Player Ratings

[Withdean Wanderer]

Henderson 8 - the only player i trust at the moment
Reid 6 - dreadful passing, but didn't get skinned very often
Hart - 6 - done for the first goal but good going forward
Mcshane 7 - sign him now
Butters 6 - lost out in the air to Ricketts imho
Carole 5 - cross the ball, don't go inside!
Chippy 5 - off the pace
Hammond 5 - gets tuck in but bad first touch really lets him down
Jarrett 5 - not a good game at all, too many trics
Knight 6 - lots of running but no service
Robinson 7 - good game, assist for the goal

Kazim Richards 5 - never got involved
Frutos 5 didn't see the ball

 

[Del Boy]

Henderson 8
Reid 6
Hart 6
Mcshane 7
Butters 5
Carole 6
Chippy 5
Hammond 6
Jarrett 6
Knight 5
Robinson 7

 

[Bakesy]

No one deserved more than a 5 today.

 

[O Lads]

Re: Re: Player Ratings

Henderson 7- good but should have come out for 2nd goal
Reid 5- not good, no left peg, poor passing
Hart 7- played quite well imho
Mcshane 7- was ok, made a good tackle near end
Butters 5- imo not good enough to be starting
Carole 6- look dangerous but couldn't cross quick enough
Chippy 5- didnt do alot
Hammond 6- poor first touch, should have tried to shoot 1st time
Jarrett 6- average
Knight 5- didnt chase anything kept hetting tackled
Robinson 8- best player on the pitch

 

[Del Boy]

No one deserved more than a 5 today.

Henderson, Jake, McShane definately deserved it for sure. FACT

 

[Normandy seagull]

Henderson 5- sorry but bring back Blaney ASAP at fault for second goal and am never confident with him in goal

Reid 5- crap passing, cannot play left-back, not a good enough defender in a 4-4-2 formation

Hart 6- tried hard, done a few times, should be playing right mid

Mcshane- 6 Please could we convert him into a defensive midfielder, looks to small for a centre half. If MM thinks this one up we could go places but at equally at fault for the second goal

Butters 6- did well with Ricketts but his lack of pace is a worry

Carole 5- poor game, no creativity, crap passing not playing as a team

chippy 5- woeful 1st half, slightly better 2nd but short of fitness and one step behind

Hammond 6- tried hard to be our only physical player but did nothing much going forward trying to help out chippy

Jarrett 5- poor game, seemed to lack confident AGAIN, lost ball far too often

Knight 5- worst game for a while, comittment was poor today but got no service from midfield

Robinson 7- tried hard but didn't try to link up with anyone. Should not have come off as others were far worse

 

[Kaney]

Henderson - 6
Hart - 6
McShane - 5
Butters - 5
Reid - 4
Carole - 3
Carpenter - 2
Hammond - 3
Jarrett - 5
Knight - 5
Robinson - 5

CKR - 5
Frutos - 4

 

[Wilka]

Henderson - 6- Alright
Reid 2 - Awfal but out of position so not really his fault
Hart - 5 - Alright
Mcshane 6 - ok
Butters 5 - Alight
Carole 3 - Non existant
Chippy 3 - One of his worst games for the Albion
Hammond 4 - Not at the races
Jarrett 4 - Didn't put any testing ball in
Knight 5 - Didn't do much
Robinson 6.5 - Man of the match.... but only just

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Henderson -8 two good saves - im not sure how he was at fault for second?

Hart -3
Butters - 4
Mcshane -4
Reid - 3

Chippy - 4
Hammond - 4
Jarrett - 2
Carole - 3

Jake - 3
Knight - 4

 

[Normandy seagull]

Henderson -8 two good saves - im not sure how he was at fault for second?

Hart -3
Butters - 4
Mcshane -4
Reid - 3

Chippy - 4
Hammond - 4
Jarrett - 2
Carole - 3

Jake - 3
Knight - 4

Henderson should have come out and was just stood rooted to the spot. Equally centre-halfs should have communicated this though

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Thought Hart just stood there to be honest - not keepers fault really - maybe its the Hes is not Kuipers coming out again!

 

[Yorkie]

Henderson 6
Reid 6
Hart 6
Mcshane 7
Butters 5
Carole 6
Chippy 5
Hammond 5
Jarrett 6
Knight 5
Robinson 7

 

[BatterSeagull]

Henderson 6
Hart 6
Butters 4
McShane 5
Carole 4
Carpenter 4
Hammond 4
Jarrett 5
Knight 4
Robinson 6

Frutos 4
CKR 4

 

[Lokki 7]

Henderson 6
Reid 5
Hart 4
Mcshane 5
Butters 5
Carole 5
Chippy 5
Hammond 5
Jarrett 5
Knight 5
Robinson 5

McGhee 3 Sorry, but that result/performance rests on the managers shoulders. This is not a bad bunch of players and should produce better team displays than this. Please change it for Palace Mark or we are going to get humiliated AGAIN.

 

[Silent Bob]

Henderson- 6 Played well but at fault for the goal. Such is the life of a goalkeeper.

Reid- 4 Piss poor again. Can't use his left foot, shouldn't be at left back.
Hart- 5 Skinned several times.
McShane- 6 Played well but his missed tackle was a mistake in the build up to the first goal.
Butters- 5.5 Good in the air, Jerome gave him (and McShane) all sorts of problems with his strength and pace.

Jarrett- 3 His worst game for a long time.
Carole- 4 Very poor, a shadow of what he has been so far. Why did he keep going inside?
Carpenter- 4 Started to find his range a bit late on but a very poor game
Hammond- 6 Tried hard, may have played well in a good team performance

Knight- 5.5 Poor service. Played one beutiful through ball which Kaey failed to make the best of
Robinson- 5.5 Poor service. Worried the defence with his running but touch wan't always the best.

Subs:
Frutos- 5 Hardly touched the ball. Put in a couple of good crosses though. Give him a start.
Kazim-Richards- 4 Again poor service, but did nothing when he had the ball. Apart from the goal and the brief period after it against Coventry he's done nothing.

McGhee- 4 Taking Jakey off straight after the goal was the wrong move.

 

[Albion Edd]

Henderson 7
Reid 4
Butters 5
McShane 6
Hart 6
Jarrett 3
Hammond 5
Chippy 4
Carole 5
Knight 5
Robinson 5

CKR 4
Frutos 5

 

[Schrödinger's Toad]

Henderson 7*

Reid 6
Butters 5
McShane 6
Hart 5

Jarrett 4
Carpenter 4
Hammond 5
Carole 5

Knight 6
Robinson 5

 

[goldstone]

Very surprised at the poor ratings for Jarrett. I thought he was one of our best players.

 

[timbha]

Very surprised at the poor ratings for Jarrett. I thought he was one of our best players.

yesterday or generally? what does he do?

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

yesterday or generally? what does he do?

Fall over the ball.