So it is "footballing reasons" then. JT is a far better player, and has no footballing related problems (such as a drugs related matter that RF has). If only one player goes, it has to be JT.
Also, JT may be getting a bit "past it", but RF should simply hang up his boots now.
Whether or not he is the better of the two options between him and JT isn't what has set him off. It's the 'down to the bare bones, but still we won't pick the defender who was regularly picked by great manager alex ferguson, champions league winner, premier league winner, fa cup and league cup winner, and world club cup winner rio, instead we'll get the reserve defender (who's closest thing to an accomplishment is being on the bench for their penalty shoot out defeat of a team from the division below) for the team that finished 8th'.
Maybe he can, maybe he can't play every game (he played three games in 8 days three times this past season, Nov, Dec and April). But it's not about whether he can play in every game when you have a 23 man squad. And if we're going to not pick people because of injury worries, Terry shouldn't be in the team because of his injuries towards the end of the season, Scott Parker shouldn't be in the squad. Gerrard is only recently back from injury and was in and out of the livrpool squad towards the end of the season so maybe we shouldn't risk him.
I'm not saying moralee is right to say this now, but rio has been hard done by and more so with every replacement that gets called up, and this will all blow up again if John Terry is found guilty after his court trial. Anyone who thinks Rio wouldn't be in the squad if when the FA stripped Terry of the captaincy they went the whole way and removed him from availability for the England team, or if he had been ruled out yesterday instead of Cahill is being naive.