It's the level they're being loaned to. If Buonanotte was off to League 1 and Barco to the Belgian 2nd. division you'd have a point, but they're not.Agree JP just had a standard progression, i.e. he was not positioned in first team and then moved back.
Everyone has their own view , with Barco & Buonanotte being first team and then shipped out on loan is not a good message. Hopefully I am wrong and that both individuals respond well and comeback better.
Of the two I was more surprised about Barco given that Pervis not back yet but to be fair to Hinshelwood he has shown how competent a player he is by playing out of position again, roasted by Harrison but better today.
Good job I am not the manager we would still be playing Murray.