Would you start with Dunk or El Abd???

[Leebrighton]

How comes you don't point out facts like Bruno getting beat front post for readings goal and all you see to do is pin point ONE mistake dunk has done against the champions of Europe. Dunk is 10 times the player of elabd. If he was better dunk wouldn't be starting. He's been amazing every game he has played and is still so young. Some of your comments guys are hilarious

 

[JBizzleBeard]

Adam all day long.

 

[Notters]

El Abd all the way. I think those who still think he's rubbish base their opinions solely on the fact that he looks.like a thug.

 

[JBizzleBeard]

How comes you don't point out facts like Bruno getting beat front post for readings goal and all you see to do is pin point ONE mistake dunk has done against the champions of Europe. Dunk is 10 times the player of elabd. If he was better dunk wouldn't be starting. He's been amazing every game he has played and is still so young. Some of your comments guys are hilarious

Hi Lewis

 

[Bring back Bryan wade!!]

The Egyptian international for me

 

[JBizzleBeard]

How comes you don't point out facts like Bruno getting beat front post for readings goal and all you see to do is pin point ONE mistake dunk has done against the champions of Europe. Dunk is 10 times the player of elabd. If he was better dunk wouldn't be starting. He's been amazing every game he has played and is still so young. Some of your comments guys are hilarious

Nearly 78% for AEA....hmmmmm

 

[Notters]

How comes you don't point out facts like Bruno getting beat front post for readings goal and all you see to do is pin point ONE mistake dunk has done against the champions of Europe. Dunk is 10 times the player of elabd. If he was better dunk wouldn't be starting. He's been amazing every game he has played and is still so young. Some of your comments guys are hilarious

Dunk made two or three calamitous mistakes on Saturday and I don't think the fact that they were against Chelsea is at all relevant.

Hi Lewis

Looks that way doesn't it!

 

[Gregory2Smith1]

as it stands,both are at the very limits of there ability in the championship

adam,maybe could cut it as a full back,but not centre half at this level,let's have a reality check,he's not in the same class as wayne bridge

lewis has time on his side,could improve and become a very good championship centre half,but he's far from the finished article,been talked up too much in my view

 

[Sarisbury Seagull]

El-Abd for me as he has improved massively under Gus and IMO is our best defender now.

Thinking of the future though I would also like to see the two of them played together a bit more this season to see how that works.

 

[catfish]

El Abd.

 

[Mr Burns]

Dunk all day long.

 

[bn1&bn3 Albion]

Dunk obviously has potential but makes too many mistakes..

 

[Leebrighton]

It's not our opinions that count. It's gus's. In gus we trust. The footballer over the 'egyptian international' any day

 

[Springal]

It's not our opinions that count. It's gus's. In gus we trust. The footballer over the 'egyptian international' any day

And let's see what Gus does in our first couple of competitive matches shall we ;-)

 

[Deleted member 2719]

Dunk will one day surpass El Abd's ability, possibly be a decent Premier League centrehalf one day... but not yet. Adam for me

Exactly this.

Adam is the current man for a stable and SOLID defence.

 

[magoo]

Only seen the 2 home pre-season games but Dunk has made mistakes that El-Abd wouldn't have.

 

[Eddiespearritt]

Personally I'm not so sure about Greer at times - but Dunk makes the most obvious mistakes and there are many of them. He's young and the supposed queue of top clubs wanting his signature never materialised. Maybe the Anfield own goal live on TV was not easy to hide.....

If it is Dunk or El Abd - right now it's El Abd - but I also want to feel more confident about Greer on certain occasions too.

 

[Marshy]

If Dunk does not play he will never get " better " than El-Abd.

I already think he is.

Its great we have 3 centre halfs that are of great quality.

 

[Icy Gull]

It's not our opinions that count. It's gus's. In gus we trust. The footballer over the 'egyptian international' any day

If we didn't have opinions there wouldn't be much point in this site, I don't think many really believe that they know better than Gus.

Although I'd plump for AEA I'll not be vaguely upset or surprised if he goes for Dunk.

 

[chucky1973]

to sum it up for me i put it like this. Rate them both highly, but when I see the line up I feel more confident with AEA in the starting line up than Dunk. I like the physical side of his game and we need that as we dont have anyone else that can do it, strikers hate him which is great.