Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Worst Premier League XI of the season
- Thread starter Bozza
- Start date
Machiavelli
Well-known member
Agreed. Perhaps I got this wrong, but I always used to think he was a monster of a keeper. Since his return from injury, he's been a monstrously bad keeper.
Totally agree. Just because Hart isn't good enough for England anymore, doesn't make him the worst keeper in the league. Picking him is just playing to the gallery with an easy target. As you say, Adrian is wànk.
Garry Nelson's teacher
Well-known member
How dare you deny Pardew of an opportunity that he worked so hard for!
To be fair when he was good, he had a hell of a 4 infront of him. Most of which now play for Liverpool or United.
Hart is 4th in errors leading to goals after Cech (6) Begovic (5) Hugo (5) Hart (4)
However hart has played at least 15 games less than the other 3.
Last edited:
For that price tag he must have ‘something’, just seen precious little of it this season.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Interesting, but it does only tell us half the story. How busy has he been in those games, and how many above average stops has he made? As an example, when we played them away, he let Izquierdo's shot slip through his fingers only moments before he'd made an excellent one-on-one stop to deny Murray.
I did wonder what classes as an error, as you say the Izquierdo goal wasn’t actually an error - however it was poor - think he was at fault for another that game?
I personally don’t think he is currently good enough to be a PL number 1.
However, how much of that is due to him being dropped and recalled to the team throughout the season, would that change if he had a chance to settle - he was poor in Italy as well.
He’s always had a blunder in him as well as the wonder save - just seems more blunder at the moment
Pavilionaire
Well-known member
- Jul 7, 2003
- 31,262
For me Hart is the worst keeper in the Prem. Watch his feet when there's a free kick anywhere near the edge of the box - he's a complete liability.
Piss poor distribution, he often goes with his wrong hand when diving, the confidence in his defence was shot.
Piss poor distribution, he often goes with his wrong hand when diving, the confidence in his defence was shot.
No he won't. He hasn't been first choice for about a year or so at least, has he? I would bet a lot of money he won't be first choice, Southgate isn't a mug.
Forster, IMO isn't a goalkeeper (insofar as having ANY of the required technique). He's just a (really) big bloke, with good reflexes.
I wasnt suggesting I though he was good, However there was a seaon where he kept 10 clean sheets and a lot of how good a keeper someone is can be based on cleansheets.
If you look at the defence infront of him, it really isnt a suprise that they did so well.
I would argue his relexes have gone, never should Muzza been able to score at home this season against the Saints.
I agree. In fact I'm not sure he'll make the squad at all. Butland and Pickford are shoo-ins, so why take Hart as third choice? Better to take a younger keeper to warm the bench I'd think.
Walton would be the best choice.
