Publius Ovidius
Well-known member
Sorry, can someone enlighten me as to why GUY BUTTERS WAS SHIT?
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Brighton v Blackpool (Player Ratings)
- Thread starter Trigger
- Start date
Behind Enemy Lines
Well-known member
Kuipers 3
Whing 4
Butters 3
El-Abd 0
Lynch 3
Mayo 1
Carpenter 1.
Hammond 1
Cox 5
Revell 5
Williams 2
Cox and Revell only players who deserved to wear the shirts. Other than that they were all abject.
Whing 4
Butters 3
El-Abd 0
Lynch 3
Mayo 1
Carpenter 1.
Hammond 1
Cox 5
Revell 5
Williams 2
Cox and Revell only players who deserved to wear the shirts. Other than that they were all abject.
The Large One
Who's Next?
Because he was not utter shit yesterday, yet some people find it hard to come to terms with that.Lokki 7 said:
No, I don't agree with them, it's they who agree with me. I was just too slow to post it.Lokki 7 said:
Uncle Spielberg
Well-known member
Kuipers 0
El Abd 0
Mayo 0
Lynch 0
Butters 0
Whing 0
Carpenter 0
Hammond 0
Cox 0
Revell 0
Williams 0
El Abd 0
Mayo 0
Lynch 0
Butters 0
Whing 0
Carpenter 0
Hammond 0
Cox 0
Revell 0
Williams 0
The Large One
Who's Next?
I was a critic of Hammond last season, but when Chippy was suspended, I though he played much, much better - especially with what I believe is an inspired decision to made him captain.
I don't want to lump to much on-field blame on to one person, but I do feel Carpenter's time to be put out to pasture has come. He is a hindrance, and at times a liablity whose confidence is running on zero. He may get the confidence back one day, but the legs seem to have gone as well. Great servant, and five Championship medals is a decent return for one career, but for me, enough is enough.
I don't want to lump to much on-field blame on to one person, but I do feel Carpenter's time to be put out to pasture has come. He is a hindrance, and at times a liablity whose confidence is running on zero. He may get the confidence back one day, but the legs seem to have gone as well. Great servant, and five Championship medals is a decent return for one career, but for me, enough is enough.
Publius Ovidius
Well-known member
Uncle Spielberg said:
No nrgatives there then gareth
The Large One
Who's Next?
He wasn't. Not comparatively, anyway.Dave the Gaffer said:
BensGrandad
New member
The Large One said:
I actually agree with you it is very easy to stay just that little bit too long and not know the right time to go.!!!
Publius Ovidius
Well-known member
The Large One said:
thankyou alan
Lokki 7
WSU
The Large One said:
Sorry, of course you are right. What was I thinking?!
The Large One said:No, I don't agree with them, it's they who agree with me. I was just too slow to post it.
Good logic, I like it.
Man of Harveys
Well-known member
Uncle Spielberg said:
0.2 for those ratings
Zesh Rehman
New member
i think Mayo should play in midfield more, he did well against Southampton last year aswell
Scoffers
Well-known member
Kuipers 2
Whing 5
Butters 5
El-Abd 5
Lynch 3
Mayo 3
Carpenter 4.
Hammond 4
Cox 6
Revell 6
Williams 4
Very poor all round I'm afraid. Just didnt gel at all, young heads dont seem to know what to do with the ball, old timers are passed their sell by date.
Whing 5
Butters 5
El-Abd 5
Lynch 3
Mayo 3
Carpenter 4.
Hammond 4
Cox 6
Revell 6
Williams 4
Very poor all round I'm afraid. Just didnt gel at all, young heads dont seem to know what to do with the ball, old timers are passed their sell by date.
pasty
A different kind of pasty
malcolm prescott said:
We would probably have missed it
SULLY COULDNT SHOOT
Loyal2Family+Albion!
Kuipers 1 - at fault for two of the goals (remember ... I know I'm a goalie!)
