Choice between re-signing Benno or Noonie

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

From what little I've seen of him since his return, Benno looks a shadow of his former self. Nooney would maybe add a bit of spark and spontaneity and would be interesting to see if he's finally learned to look up when he's on a run. If so, we could be on a WINNAH! So, yeah, clear vote for Nooney.

 

[Albion Robster]

Better end product with Benno.
Better banter and morale with Nooney.

 

[Fourteenth Eye]

Once we had binned the finn we started to see the old Benno come back, particularly at Fulham

#teambenno

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

Benno as 1st choice, but in reality I'd be happy with both.

 

[slartibartfast]

To be honest, I dont want anybody "on loan" really ... get them signed! Im sick of watching 3 Villa players, 1 Norwich player, 1 Liverpool player and 1 Forest player run around in our shirts. Either sign, or feck off. (Plus Bennett was fairly crap this time round, so if I had to choose Id go for Noone)

 

[theyellowdinosaur]

Noone edges it because of his karaoke display

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Noone edges it because of his karaoke display

He could also fix that light on the roof of the North Stand that blew out on Boxing Day

 

[Icy Gull]

I think that's correct. Additionally, Benno has not really looked like the same player that we once had in his performances back here. Granted, he's feeling his way back from a long-term injury, we play a different system and brand of football to when he was here last time and morale wasn't really there.

Strangely he looked our best player by some distance in the first half against Wigan, his first game for us. Went downhill from there, I'm blaming Hyypia and his ridiculous tactics, I'm sure Hughton could get the best out of him

Can I be greedy and say I'd like both Elliott and Nooney?

 

[kip]

Head says Bennett, heart says Nooney. So didn't vote