Player ratings

[West Hoathly Seagull]

Kuipers - 6 - no chance with any of the goals. Catching brilliant, kicking still rather dodgy.
El Abd - 6 - did nothing wrong, probably unfortunate to be substituted.
Harding - 5 - looked uncomfortable whenever QPR attacked. His England call-up doesn't seem to have increased his confidence.
Cullip - 4 - his worst game for a long while. Terrible error for their first goal and could have caused more.
Mayo - 6 - didn't play badly for a player playing out of position.
Hammond - 5 - looked out of his depth today. Ok in the first half, but totally out of it in the second.
Nicholas - 7 - very good for most of the time, but his passing wasn't as good as in the last few games, and he was giving the ball away too much.
Hinshelwood - 7 - played very well, for someone also out of position. Ran in well to take his goal.
Currie - 8 - easily the best player on the pitch today from the Albion, perhaps faded a bit in the second half.
Virgo - 7 - led up front well, though service to him was not very good.
McPhee - 6 - impressive in the first half, obviously tired in the second half, should have been replaced by Knight earlier.

 

[seagulls4ever]

Official Brightonfc.co.uk Player Ratings:

Kuipers: 6
El-Abd: 6
Cullip: 5
Mayo: 7
Harding: 5
Hinshelwood: 7
Nicolas: 7
Hammond: 7
Currie: 8 MOM
McPhee: 6
Virgo: 6

Subs:

Jarrett: 6
Carpenter: 5
Knight: 5

 

[BatterSeagull]

Kuipers 6
El-Abd 6
Cullip 4
Mayo 7
Harding 4
Currie 7
Nicholas 6
Hammond 6
Hinshelwood 5
McPhee 6
Virgo 6

subs:- on far too late to score

 

[oapdodge]

Kuipers: 6
El-Abd: 5
Cullip: 5
Mayo: 5
Harding: 5
Hinshelwood: 6
Nicolas: 7
Hammond: 7
Currie: 8 MOM
McPhee: 7
Virgo: 7

Subs:

Jarrett: 6
Carpenter: 5
Knight: 5

McGhee 4 admitted by himself cost us the game or at least a point

Crowd 5

 

[perseus]

Kuipers 6
El Dabd 6
Cullip 4
Mayo 7
Harding 7

Currie 6
Hammond 5
Nicolas 0 (verging on minus 2)
Hinshelwood 7

McPhee 4 (not quite ready yet)
Virgo 7

 

[oapdodge]

Nicholas 0 minus 2
The game is of opinions but did you watch the game ?
Not taking the piss but why such a low score ?

 

[perseus]

Nil because he did not do anything positive.

And minus two because if he was doing anything he might have been in a position to challenge two of their goals.

He made a few tackles and it is arguable whether they made much impact.

He hardly covered any ground in the whole match. He just sort of wondered around the middle as the game passed him by.

I watched to see if any Albion player passed the ball to him. Once.

Not fault on his effort. Seems an honest sort of player. Just maybe not good enough on the day

Maybe he would be better playing a bit wider? I can't see it though

 

[The Large One]

I know it's a game of opinions, and my opinion is Perseus lives up his own arse. The more I read his diatribes, the more urgent finding my cricket bat becomes.

 

[Bobby's Gull]

Kuipers 4
El-Abd 6
Cullip 4
Mayo 6
Harding 4
Currie 7
Nicholas 5
Hammond 5
Hinshelwood 6
McPhee 6
Virgo 5

 

[dougdeep]

FDM--------6
El-Abd-----7
Cullip------5
Mayo------6
Harding---5
Currie-----7MOM
Nicolas----6
Hammond5
Hinsh-----6
McPhee---6
Virgo------5

 

[Gwylan]

Kuipers 5 - Some good saves but still doesn't look in command of his area
El-Abd 5 - Still learning. Tackles well but distribution shocking
Cullip 4 - The worst game I've seen him have. Perhaps needs op now
Mayo 4 - Looked off the pace
Harding 5 - Made a couple of good forward runs but looked terrified in defence
Hinshelwood 6 - Took goal well and ran hard. Limited imagination though
Nicholas 7 - Got stuck in but gave the ball away a lot (by his standards)
Hammond 4 - Looked out of his depth today
Currie 8 - Clear MoM, even if he did nothing second half
McPhee 6 - Doesn't stop running but wonder whether this is a level too high
Virgo 5 - Looked like a centre back playing up front

Subs: not on long enough to make an impact

 

[The Great Cornholio]

Nil because he did not do anything positive.

And minus two because if he was doing anything he might have been in a position to challenge two of their goals.

He made a few tackles and it is arguable whether they made much impact.

He hardly covered any ground in the whole match. He just sort of wondered around the middle as the game passed him by.

I watched to see if any Albion player passed the ball to him. Once.

Not fault on his effort. Seems an honest sort of player. Just maybe not good enough on the day

Maybe he would be better playing a bit wider? I can't see it though

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Kuipers 6
El Abd 4
Harding 3
Cullip 3
Mayo 5
Currie 9 - MOM by a country mile
Nicolas 6
Hammond 5
Hinshelwood 5
McPhee 7
Virgo 6

 

[Titanic]

Kuipers: 6
El-Abd: 7
Cullip: 4
Mayo: 7
Harding: 5
Hinshelwood: 6
Nicolas: 7
Hammond: 7
Currie: 8
McPhee: 7
Virgo: 6

 

[Kryten]

Kuipers: 6
El-Abd: 7
Cullip: 4
Mayo: 7
Harding: 5
Hinshelwood: 6
Nicolas: 7
Hammond: 7
Currie: 8
McPhee: 6
Virgo: 6