Your best side of the Withdean era

[Whitterz]

No.

he was FLAIR

 

[vulture]

roberts
virgo
mcnaulty
cullip
morgan
hart
chippy
oatway
brooker
zamora
forster
subs
elphick
watson
murrary
dicker
kuipers

 

[Simon Morgan]

-----------------Kuipers-------------------
--Watson---Cullip---Ingimarsson---Mayo---
--Currie-----Sidwell--Rodger-----Brooker---
------------Zamora----Knight--------------

Subs : Roberts, Butters, Carpenter, Hart, Forster

 

[Skaville]

I completely forgot about McShane. Butters, Cullip, Virgo, Morgan, Ingimarsson, Hinshelwood, Elphick, Lynch and McShane. What a great bunch of centre halves

 

[beorhthelm]

in 3-5-2 formation

kuipers
mcshane
cullip
elphick
hart
reid
carpenter
sidwell
lynch
forster
zamora

yes, Lynch in the wide left midfield/wingback role. Reid gets the nod for what he could/should have done had injury not been so cruel.

 

[Braders]

FDM


Watto
Cullip
Butters
Whingy



Currie
Sidwell
Oatway
Coxy

Knight
Zamora

Subs ( 7)
Sully
McShane
Elphick
Jones
Jakey
Ingi
Harty
Manager : Micky Adams (first time round)

 

[dougdeep]

Zamora and Knight would have been crap together.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

FDM


Watto
Cullip
Butters
Whingy



Currie
Sidwell
Oatway
Coxy

Knight
Zamora

Subs ( 7)
Sully
McShane
Elphick
Jones
Jakey
Ingi
Harty
Manager : Micky Adams (first time round)

You don't SERIOUSLY think that Sullivan is better than Roberts, and Robinson was better than Brooker, surely?

 

[Cpt. Spavil]

Roberts

Watson Cullip Elphick Mcnulty

Hart Hammond Oatway Cox

Zamora Forster

Subs
FDM
Whing
Virgo
Knight
Murray
Loft
Butters

Manager
Russell Slade

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Michel Kuipers
Paul Watson
Danny Cullip
Andy Crosby
Nathan Jones
Paul Brooker
Paul Rogers
Richard Carpenter
Junior Lewis
Bobby Zamora
Glenn Murray

Subs;
Mark Cartwright, Simon Morgan, Gary Hart, Leon Knight, Charlie Oatway.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

Cartwright over Roberts?! Some people amaze me!!

 

[seagullsdaz]

Kuipers

Whing Cullip McShane Harding

Brooker Sidwell Hammond Cox

Zamora Forster

Roberts
Ingimarsson
Carpenter
Kazim Richards
Knight

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Cartwright over Roberts?! Some people amaze me!!

I f***ing loved Cartwright, obviously Roberts was the better keeper.

 

[Without Limits]

Zamora and Knight would have been crap together.

Little and large. Zamora seems to be a team player more and more now and we all know Knight had pace and could finish them off from some hard work by somebody else.


Kuipers
Watson Cullip Virgo Mayo
Hart Carpenter Rogers Brooker
Zamora Knight

Roberts
Wing
Jones
Oatway
Forster
Morgan
Carole

 

[Braders]

You don't SERIOUSLY think that Sullivan is better than Roberts, and Robinson was better than Brooker, surely?

to be honest with you , probably not - both Roberts and Henderson are stronger possibilities then Sully , granted and the Brooker / Robinson , yeah

kind've got lazy when it came to subs I guess..

 

[bigc]

This list makes me realise, we've only really had two proper right backs during our time at Withdean!

Watson and Whing. Inbetween them(nearly 4 years!) we had a collection of stand in's from other positions like Reid and Hart. I wonder if RB was our least covered position in the last 10 years.

 

[desprateseagull]

pugh
pugh
barley
mcgrew
etc

 

[Brighton Breezy]

GK Roberts

RB Whing
LB McNulty
CB McShane
CB Ingimarsson

RW Currie
LW Brooker
CM Hammond
CM Sidwell

F Zamora
F Knight

How ANYONE can put Cullip, Virgo or Butters above McShane and Ingimarsson is BEYOND me. I can only assume they are idiots...

 

[bigc]

How ANYONE can put Cullip, Virgo or Butters above McShane and Ingimarsson is BEYOND me. I can only assume they are idiots...

It must be remembered that in 2003-04, that Bristol City game aside, we had a mean defence at home and Cullip/Butters/Virgo all contributed to that alongside Roberts.

 

[Brighton Breezy]

Indeed. But McShane and Ingimarsson were CLEARLY better.

And how anyone can pick Mayo literally beggars belief.