Andy Whing

[smudge]

Played a blinder tonight I thought. That is all.

 

[Beach Hut]

Yes he looked quality - hopefully we can sign him up permanently or at least a loan to the end of the season.

 

[Zesh Rehman]

my mate slagged him off all night, but i thought he was mostly good.

 

[Ernest]

I thought he was crap

 

[Beach Hut]

I thought he was crap

Nothing new there then

 

[Icy Gull]

I thought he was crap

Your judgment is as good as your awareness of what time kick of was

 

[gwpdylan]

can i just say that on first viewing of the guy i was impressed in a lot of his play (given it took a while for me to work out who was who after so long). only thing i would question at times was his distribution down the line when not unduly pressured. wether it was more about the forward runs of others i dont know but certainly in first half the ball appeared to end up in no mans land. overall though i thought he looked good. perhaps after my first live game in many years i ought keep quiet but hey, its all subjective. great night for me and loved it all

 

[B.W.]

He has made a fantastic contribution to our team this year, especially in terms of his fully-committed defending... would love for us to sign him on a perm...

 

[The Oldman]

He was elbowed in the face early on in the match, right on the spot where he had that awful injury a few weeks ago. The Ref did not see it neither did most of the crowd. You could see the bench were very concerned as he was really struggling for about 10 minutes but still made a couple of decisive takles.

Top bloke and will get better if we can keep him.

 

[fatboy]

Signing in January.

 

[Zesh Rehman]

Signing in January.

lets hope

 

[Ernest]

Signing in January.

Gain Whinge and lose Cox , Revell and Lynch .

That is sure going to get the crowds on the increase

 

[goldstone]

And as in the Millwall game he looked even better when he moved to central defence ... is he a cente back in disguise?

 

[Sav]

Yes he looked quality - hopefully we can sign him up permanently or at least a loan to the end of the season.

Yup, He's not a very good player IMO. Never looks for an easy ball and just does the long ball down the line everytime where we never win them over the top. His control isn't that good either tbh, and even in the Warm up last night he was slicing them everywhere.

 

[bristolseagull]

But he's ginger.


i think we have our required quota of red heads.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

Yup, He's not a very good player IMO. Never looks for an easy ball and just does the long ball down the line everytime where we never win them over the top. His control isn't that good either tbh, and even in the Warm up last night he was slicing them everywhere.

Clearly, you have no idea what a good player is.

 

[Sav]

Clearly, you have no idea what a good player is.

LOL are you that kid we was callin Harry Potter?, Mate I was standin with Sam last night at the Game next to you...

And you're tryna tell me I have no idea, Lmao...

 

[Zesh Rehman]

FIGHT FIGHT FIGHT

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

LOL are you that kid we was callin Harry Potter?, Mate I was standin with Sam last night at the Game next to you...

And you're tryna tell me I have no idea, Lmao...

I am well aware. And your constant criticism of Whing last night pissed me off, as you were actually being deadly serious.

Without Whing, we are forced to play El-Abd at right back. He's not half the player there as he is at centre back. Other than that, our cover is Hart, who is an attacking player.

Whing is apparently 'not very good' because he is capable of playing a low bending pass down the line that doesn't always reach one of our forwards. Well, that might be something to do with the fact that we aren't playing a proper right winger, and instead have Cox who plays inside. His plan 'b', if you like, seems to be to hoof it, which all of our defenders do under pressure.

What's wrong with that?

 

[Caveman]

I think Whing is a cracking player and we should definately sign him if we are able to.