Player Ratings

[king Wombat]

Shaaban 6

Reid 6
Hinshelwood 6 (Hammond 6)
Butters 5 Mayo 4 (Jones 5)

Hart 2
Oatway 1
Virgo 6
Harding 6

McCammon 5 (McPhee 5)
Knight 7

a midfield would have been nice.

Mayo did not look once at who he was passing to - just hoofed it aimlessly up the park and the rest of the back 4 were no better at trying to build from the back.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Shaaban 6 whats wrong with punching

Reid 4 woefull
Hinshelwood 6 will be a big miss, doubt we will see him again this season if mcghee is right
Butters 4 sorry this formation doesnt suit him
Mayo 4

Hart 2 was he on the pitch?
Oatway 1 worst of a bad bunch
Virgo 5
Harding 6 did a lot better

McCammon 5 held the ball up well but missed a sitter
Knight 7 at least someone wants to stay up

Hammond 6
McPhee 5
Jones 5

 

[Marshy]

Nobody had a bad game in all honesty, although i was dissapointed in the keeper, what little he had to do didnt inspire me with confidence.

Knight was clearly our best player on the park, looked dangerous whenever we gave him a half decent ball and i thought worked very hard also.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Nobody had a bad game in all honesty, although i was dissapointed in the keeper, what little he had to do didnt inspire me with confidence.

Knight was clearly our best player on the park, looked dangerous whenever we gave him a half decent ball and i thought worked very hard also.

How can you say nobody had a bad game? the team was second best to everything

 

[king Wombat]

we were woeful. the games we have won this year against the 'big' clubs we have at least attempted to pass the ball but last night all we did was launch 40 yard balls to their centre halves in the hope that they would clear the ball out.

it was shockingly bad.

 

[keaton]

McCammon 6 - held it up but then seemed to want to turn and get at people rather than lay off to the midfield

What midfield?

 

[Barnet Seagull]

Shaaban 5 - Prone to punch, not confidence inspiring but did ok.
Reid 4 - Out of position too often, allowed cross for goal
Hinshelwood 6.5 - Unfortunate, looked good up until injury.
Butters 6 - Reliable but caught out a few times, not his best game.
Mayo 5 - Defensively ok, distribution was woeful
Hart 5 - anonymous, looked jaded
Virgo 6.5 - Asked to play in 3 positions, looked out of depth in the middle
Oatway 5 - Not one of his better games
Harding 6.5 - Played reasonably well, looked confident and comfortable, lacked support from Mayo.
McCammon 6.5 - Was a threat, shame he had to leave the field
Knight 6 - Disappointing, not his usual productive self.
Hammond 6 - Got into some good positions but defensively lacking.
McPhee 4 - Did Nothing of note.
Jones 4 - ditto

 

[GUNTER]

Shaaban - 5, looked unsure
Reid 5 - poor game
Hinshelwood 6
Butters 7 - got better as game went on
Mayo 4 - woeful
Hart 4 - did he play?
Virgo 6 - looked better in defence
Oatway 7 - thought he played ok after poor first 15 mins
Harding 7 - solid game
McCammon 7 - struggled with illness but still looked a threat
Knight 8 MOM - behind just about everything good we did

Subs

Hammond 6
McPhee 4 - simply not up to this level
Jones 5

 

[Rookie]

Shaaban - Looked confident in some pieces but then changed his mind - 6

Reid - Shocking, postion just went to pot - 3
Hinsh - Injured
Butters - Solid - 7
Mayo - Crossing was awful - 5

Hart - Went missing most of time - 5
Virgo - Defence looked more solid with him - 7
Oatway - Whats gone wrong, can't pass at mo - 5/6
Harding - Actually looked quite solid saved us quite a few times - 6/7

BigMc - Tried but was clearly ill and not up to it - 6
Knight - Some of those crosses in the second half were superb, how we didn't score. 8

Hammond - Gave a midfield threat going forward - 7
McPhee - After all the talk of his hat trick very dissapointed - 5
Jones - Didn't really do much, right or wrong - 5

 

[Skaville]

Shaaban 5 - CATCH THE BALL
Reid 6 - Needs to be given a chance in midfield
Hinshelwood 5 (was playing okay until injury)
Butters 6 - Solid
Mayo 5 - did okay
Hart 4 - a legend, but time to move on to Orient
Oatway 4 - Off the pace all night
Virgo 7 - Commendable. Did waht was asked in three positions
Harding 7 - a better performance
McCammon - 5 Not fit
Knight 7 - Has suddenly become a real trier

Jones 4 - WHY IS HE STILL HERE?
Hammond 6 - encouraging
McPhee 5 - Has a great career ahead of him at Eastbourne Borough

McGhee - 4 - Not enough changes after Wigan and Plymouth.

 

[bellsize seagull]

Shaaban - did nothing wrong
Reid - porrest game for along time lacking confidence to cross the halway line
Hinshelwood - big injury loss to the player of the season so far
Hammond - worked hard and tried to get the ball down
Butters - was solid
Mayo - got forward well at times
Jones - could not get into the game
Hart - off colour
Oatway - " "
Virgo - Played in three different positions caused problems when up front
Harding - mixed performance, worked hard second half
McCammon - fingers crossed he can still play this season
McPhee - not fit
Knight - another hard working performance, when plays wide he is at his best

 

[oapdodge]

Shabaan 6
Reid 5
Butters 7
Hinshelwood 7 fine until he went off.
Mayo 5
Hart 5
Oatway 4
Virgo 7 MOM
Harding 7
McCammon6
knight 7

Hammond 7
Mcphee 5
Jones 5

McGhee 7
Crowd 7

 

[dougdeep]

All 6, except for Harding, Virgo and Hammond 7.

 

[Del Boy]

Re: Re: Player Ratings

Shaaban 5

Reid 5
Hinshelwood - 6 (Hammond 5)
Butters 7
Mayo 6 (Jones 4)

Hart 6
Oatway 5
Virgo 8
Harding 7

McCammon 6 (McPhee 6)
Knight 7

 

[ShorehamGull]

Shaaban 6

Reid 5
Hinshelwood
Butters 7
Mayo 5

Hart 5
Oatway 5
Virgo 8
Harding 6

McCammon 6
Knight 8

Hammond 7
Mcphee 6
Jones 5

 

[Albion Edd]

Shaaban 6
Reid 5
Hinshelwood 6
Butters 7
Mayo 5
Hart 5
Oatway 5
Virgo 7
Harding 7

McCammon 6
Knight 7

Hammond 7
McPhee 6
Jones 5

 

[Zebedee]

He played a blinder considering he shouldn't have even started, McGhee should have known he wasn't fit enough, i thought he was great under the circumstances.

I agree with you Trigger. I think the big man did fairly well under the circumstances although why McGhee waited for so long to replace him is a mystery. He'd certainly wouldn't win a prize in a Duty of Care contest.

 

[Zebedee]

I thought Harding played well - didn't give it away and some some strong challenges - how some of you gave him 3's and 4's is beyond me

Sadly, there are still a lot of Harding haters out there. I wish they'd give the lad a chance.

 

[Albion Edd]

I've been a critic of Harding, but I thought he was one our best players yesterday, a big improvementon his performance against Wigan. I think he's played far better in midfield or as a wing back.