Reyes & Harper...do you want them back?

[Medwayseagull]

Id love Reyes back as he was quality..few concerns around his antics but more importantly that his wife and kids still live in south America. Sounds like another potential tevez!!!

Perhaps they would move over if he played and lived in the balmy south.

 

[e77]

Can't see Harper leaving Newcastle but not bothered either way if he does come back.

Would have to take Reyes on loan for a while to see if he can sort his head out. Certainly a good enough player though.

 

[tubaman]

Both great players that would strengthen our squad.
Reyes bit of a risk as I think he may well get a bit of stir for his driving while disqualified.

I would love to see Reyes back. There is absolutely NO chance of him going to prison. He could be given a suspended sentence but even that would be most unlikely. Probably a large fine and a community order.

 

[Norman Baker suck my lozenge]

I would love to see Reyes back. There is absolutely NO chance of him going to prison. He could be given a suspended sentence but even that would be most unlikely. Probably a large fine and a community order.

Good point,but can you just begin to imagine all the wank bubbles on here slagging off Poyet if we sign him and He gets porridge?

 

[Vegas Seagull]

We're not going any higher with our current keepers

 

[JBizzleBeard]

Yes and yes.

 

[Magic Sponge]

Would love to have both back but as said before Harper is probably a no go.
As with Reyes, would like to get him in as I think he is a great defender and brings something different to our game.

 

[brightonrock]

Reyes a big yes, for the flair as much as the quality, but Harper, meh. Aside from the relocation of the family, and the wages etc etc, I felt like I was the only one not wanking myself silly over him. Sure, he came for crosses better than Ankergren, but his shot-stopping was pretty much the same and his distribution was just punting it long, Watford being the prime example when in all honesty we should've asked for our sodding money back. Seems like we solved one problem but created another. If a new keeper is needed (which seems to be a discussion point in itself), there are plenty of keepers who come for crosses but don't feel the need to hump it miles up the pitch every time they get it. I don't think a keeper (unless it's a loan in Jan) will be on the radar until the summer anyway, when I can see Gus dropping Casper to no2 and spending proper money on a new no1.

 

[severnside gull]

Was told the other day by a Baggies regular that we are in talks with the club for Reyes.

Did wonder about Cudicini for a possible loan target?

 

[BensGrandad]

I would love to have Jara back as he is class. Dont think that Harper is that much better than Ankergren so would like to keep Casper and then look again in the summer for an experienced man to be no 1.

 

[Super Steve Earle]

Jara yes, Harper a big no way.

 

[bn1&bn3 Albion]

I'd love Reyes back and I'd like Harper back.

 

[SeagullinExile]

A big fat yes!

 

[wunt be druv]

Yes,Reyes please,quality.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Jara yes, Harper a big no way.

This. I can't understand why people think Harper is so much better when he conceded 5 goals in 5 games. He hoofed it upfield all the time at Watford which cost us the game.

 

[Husty]

Did I hear correctly we sent Harper back because we wanted to free up his wages to bring in Paynter?

Or was that just some horrible nightmare I had?

 

[perseus]

Harper: a big No!

Reyes: appreciate the quality, but central midfield is our prime concern.

I would like to see Crofts, Elliott, Murray back (wish they hadn't left). And I would prefer Cook to stay.

 

[Mr Burns]

I'd have Reyes back any time, but I'm not sure on Harper.

I can see us going for a Joe Lewis type of keeper. Shame Peterbrough won't do business in the January window...............................................

 

[LamieRobertson]

I hav a major concern over Reyes attitude ...if its correct wife n kids r bak in south American tht would go someway to explaining it

 

[southasp]

Reyes...yes
Harper...no