Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
The official referees a wanker thread
- Thread starter Buzzer
- Start date
Beach Hut
Brighton Bhuna Boy
Ruined the game, sadly
Wilka
Well-known member
Got the sending off bang on but was poor on other decisions. Had to book there 8 if it wasn't a pen which I'm not convinced about either
Another ref who comes down here and hasn't got a clue. I am positive the quality of referees is declining from the top to the bottom.
the wanderbus
Well-known member
I've been saying that for the last 18 months , some of them seem to think we pay just to watch them.
Taybha
Whalewhine
well i am f***ing fed up to the back teeth of these f***ing shit muppets who have the front to call themselves officials , my aunty vera who was almost f***ing blind would have spotted the offside in the build up and thats just the obvious balls up these 3 twats made,am f***ed off with this week in week out ,bunch o twat faced cockmasters
Hungry Joe
SINNEN
Really? Looked pretty inocuous to me and El Abd was clearly looking at the ball, not the man. He wasn't even hurt. If that kind of challenge is a straight red it's a wonder any game finishes 11 v 11.
Theatre of Trees
Well-known member
Agreed, it looked to me like El-Abd's leg was stretched to poke the ball away which was dropping down from above. Referee was consistently awful today and killed the game as a spectacle.
Hunting 784561
New member
- Jul 8, 2003
- 3,651
It happened right in front of me in the north stand, and IMHO it was fully justified.
El Abd went in high, with studs showing.
A booking may have been more the common sense response, but the ref's reaction was correct to the laws of the game.
El Abd went in high, with studs showing.
A booking may have been more the common sense response, but the ref's reaction was correct to the laws of the game.
Wilka
Well-known member
It was high and his studs were showing
SirDouglasLoft
New member
- Jul 4, 2008
- 6,876
He was shit, but we just have to get on with it, it's not an excuse.
The Auditor
New member
The ref Mr Paul Taylor never gives us anything ..was the ref at Reading when we lost 5-1...nearly always gives a pen against us or sends one of ours off...IMO it goes back to him being critised by the club after a game at the Goldstone versus Bristol Rovers...
Lindfield by the Pond
Well-known member
Pavilionaire
Well-known member
- Jul 7, 2003
- 31,278
What really annoyed me about the dismissal was the complete lack of communication with his assistant, who was standing 10 yards away from the incident.
"He dived in with studs showing" - that conjures up an image of 2 players chasing a slow moving ball and going into the tackle horizontally. What happened here is the ball was coming down at a vertical angle, El-Abd used poor technique but still touched the ball first and then caught the man, who was very much second to the ball anyway.
The man didn't even need treatment and showed no signs of injury for the rest of the match.
I'd accept the card more readily if he'd have consulted with this assistant, but he saw all the Dons players running towards their man dramatically and that was probably the decisive reason for his award of a red.
Compared to officiating in other sports this is all so AMATEUR....
"He dived in with studs showing" - that conjures up an image of 2 players chasing a slow moving ball and going into the tackle horizontally. What happened here is the ball was coming down at a vertical angle, El-Abd used poor technique but still touched the ball first and then caught the man, who was very much second to the ball anyway.
The man didn't even need treatment and showed no signs of injury for the rest of the match.
I'd accept the card more readily if he'd have consulted with this assistant, but he saw all the Dons players running towards their man dramatically and that was probably the decisive reason for his award of a red.
Compared to officiating in other sports this is all so AMATEUR....
hopper_182
Active member
- Sep 25, 2008
- 650
yep he had a shocker. The number of decisions that went against us was staggering.dougdeep
New member
No worse than the others this season.
I Saw This Coming
When I saw who the ref was, I told my mate he was a shocker and he was. Will have to watch the sending off again on tv later but I hate refs who approach an incident while reaching for the red card as they are running ( Andy D'urso does the same ). Regrettably this ref is one of the more experienced in the lower divisions but he struts about like lord of the manor. Only thing I did think that Elphick clearly pulled their bloke down in the second half when he was through and no pen given...but no booking for diving either.
In the circumstances by playing 63 mins with 10 men, I thought we played pretty well. Not impressed with MK Dons.
When I saw who the ref was, I told my mate he was a shocker and he was. Will have to watch the sending off again on tv later but I hate refs who approach an incident while reaching for the red card as they are running ( Andy D'urso does the same ). Regrettably this ref is one of the more experienced in the lower divisions but he struts about like lord of the manor. Only thing I did think that Elphick clearly pulled their bloke down in the second half when he was through and no pen given...but no booking for diving either.
In the circumstances by playing 63 mins with 10 men, I thought we played pretty well. Not impressed with MK Dons.
BensGrandad
New member
The only decision he got right was the sending off. It doesnt matter whether or not the player was injured or AE touched the ball first. The tackle was high and with all studs showing and dangerous, a definite red card offense.