birchall and jarret

[alex_brighton]

if we have only signed birchall jarret and carole to the end of the season,
based on the performances we have seen so far would you give them new contracts?

 

[BIRCHYBOY27]

Birchall yes, not sure about other two yet, depends what league we are in i suppose.

 

[buller89]

Yes, 2 year deal each. Whether they would want them with us in this position is another matter

 

[blue and white army]

They'll only get contracts if we stay up simple as that

 

[chalkmycue]

Carole Defintly!!
Birchall Yes. Although i think he is looking heavy at the moment.
Jarrett Jurys out??

The problem with short contracts is if they dont work out your not stuck long term with a player you dont want, if they work out they will just go on a freebie to a better team which i beleive will happen with Carole.

 

[SirDouglasLoft]

Carole yes.

Other two, so far, no way!

 

[bright1064]

Birchall - Yes

Carole - Yes

Jarrett - No

 

[Richy_Seagull]

what? have any of you seen these players?! Jarrett was far and away the best albion player against carlisle, and has impressed in most other games. He would be my definite out of the three.

 

[buller89]

Jarrett is the best of the 3

 

[bright1064]

In most of the games I've seen him play, Jarrett has been anonymous.

 

[Da Man Clay]

Yes for all 3. The three best midfielders we currently own. Comfortably.

 

[drew]

What exactly do people see in Carole. He does some fancy footwork on the wing but his end product is, to say the least, unproductive. He might look good at times but apart from his first time cross in his first game, nothing has come of it. On Saturday, he should have scored against Carlisle with just the keeper to beat but instead only hits the bar. He cannot track back and defend. He doesn't even fall into the category of a luxury we can't afford!!!!!

 

[strings]

Birchall and Jarret - yes.
Carloe still needs to work on his final product, but I would still sign him.

 

[bright1064]

I actually think Carole is very creative on the ball, and not just with his fancy footwork. He can pick some wonderful passes, and is more creative than Cox.

 

[Uncle Buck]

How very Brighton, in Jarret we finally have a midfielder who has a bit of height, can get stuck in and probably can play from box to box.

So what do the fans do, write him off as not good enough...

 

[bright1064]

How very Brighton, in Jarret we finally have a midfielder who has a bit of height, can get stuck in and probably can play from box to box.

He may well be able to do that, but I certainly haven't seen much of it yet!

 

[Richy_Seagull]

How very Brighton, in Jarret we finally have a midfielder who has a bit of height, can get stuck in and probably can play from box to box.

So what do the fans do, write him off as not good enough...

The best midfield player in terms of retaining the ball I have seen for some time in a Brighton shirt. Definitely get him signed up long term.

 

[Russell Slade's hat]

Yes all 3 of them, they have all shown good signs although Birchill has till got something to give

 

[Sheebo]

In most of the games I've seen him play, Jarrett has been anonymous.

Anonymous? He seems like the best centre midfielder we've got by MILES. The 2 times i've seen him he's looked quality and DEF one to keep - he just needs a new partner in the middle. Very tiday midfielder yet more creative than say Thompson...