[Albion] Crowd effect or no crowd effects?

[Beanstalk]

Watching the Albion with - helps make it feel less tense.

Watching anyone else without - Listening to Chris Wilder and Dean Smith have a "BASHY" and "CASHY" shout off is an experience in itself.

 

[Guinness Boy]

I'm a without but I don't mind it with, Madam.

 

[pasty]

With, definitely.

As an aside, some of the stuff going in the stadiums amuses me. Like last night at Deepdale for instance, why were each of the substitutions announced over the stadium tannoy? And I noticed watching highlights of West Ham v Hull, they played goal music after each of West Hams 5 goals. I mean why, just why?

 

[tronnogull]

Depends on the game. Crowd noise on for Albion home games with primarily Albion crowd noise. Crowd noise off for most away games. Especially Southampton or any other ground , like Tottenham, where the crowd noise will be predominantly the ' go marching in ' song which I absolutely cannot stand....especially when it turns into an ear worm.

 

[amexer]

. Cant wait to attend but must say have got used to no crowds and has not detracted from my enjoyment of both league games I have watched

 

[Behind Enemy Lines]

Definitely no crowd. The fake fan noise is a lie: there's no-one there.

 

[Icy Gull]

I initially thought I’d prefer with but after watching the last three games without, I prefer the unplugged offering

 

[LamieRobertson]

I go with effects ..but I’m beginning to be swayed the other way ...hearing Arsenal fans singing is so false

Would add though that on the radio I’d prefer ‘effects’

 

[Gabbafella]

Noises on for me. I find I don't celebrate goals as much when there's no crowd cheering along with me, even if it is a fake crowd.

 

[father_and_son]

Started Project Restart as a With but have become very much a Without now. Finding it quite strange to hear a crowd but see empty stands and it just seems fake (I guess I was just deluding myself before).

 

[Klaas]

I don't mind a bit of ambient background filler crowd noise, but the howls of disbelief for a bad tackle and applause when a player goes off is a bit too much for me Brian.

 

[Invicta]

Started Project Restart as a With but have become very much a Without now. Finding it quite strange to hear a crowd but see empty stands and it just seems fake (I guess I was just deluding myself before).

Same as this. Enjoying the real sound this season

 

[zefarelly]

Agree on the radio point. It's made me realise that I often know what has happened more quickly due to the presence of a crowd.

On radio commentaries without crowd noise, it can take a surprisingly long time for a commentator to actually reveal a goal has been scored!

Chris Kamara ?

 

[Arthritic Toe]

I love it - mainly when they get it wrong, e.g. when they give us a full-on goal roar when its hit the side netting. Also love the booing when there's a bit of argie bargie.