Shane Duffy - it's a DONE DEAL!

[Thunder Bolt]

My point is that we as a club failed not any individual. I could identify a Maseratti as being the ideal car for my son but I know he couldnt afford it.

My point was in reply to Nixonater.

 

[BensGrandad]

My point was in reply to Nixonater.

sorry my mistake

 

[LamieRobertson]

Still prefer Goldson...but thought he had a competent game..one dodgy moment first half where either he or Stockers dithered

 

[portslade seagull]

He looked much better tonight

 

[Munchkin]

Much better tonight, still need to be convinced he's a better option than Goldson.

 

[BensGrandad]

Great improvement tonight and stepped in and stopped Kayal possibly doing something to get a red card.

 

[Machiavelli]

I thought he did better than good tonight. Solid and commanding (although that's somewhat easier with Dunk in imperious form), and there were two or three brilliant passes threaded through, turning defence into attack.

 

[Albumen]

He was phenomenal tonight.

 

[atomised]

Definitely his best game for us so far

 

[samtheseagull]

He was very good tonight. looks decent on the ball as well

 

[Sheebo]

He was alright tonight - still nowhere near Goldson's level IMO. A strange signing for such a high fee. He is fairly slow and his headers are a bit wayward at times but is def solid enough - just hope he doesn't keep playing just to justify his price tag when it seems fairly clear Goldson is better at the moment...

 

[Ninja Elephant]

He was phenomenal tonight.

Your expectations on a centre back performance must be based on Hawkins vs Hartlepool to call Duffy phenomenal tonight.

He is an accident waiting to happen, he should be a back up for Dunk, Goldson, Hünemeier and Bruno for a centre back spot. Awful waste of £4million.

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

Excellent tonight.

 

[Justice]

Your expectations on a centre back performance must be based on Hawkins vs Hartlepool to call Duffy phenomenal tonight.

He is an accident waiting to happen, he should be a back up for Dunk, Goldson, Hünemeier and Bruno for a centre back spot. Awful waste of £4million.

Did you watch a different game tonight? Hudds didn't have a sniff cleared everything in the air and looked good on the ball bit like having two Dunks once they get their partnership stronger.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Your expectations on a centre back performance must be based on Hawkins vs Hartlepool to call Duffy phenomenal tonight.

He is an accident waiting to happen, he should be a back up for Dunk, Goldson, Hünemeier and Bruno for a centre back spot. Awful waste of £4million.

I disagree strongly. He worked well tonight and has a better understanding with Bruno.

 

[theboybilly]

Your expectations on a centre back performance must be based on Hawkins vs Hartlepool to call Duffy phenomenal tonight.

He is an accident waiting to happen, he should be a back up for Dunk, Goldson, Hünemeier and Bruno for a centre back spot. Awful waste of £4million.

Is Duffy your new Stockdale?

 

[Machiavelli]

I disagree strongly. He worked well tonight and had a much better understanding with Bruno than the car-crash on Saturday.

Amended for you

 

[The-Libertine]

Your expectations on a centre back performance must be based on Hawkins vs Hartlepool to call Duffy phenomenal tonight.

Hold on. Are you using Hawkins' performance against Hartlepool as your measure of the worst possible performance by a Centre Back? Shouldn't we use Hawkins' display against Stockport instead?

 

[Perkino]

Goldson was in superb form at the end of last season. I look forward to having him back in the starting 11

 

[Turkey]

Thought he was excellent tonight to be fair.