipperly is mid 30s, probably only got one season left him in especially at Championship level. IF we were to sign him and go up we'd need half a new team, what with Oatway, Carpenter, and Butters as well.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Shipperley will be availiable...is he better than GNW

Id say so, plus he maybe more interested as it would be a return south.

GNW would be a gamble - you could get 40 games out of him or 4 with his injury history.

 

[Gritt23]

I bet we don't sign a better target man than Noel-Williams this summer.

 

[Basil Fawlty]

Never in a million years thankyou very much

I agree, GNW did nothing to impress me.

 

[y2dave]

Can't believe the negative opinions on GNW. We were a fundamentally flawed team without him and looked a decent side in several of his games, mainly due to the difference his presence made. I can't see any proven strikers better than GNW signing in the summer. I guess the whingers will be happy with another of Magoos one for the future?

 

[B.W.]

Actually, I think Shipperly is a better option... what about that Tom Brighton guy in jock-land?...

 

[London Irish]

GNW would be an excellent signing, we improved instantly with him in the team, as did CKR. I'm guessing we are playing a waiting game at the moment looking at a few other players and banking on GNW's wages being able to be negotiated down to a level we can sustain.

 

[Fred Oliver - Legend]

isnt he really good friends with CKR? it might be a good thing to hopefully keep them both,as we still dont know whos staying and whos going the teamspirt might drop. at least theyd get on with each other and might help to keep the spirit up!

 

[Schrödinger's Toad]

Semi-fence-sitting jobby. He's got the ability, but you can see the effect the injuries have had on him, he can barely run - however, I doubt we can do better, and he's still a decent targetman with a good touch; on balance, I'd take him.

 

[dougdeep]

No, there must be better out there. We've wasted time and cash on lame ducks before.

 

[Hannibal smith]

Some people on here crack me up.

I bet the people saying they dont want GNW are the same who said Chris Iwelumo was shit.

We looked a MUCH better outfit with GNW in the side than without, and at Millwall he was the best player on the pitch.

Reckon hed score for fun in Div 1, the only worry for me is his knees.

Spot on. For anyone that compares McCammon with GNW is obviously blind. He has a better first touch (by a country mile), heading ability, ablility to bring other players into the game and tactical ability that McCammon cant even dream about.

Its like comparing shagging Jo Brand and Cameron Diaz. Irelevant anyway - He will go to Plymouth and didn't want to come here in the first place (an Interview with him said he was all lined up to go to Millwall before it fell through).

 

[London Irish]

Spot on. For anyone that compares McCammon with GNW is obviously blind. He has a better first touch (by a country mile), heading ability, ablility to bring other players into the game and tactical ability that McCammon cant even dream about.

Its like comparing shagging Jo Brand and Cameron Diaz. Irelevant anyway - He will go to Plymouth and didn't want to come here in the first place (an Interview with him said he was all lined up to go to Millwall before it fell through).

The hope here is there is a lot of uncertainty at Plymouth at the mo, will Pulis got back to Stoke?