Whing 3.5 - but couln't expect more as he'd had no time to settle
El Abd - 1 - very poor
Butter 3.5 - short of match fitness and slow but slow not necessarily a prob in this div, did have some passion and won headers
Lynch - 4 - did ok and w emisse dhim in the 2nd half
Hammond - 3 - very dissappointing but that's because Crapenter was playing in his position
Carpenter - 1 - truly awful... just not good enough any more
Mayo - 4 - did ok on a bad day
Revell - 6 - MOM for us. this is the height of his ability though and shoudl eb better used in the centre.
Cox - 5 - out of position and below what I expect from him but was the only other threat apart from Revell.
Williams - 2 - Very poor but why? Because he had no one to knock a ball down to. You can't have a target man like Williams playing on his own! He needs a proper 4-4-2 with another forward right next to him.
As far as I was concerned we only had 7 players on field today.
Whing 3.5 - but couln't expect more as he'd had no time to settle
El Abd - 1 - very poor
Butter 3.5 - short of match fitness and slow but slow not necessarily a prob in this div, did have some passion and won headers
Lynch - 4 - did ok and w emisse dhim in the 2nd half
Hammond - 3 - very dissappointing but that's because Crapenter was playing in his position
Carpenter - 1 - truly awful... just not good enough any more
Mayo - 4 - did ok on a bad day
Revell - 6 - MOM for us. this is the height of his ability though and shoudl eb better used in the centre.
Cox - 5 - out of position and below what I expect from him but was the only other threat apart from Revell.
Williams - 2 - Very poor but why? Because he had no one to knock a ball down to. You can't have a target man like Williams playing on his own! He needs a proper 4-4-2 with another forward right next to him.
As far as I was concerned we only had 7 players on field today.
TSB
Captain Hindsight
seagull4life said:
He made 3 saves.
Tom Bombadil
Well-known member
The Large One said:
He wasn't total shit. What about when he outpaced their attacker in the second half and got the ball back after giving him a 5m headstart. That guy must be a candidate for slowest player in the league,
Deportivo Seagull
I should coco
Mayo was not shit ... well not whilst he was in midfield, when he went to LB he was a bit dodgy.
Whing played well considering he'd only just joined (he must think Adams hate his guts though).
El-Abd - utter crap, at fault against Brenford and against Chesterfield - unbelievably crap.
. Pity as he's better than that, should be at RB
Butters - slow, old but at least he reads the game and tries to bring a bit of confidence. Like to see him and Lynch at CB
Chippy - just not doing it
Hammond - utter crap Why? Can some tell me why he needs three touches, yes that three touches before he can pass. Every time he got the ball the Blackpool manager was telling his defenders where it was going. So predictable that it was depressing. if he's the answer we don't understand the question. Too be fair he and chippy can't be in the same side because both play better when the other is missing.
Revell -
never ever gives up. He'd still be running around the pitch now if he thought we could win.
Williams - no service what's so ever didn't stand a chance
Cox - more composure in front of goal required.
Lynch better at CB.
Only bright point is that Hinsh looked good in midfield, took control until Frutos got sent off. Like to see him play the holding role, looks much better than either Hammond or Chippy
Whing played well considering he'd only just joined (he must think Adams hate his guts though).
El-Abd - utter crap, at fault against Brenford and against Chesterfield - unbelievably crap.
. Pity as he's better than that, should be at RBButters - slow, old but at least he reads the game and tries to bring a bit of confidence. Like to see him and Lynch at CB
Chippy - just not doing it
Hammond - utter crap Why? Can some tell me why he needs three touches, yes that three touches before he can pass. Every time he got the ball the Blackpool manager was telling his defenders where it was going. So predictable that it was depressing. if he's the answer we don't understand the question. Too be fair he and chippy can't be in the same side because both play better when the other is missing.
Revell -
never ever gives up. He'd still be running around the pitch now if he thought we could win.Williams - no service what's so ever didn't stand a chance
Cox - more composure in front of goal required.
Lynch better at CB.
Only bright point is that Hinsh looked good in midfield, took control until Frutos got sent off. Like to see him play the holding role, looks much better than either Hammond or Chippy