Ashley "Marmite" Barnes - In or Out ??

[HawkTheSeagull]

Everyones favourite player comes back from suspension on Saturday, but after tonights impressive performance - do you think if deserves his usual starting position ?

Simple In or Out question !!

 

[TheBigUnit]

Debatable, Orlandi and Spanish Dave definitely do!

 

[Seagull27]

Massive fan of Ash, but like any player he should have to work his way back in the team after today's performance, assuming no injuries. Definitely on the bench though.

 

[ees complicated no?]

Up front with Ulloa for me.

 

[portslade seagull]

If Hammond is injured he will be back

 

[yxee]

Really liked him alongside Ulloa, rest Buckley for a game.

 

[Acker79]

Bridcutt suspended, hammond possibly out injured. Hoskins out. CMS might not be fit. Barnes and Ulloa paired well v Arsenal. I don't think it's quite so easy to leave him out as some seem to think judging by the other bumped thread. Gus may not have a lot of options. Unless CMS is back and/or hammond is fit, I'd say barnes not starting would be more surprising, perhaps something to be read into.

 

[DumLum]

I was over the moon with a three match ban. 7 points in 3 games!

 

[moggy]

Out.....and stay out

 

[Seagull1989]

We have a squad for a reason! Barnes in for buckley and have Buckley come
On as an impact sub.

 

[Deleted member 2719]

No question......In.

He is the sort of player that will improve immensely.

 

[catfish]

In....and stay in.

 

[somerset]

Out out effin out

 

[Rookie]

Depends how Lopez/Orlandi/Buckley feel after tonight. Also got Vicente to come in as well

 

[HawkTheSeagull]

I want him out as we havent played too badly without him - but i want to see him up front with Ulloa.

Ill put out, but we should certainly have him on the bench.

 

[Snarkey5]

sell him! he's just a powerful league 1 player at best!

 

[Worthai Seagull]

Bridcutt suspended, hammond possibly out injured. Hoskins out. CMS might not be fit. Barnes and Ulloa paired well v Arsenal. I don't think it's quite so easy to leave him out as some seem to think judging by the other bumped thread. Gus may not have a lot of options. Unless CMS is back and/or hammond is fit, I'd say barnes not starting would be more surprising, perhaps something to be read into.

Hold on....why are you reading into something that hasnt evened happened re Barnes? The guy has been suspended for 3 matches . He may or may not start on Saturday. What is there to read into. Honestly....some of the posts here are just such drivel !

 

[somerset]

I was over the moon with a three match ban. 7 points in 3 games!

This is an irrefutable fact........ The Barnes camp will still make some tosh up to make the case for his inclusion in place of one of our match winning team.

 

[HawkTheSeagull]

You can see why he is marmite at present - a near 50/50 split !!

 

[Acker79]

Hold on....why are you reading into something that hasnt evened happened re Barnes? The guy has been suspended for 3 matches . He may or may not start on Saturday. What is there to read into. Honestly....some of the posts here are just such drivel !

Huh? I'm saying if, in the circumstances listed above (i.e. if cms was out, hammond was out, bridcutt was out and hoskins out), barnes wasn't to start, perhaps there could be something more to read into it (for example - extra punishment for getting sent off). A quite reasonable thing to suggest, I think.