Bertin better than Carole

[NS Herald]

I know it's only been a few games but so far I think Bertin has been better than Carole and will be a more valuable asset.

Carole looked good but tended to over elaborate whereas Bertin really does the business. He has excellent technical ability, his work rate is great and he has really added something to the midfiled

As Hawsey said last night "he makes space where there isn't any". I think the bloke oozes quality

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

Dunno really coz Carole was a winger and this Bertin bloke is centre midfield??

 

[Uncle Buck]

Dunno really coz Carole was a winger and this Bertin bloke is centre midfield??

Now lets not get picky on things like players roles and best positions, it never stopped McGhee....

 

[dylan_bha]

Completely different players, Carole = FLAIRE, Bertin = Quality!!

 

[logan89]

we've only got him till the end of the season though, we should start by offering him a new deal, and soon.

 

[empire]

bertin is quality,think wards overrated at the moment,last 2 games imo,he has given the ball away too cheaply,and wants far too much time on the ball,hope he comes good

 

[Icy Gull]

I see Carole has had any easytime of it at Leeds this year with 3 full appearances (sub 9 times) and 1 cup appearance. It is however unbelievably his 2nd highest games total in 1st team football in his career, the highest being with us with 34 games.

Comparing him to Bertin is hard, totally different types of player, I'd be more inclined to compare him to Ward

Carole stats

 

[vulture]

In my view Seb was very over-rated.Maybe due to the fact he was playing in a very poor side.

 

[Silent Bob]

I see Carole has had any easytime of it at Leeds this year with 3 full appearances (sub 9 times) and 1 cup appearance. It is however unbelievably his 2nd highest games total in 1st team football in his career, the highest being with us with 34 games.

Comparing him to Bertin is hard, totally different types of player, I'd be more inclined to compare him to Ward

Carole stats

Sign him up.

 

[TSB]

Completely different players, Carole = FLAIRE, Bertin = Quality!!

I think you'll find that Carole = ZERO end product

 

[Ernest]

A one legged ant would be better than Carole

 

[Blue&WhiteSea]

Surely we should be comparing to nicolas not carole?

 

[NS Herald]

Surely we should be comparing to nicolas not carole?

The comparison is based purely on them being French midfielders.

I know they are different types of player but Carole always seemed to want to do too much whereas Bertin does what is needed.

If I had a choice of one of them I know which I would choose

 

[Icy Gull]

I think you'll find that Carole = ZERO end product

Would have been good if he'd had a forward who knew where the goal was to cross to though.

 

[cjd]

I think you'll find that Carole = ZERO end product

Agreed....could run circles around his ankles all day....but couldn,t cross a ball to save his life.

 

[trueblue]

Bertin is the future of our midfield.

Although, knowing us, we won't sign him and he'll be the future of someone else's midfield instead...

 

[Bakesy]

Agreed....could run circles around his ankles all day....but couldn,t cross a ball to save his life.

He did manage ONE good cross.




HAPPY DAYS...............

 

[Man of Harveys]

I think it's about time we STOPPED going on about how good Bertin is.

He is SHIT. He'd be USELESS for any other club. Anybody else's scouts reading this should take my word for it: he's RUBBISH.

 

[balloonboy]

Bertin is the future of our midfield.

Although, knowing us, we won't sign him and he'll be the future of someone else's midfield instead...

We HAVE signed him (til the end of the season).