Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Player ratings vs Chelsea
- Thread starter goldstone
- Start date
Ryan 7.5
Schelotto 7
Duffy 6
Dunk 6
Suttner 7
March 5
Propper 6
Stephens 6 - Really hot and cold game. Some really good bits but some bad bits as well.
Kayal 8 MOTM - Absolute class, hopefully he'll start more games
Izquierdo 5
Hemed 6
Gross 6
Murray N/A - Tempting to give a 5 after his good chance that didn't go in anyway was ruled out due to him being offside. Again.
Knockaert N/A - Should have replaced March at half time
Schelotto 7
Duffy 6
Dunk 6
Suttner 7
March 5
Propper 6
Stephens 6 - Really hot and cold game. Some really good bits but some bad bits as well.
Kayal 8 MOTM - Absolute class, hopefully he'll start more games
Izquierdo 5
Hemed 6
Gross 6
Murray N/A - Tempting to give a 5 after his good chance that didn't go in anyway was ruled out due to him being offside. Again.
Knockaert N/A - Should have replaced March at half time
Hampster Gull
Well-known member
- Dec 22, 2010
- 13,465
Kayal was monstrous out there, top top performance
6 - average
Ryan 7
Schelotto 6
Suttner 6
Dunk 7
Duffy 6
March 5
Stephens 7
Propper 6
Kayal 7
Izquierdo 5
Hemed 6
Gross 5
Murray n/a
Knockaert n/a
Thought the first half defensively was excellent. The second for 25 mins, we were basically outplayed.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Ryan 7
Schelotto 6
Suttner 6
Dunk 7
Duffy 6
March 5
Stephens 7
Propper 6
Kayal 7
Izquierdo 5
Hemed 6
Gross 5
Murray n/a
Knockaert n/a
Thought the first half defensively was excellent. The second for 25 mins, we were basically outplayed.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Not seen any replays at all but as I saw it.........
Ryan - 8.5 - MOTM - nothing he could do about the goals from what I could see, and several good saves (and at least a couple of exceptional saves). Good distribution. Turning into a bit of a superstar IMHO
Schelotto - 7.5 - much better from him. Better positioning, some decent tackles, good anticipation and looks good breaking forward. Rapid.
Dunk - 7 - as usual mostly very solid but not sure what he was doing for the first goal (although not seen a replay yet)
Duffy - 7.5 - solid.
Suttner - 7 - unsurprisingly not as effective as against Watford but did well defensively
Stephens - 7 - tough game for him, Davy and Beram. Broke play up well several times but quite a few misplaced passes again
Propper - 6.5 - did ok but didn’t really stand out
Kayal - 6.5 - same as Propper. Great to have him back though, improves our options in CM, maybe he’ll be paired with Dale and Propper can play in the no 10 role against lesser teams if Gross needs a rest. Did his best when obviously told to play further forward when we went behind, but that is when Sam should’ve come on really
Izquierdo - 6.5 - frustrating for him again as didn’t get the ball enough. Very good defensively
March - 5 - very disappointing. No confidence at the moment. Making way too many wrong decisions
Hemed - 7 - won everything in the air, but was so isolated it wasn’t worth much. Absolutely worked his nuts off for the team.
Subs
Knocky - 7.5 - had an immediate impact despite short time on the pitch, couple of good runs and excellent crosses. Looked dangerous.
Murray - 6 - maybe could’ve made more of a couple of decent chances (caught offside for one of them again)
Gross - 6 - no real impact that I recall
Ryan - 8.5 - MOTM - nothing he could do about the goals from what I could see, and several good saves (and at least a couple of exceptional saves). Good distribution. Turning into a bit of a superstar IMHO
Schelotto - 7.5 - much better from him. Better positioning, some decent tackles, good anticipation and looks good breaking forward. Rapid.
Dunk - 7 - as usual mostly very solid but not sure what he was doing for the first goal (although not seen a replay yet)
Duffy - 7.5 - solid.
Suttner - 7 - unsurprisingly not as effective as against Watford but did well defensively
Stephens - 7 - tough game for him, Davy and Beram. Broke play up well several times but quite a few misplaced passes again
Propper - 6.5 - did ok but didn’t really stand out
Kayal - 6.5 - same as Propper. Great to have him back though, improves our options in CM, maybe he’ll be paired with Dale and Propper can play in the no 10 role against lesser teams if Gross needs a rest. Did his best when obviously told to play further forward when we went behind, but that is when Sam should’ve come on really
Izquierdo - 6.5 - frustrating for him again as didn’t get the ball enough. Very good defensively
March - 5 - very disappointing. No confidence at the moment. Making way too many wrong decisions
Hemed - 7 - won everything in the air, but was so isolated it wasn’t worth much. Absolutely worked his nuts off for the team.
Subs
Knocky - 7.5 - had an immediate impact despite short time on the pitch, couple of good runs and excellent crosses. Looked dangerous.
