Reading and Newcastle

[dwayne]

Which scenario would you take given the choice:

1) draw both games

2) win Reading lose Newcastle

Would depriving Newcastle of 2 points be better than gaining the extra point ?

 

[aolstudios]

More worried by Huddersfield, so maximum points possible please

 

[JonnyComeEarly]

3 please: beat newcastle and draw reading

Newcastle are the ones to reel in to this 3 way battle not reading. We need to beat them and then when they lose to hudds they'll be flapping

 

[Wilko]

4 points fro the 2 games is a must I would say, win and a draw either way around is all good.

 

[BensGrandad]

A win for us and Barnsley on Saturday and then look again over the weekend and re asses.

 

[Stat Brother]

Shirley it's all academic as the season is all but over anyway.

 

[OzMike]

Win both or at least die trying.

 

[smeg]

Shirley it's all academic as the season is all but over anyway.

haha

 

[DavidRyder]

Barnsley will hopefully be up for this one and get at least a draw v Hudds. Then a win for us, 6 point gap going into Tuesday, I'd feel happier.

 

[BBassic]

Beat Reading. Draw or beat Newcastle.

 

[The Camel]

No disrespect, but what a ridiculous question.

If anyone would prefer 2 points to 3, they need their head examined.

 

[Jim D]

Let's beat Reading first then we go again v Newcastle.

 

[lizard]

Need to win our home games if we're serious about going up.

 

[dwayne]

I had a specific question for this thread. But it seems to have veered off course !

 

[PILTDOWN MAN]

Which scenario would you take given the choice:

1) draw both games

2) win Reading lose Newcastle

Would depriving Newcastle of 2 points be better than gaining the extra point ?

Neither, win both.

 

[dwayne]

No disrespect, but what a ridiculous question.

If anyone would prefer 2 points to 3, they need their head examined.

I don't think it's a ridiculous question. And I still can't make my mind up which I would prefer. Obviously 3 points is better than 2 but preventing Newcastle from getting 2 extra points would surely be more beneficial.

 

[LamieRobertson]

3 please: beat newcastle and draw reading

Newcastle are the ones to reel in to this 3 way battle not reading. We need to beat them and then when they lose to hudds they'll be flapping

Not four then?

 

[Greg Bobkin]

Which scenario would you take given the choice:

1) draw both games

2) win Reading lose Newcastle

Would depriving Newcastle of 2 points be better than gaining the extra point ?

Well, clearly we're going to lose both games because we're 'not a two 2 side'...

EDIT: Sorry, not top 2 MATERIAL.

 

[Dick Swiveller]

A win for us and Barnsley on Saturday and then look again over the weekend and re asses.

Re your post of 09:42. What were you trying to bring our attention to with regard to asses?

 

[sparkie]

We don't want to lose to Newcastle, unless Newcastle then beat Huddersfield.

Worst case : Newcastle beat albion, Huddersfield beat Newcastle.

Need to beat Reading to mitigate in advance against this.