Mick Beard BHA
Hirsute
Good one. While we're at it lets 'seed' the second round at the Finals, and then the quarters, and the semis aswell.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
World Cup Play-Offs: Should There Be Seeding?
- Thread starter Robot Chicken
- Start date
Good one. While we're at it lets 'seed' the second round at the Finals, and then the quarters, and the semis aswell.
¤DãŃn¥ §êãGüLL¤
Banned
Oh surprise surprise, Ronaldo and chums get the easiest draw.
Mick Beard BHA
Hirsute
¤DãŃn¥ §êãGüLL¤;3171980 said:
Away for the second leg though, so you never know.
¤DãŃn¥ §êãGüLL¤
Banned
Nah they're through.
To knock us out in the quarters, on pens.
To knock us out in the quarters, on pens.
Durlston
"You plonker, Rodney!"
Portugal,Rep of Ireland,Russia and Ukraine to qualify.
If i could get at least 8/1 on that i'd be happy.
If i could get at least 8/1 on that i'd be happy.
deletebeepbeepbeep
Well-known member
- May 12, 2009
- 21,818
I had a dream it would be France last night, and then we went on to beat them 2 - 1 over both legs.
Get your money on it.
Why is everyone getting so up tight. The play-offs were seeded in exactly the same way for the last world cup. I haven't heard one complaint from any of the countries involved. Why? Probably because they all knew this is how it would be done.
Get a life everyone please.
If we didn't have seeded groups we could end up in a qualifying group of England, France, Italy, Spain, Portugal and Russia. How pissed off would you be if Germany were then sitting in a group of Germany, Albania, Faroes Islands, Andorra, Luxembourg and San Marino.
Get a life everyone please.
If we didn't have seeded groups we could end up in a qualifying group of England, France, Italy, Spain, Portugal and Russia. How pissed off would you be if Germany were then sitting in a group of Germany, Albania, Faroes Islands, Andorra, Luxembourg and San Marino.
sten_super
Brain Surgeon
I am completely dead against the seeding of playoff teams. However, at least now they are being honest about it. I remember a previous WC qualifying (maybe 2002?) where the playoffs were supposedly 'random' yet it ended up with all the big teams miraculously being kept apart.
The last 16 is seeded. If you win your group you will play a team that didn't.
sten_super
Brain Surgeon
That's not really seeding in the same sense though, is it? At least that is based upon current performance; i.e. in the first two weeks you play well, therefore you are rewarded in week 3. All of the teams in the playoffs finished second in their group, they therefore all did equally well to get that far, and the seedings are based on the FIFA rankings.
Gerbil
Nsc's most loved
when are the games played?
ATFC Seagull
Aberystwyth Town FC
?1. Half of Ireland is up in arms about it.
2. The whole point is that we didn't all know this is how it would be done.
3. This the PLAYOFFS, not the groups. All the teams in it were in seeded groups, and finished second, therefore surely world rankings are now irrelevant. Incidentally, if they had chosen to seed it based on points IN these qualifiers (which imo would be fair), it would have been more or less the same anyways.
Anyways, I am not complaining about the draw. I wouldn't really fancy our chances against anyone, but at least we will raise our game for France, and there'd be no shame in an exit. Shame the Paris leg isn't the saturday though, otherwise we could take 45,000 there again and put les bleus to shame!
1. Half of Ireland is up in arms about it.
2. The whole point is that we didn't all know this is how it would be done.
3. This the PLAYOFFS, not the groups. All the teams in it were in seeded groups, and finished second, therefore surely world rankings are now irrelevant. Incidentally, if they had chosen to seed it based on points IN these qualifiers (which imo would be fair), it would have been more or less the same anyways.
Anyways, I am not complaining about the draw. I wouldn't really fancy our chances against anyone, but at least we will raise our game for France, and there'd be no shame in an exit. Shame the Paris leg isn't the saturday though, otherwise we could take 45,000 there again and put les bleus to shame!
Presumably the other half knew the format having paid attention in 2006! Nothing's changed. There are of course different arguements as to how you get the seeding but as you point out, had they based it on pts then it would have been the same. At the end of the day, France aren't the team they used to be and hopefully you will get through. As for the rest of the draw, the only team I hope don't make are of course Portugal.
ali jenkins
Thanks to Guinness Dave
Surley if they all finished 2nd then they would all be equal in ability and it doesnt matter who you play?
Its shit, then again the whole qualification system is pretty crap
Austrian Gull
Well-known member
¤DãŃn¥ §êãGüLL¤;3171980 said:
Don't underestimate Bosnia. They did well to finish second in a reasonably tough group and have some great players going forward. Dzeko and Misimovic were two of the main reasons Wolfsburg won the German league last year.
If they can keep the away leg tight, they have the ability to qualify at home.
Their manager took Croatia to the semi-finals of France '98 and certainly would give me more confidence than Carlos Queiroz.
The seeding system is shit, BTW.