Murray - 6 - maybe could’ve made more of a couple of decent chances (caught offside for one of them again)
Gross - 6 - no real impact that I recall
Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo
I believe in Joe Hendry
- Oct 4, 2003
- 12,070
I wasn't at the game but I haven noticed Stephens tends to blow hot and cold quite a lot during our recent matches. Some great moments, let down by lapses in concentration and too many miss-placed passes. Could it be time to give Kayal a few starts alongside Propper to freshen things up a bit? We've been short in numbers in central midfield due to Kayal and Sidwell both getting injured so Propper and Stephens have had to play a lot of football. Infact i think they both, along with Dunk and Ryan have played every minute of every Premier League game, very hard work in the engine room of our side.
Murray seems to have been watching the Elvis Manu guide to being a striker recently given how many times he's been caught offside.
Would love for Kayal and Propper to be the CM pairing.
GoingUp
Well-known member
Going off MOTD I think they gave us 1 poor effort and it was all Chelsea. Matty Ryan looked to be the best player, other than that they didnt really show us touching the ball!
We actually had 3 near the end. Murray and Gross a step away from nearly putting away a brilliant Knockaert cross, Duffy header that should have been put away, Izquierdo shot that went over.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
kevo
Well-known member
- Mar 8, 2008
- 9,801
Ryan deserves more than 7. Several great saves stopped it being a rout. Nothing he could do about the goals.
As above apart from Ryan 8 & Izquierdo 7. March looked very poor yesterday, surprised he wasn’t taken off earlier.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
No he doesn’t IMO, two good saves, others routine that he would have been disappointed to let in.
No chance with the goals as you say.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Trelford Mills Guide Dog
Active member
- Jun 14, 2008
- 575
Ryan 7.5 [made some top class saves].
Schelotto 6.5
Suttner 6.5
Dunk 7 [lost Morata for the goal, but otherwise very solid].
Duffy 6.5
March 4.5 [looked completely lost on the right].
Stephens 7
Propper 6
Kayal 8 [fantastic first half].
Izquierdo 5
Hemed 6
Schelotto 6.5
Suttner 6.5
Dunk 7 [lost Morata for the goal, but otherwise very solid].
Duffy 6.5
March 4.5 [looked completely lost on the right].
Stephens 7
Propper 6
Kayal 8 [fantastic first half].
Izquierdo 5
Hemed 6
Ryan 7 No chance with the goals
Schelotto 7 Got to a couple of crosses and headed clear under pressure, Bruno would not have got close!
Suttner 7 Good game
Dunk 8 We rely far too much on these two CB's against top sides
Duffy 8 As above
March 4 Very poor closed down every chance we had to attack on his side. Extraordinarily bad decision making for a professional at times.
Stephens 7 Steady
Propper Steady
Kayal 8 MOM
Izquierdo 5 Doesn't appear to want to run past defenders
Hemed 7 Must feel it's a pointless effort keep winning headers as he did yesterday. I actually believe Chelsea allowed him to win them so they could pick up the second ball
Gross n/a
Murray n/a
Knockaert n/a
Hughton 4 You set up the team to play negative. You then complain about conceding you can't expect our defence to defend under such intense circumstances for so long in games. Your subs are only ever like for like why not try something different.
Schelotto 7 Got to a couple of crosses and headed clear under pressure, Bruno would not have got close!
Suttner 7 Good game
Dunk 8 We rely far too much on these two CB's against top sides
Duffy 8 As above
March 4 Very poor closed down every chance we had to attack on his side. Extraordinarily bad decision making for a professional at times.
Stephens 7 Steady
Propper Steady
Kayal 8 MOM
Izquierdo 5 Doesn't appear to want to run past defenders
Hemed 7 Must feel it's a pointless effort keep winning headers as he did yesterday. I actually believe Chelsea allowed him to win them so they could pick up the second ball
Gross n/a
Murray n/a
Knockaert n/a
Hughton 4 You set up the team to play negative. You then complain about conceding you can't expect our defence to defend under such intense circumstances for so long in games. Your subs are only ever like for like why not try something different.
No no, he’s shit. I read it on here after he’d played about 10 minutes.
clippedgull
Hotdogs, extra onions
Ryan 8
Schelotto 6
Duffy 6
Dunk 7
Suttner 6
March 4
Stephens 5
Kayal 6
Propper 5
Izquierdo 6
Hemed 5
Schelotto 6
Duffy 6
Dunk 7
Suttner 6
March 4
Stephens 5
Kayal 6
Propper 5
Izquierdo 6
Hemed 5
Neville's Breakfast
Well-known member
Problem is that last time Stephens had a rest we blew the chance of winning the Championship at Norwich.
VAL1850
Well-known member
Hopefully sky highlights will show more, on channel 402 at 12.30 & 4.30