No, mouthing off about a dubious handball (on a par with the one given against Dunk, which we unanimously decided was never a handball)
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Simon Hooper
- Thread starter Sheebo
- Start date
swindonseagull
Well-known member
From Swindon aint he......................Saw him in American Golf recently in town but was to scared to talk to him....Is this man a pie tester for Greggs
Huffing and puffing all through todays match.
Fat ****
Nobby Cybergoat
Well-known member
- Jul 19, 2021
- 8,622
Strangely not the sort of match where the official was involved that much.
He reffed it fine, as far as I can tell
He reffed it fine, as far as I can tell
American Seagle
Well-known member
- Jun 14, 2022
- 896
Not sure why we didn't get a penalty for handball in the second half near the end.
B-right-on
Living the dream
I think so. That's what he seemed to indicate after Pedro got hacked down without a free kick.
Good to see RDZ back to his animated self
From the shot by Gross? Straight at him, arm in front of his chest - not unnatural and probably couldn't move it out of the way. But that was my take - they didn't really show any replays.
He was fine, but the poor fella isn't fit enough to keep up with play which I think is why he ends up giving most 50/50s. His whole head was bright red after a few minutes. Think both sides got their fair share of those borderline decisions though.
Thought he was unusually inoffensive today. Fair play.
amazed at the other posters suggesting he ’booked Welbeck for nothing’. That was a nailed on yellow, that we’d all have been fuming if it went unpunishe, had it been the other way round
amazed at the other posters suggesting he ’booked Welbeck for nothing’. That was a nailed on yellow, that we’d all have been fuming if it went unpunishe, had it been the other way round
Winker
CUM ON FEEL THE NOIZE
This, did nothing to protect our players then booked Welbz for nothing much, his yellow card came out almost before the scummy player even hit the ground.
Very poor refereeing.
Definitely encroachment. Hooper gave that signal as he booked him.
Thought he was poor, but agree Welbeck decision was spot on.Thought he was unusually inoffensive today. Fair play.
amazed at the other posters suggesting he ’booked Welbeck for nothing’. That was a nailed on yellow, that we’d all have been fuming if it went unpunishe, had it been the other way round
Yeah, an utterly bizarre reason for a booking in the grand scheme of things. I don’t think you’ll see that in any other PL game.
That aside, Hooper was very average today, mainly because there wasn’t a huge amount to do. He’s far too inconsistent to progress further than his current level. Thought it was very funny he decided to implement the foul throw rule early on, then disregard a number of poor attempts later in the game (one in particular was appalling).
- Oct 17, 2008
- 14,487
Had a good game, controlled it generally very well. No controversial decisions, barely noticed him. Not sure what else the bloke can do really.
I agree the general standard of refereeing is not what it should be, but he was absolutely fine today.
I agree the general standard of refereeing is not what it should be, but he was absolutely fine today.
Weststander
Well-known member
That’s what I saw.
Arteta infamously has encroached on many occasions. I hope refs/4th officials are equally thorough.
American Seagle
Well-known member
- Jun 14, 2022
- 896
Yeah didn't see why replay's at all which is very odd.
That was the incident but he did appear to signal thar De Zerbi had gone on to the pitch.
Slum_Wolf
Well-known member
- May 3, 2021
- 767
Seagull58
In the Algarve
I hope he's been training hard in pre-season and laying off the pies. He's not the worst ref in the Prem, albeit the field is very competitive, but he's probably the least fit since John Moss was axed. His inability to keep up with play is the cause of some of his dodgy decisions when he simply guesses what happened and is influenced by the players/crowd.Referee on Saturday at Goodison Park.
Great