[Albion] ***Player Ratings vs Bournemouth***

[One Teddy Maybank]

Can't see a thread, apologies if missed it.

6 - average

Ryan - 5 - has to do better on the second.
Alzate - 6 - so adaptable
Bernardo - 6
Dunk - 6
Webster - 5 - back to his normal poor defensive positioning and defending, but okay going forward
AJ - 5 - struggled
Gross - 6 - surprised he was withdrawn, then realised Murray hadn't come on......
Stephens - 5 - bit in and out last evening, some good challenges interspersed with terrible passing
Propper - 7 - buzzed about but weakened as the game went on (probably in despair)
Mooy - 7
Maupay - 5 struggling. No presence, no support, poor decision making, poor first touch. Out of sorts at the moment. could've given 4

Connolly - 5 - silly substitution
March - 6 - showed more than most
Trossard - 5 - king of the pirouette. In fairness no numbers in the box for him to aim for.


Potter - 4 - tactically didn't react, wrong substitutions IMO.

 

[driller]

Can’t be bothered.
So disappointed.

 

[Sarisbury Seagull]

Ryan - 4

Alzate - 7
Webster - 4
Dunk - 5
Bernardo - 6

Propper - 7
Stephens - 4
Mooy - 6

Ali J - 5
Gross - 4
Maupay - 6

Trossard - 6
Connolly - 5
March - 6

 

[Albion Dan]

Ryan 5 Could have done better for the 3rd

Alzate 6 did the best he could but shouldn’t be playing RB

Webster 2 shocking lack of effort to get back to attempt to cover the goal for the 3rd. He visibly slowed down once Ryan had been rounded. Mistakes are one thing but lack of effort inexcusable.

Dunk 6 not looking anywhere near his best

Bernardo 6

Stephens 4 just doesn’t seem to have any fight in him and too slow

Propper 6 lively at times

Mooy 6 kept going

Gross 5 just too slow for this division, get rid

AJ 5 hugged and puffed. Feels like he’s back to the old AJ

Maupay 5 feel sorry for him as has zero support

Subs all 6 none great none terrible.

Potter 1 - a horror show from Potter. Out thought and clearly hasnt got the players believing we are good enough or displaying any mental toughness in the 6 pointers. Have a lot of sympathy with the tools he has at his disposal but he’s making very odd decisions now.

 

[Normandy seagull]

something different- I'm going to rate players by what standard league they should be playing in!


Ryan - championship
Alzate - championship
Bernardo -championship
Dunk - Premier League
Webster - League 1
AJ - Persian Gulf pro league
Gross - Bundesliga 2
Stephens - Championship
Propper - Premier League
Mooy - Premier League
Maupay - Championship

Connolly - League 1
March - Championship
Trossard - Eredivisie


Potter - Championship- sorry but based on last night, you are a "championship numpty"

 

[Is it PotG?]

Ali J, above 3?

Righto.

Bernardo was like Bambi on Ice.

 

[maltaseagull]

Ryan - 5 - Not up to his usual standards. Some sloppy passing and his nervousness spread to the defence.
Alzate - 6 - Can we just agree his best position and play him there rather than 3 different roles every game?
Bernardo - 6 Not his best but ok
Dunk - 5 Not sure what has happened to him. Perhaps he needs Duffy alongside.
Webster - 5 - Seems to play better in a back 3 but should be a sub if we are playing a back 4.
AJ - 5 - I think he is a very skillful lightweight and should play home games only.
Gross - 5 - Not his best and not playing as well this season.
Stephens - 5 - Seems to lose concentration. Was careless too often
Propper - 6 - Oh how I wish he could shoot better, more often
Mooy - 6 -Took his goal well but didn't dominate as he can.
Maupay - 5 Runs around a lot. Didn't we have one of those before?

Connolly -4- Not sure why he came on. Offers little different to Maupay. We need another Striker urgently even if from U23s as long as he can win balls in the air and score.
March - 6 - Should start next game but will probably not even be on the bench such is the scattergun approach to selection.
Trossard - 5 - Seems to have a lot of skill but like about half our side, too lightweight for a midweek battle in January away from home.


Potter - 4 - Should have kicked them out the dressing room at half time. We need a bit more passion about us and he doesn't seem to be getting this.Getting bullied too easily.

 

[Withdean11]

Ryan - 5 - Not a good game
Alzate - 5.5 - I like him a lot, but he's not a right back. Clear we need a new one.
Webster - 4.5 - Certainly not comfortable, but not the worst CB for us last night.
Dunk - 4 - Gets off far too easy on here with fans wearing blue/white specs. It was his poor passing that gave Bournemouth a lift.
Bernardo - 5.5 - Some good tackles, but his delivery is not good enough.
Propper - 6 - Was brilliant for the first 30 mins, pedestrian after that
Stephens - 4.5 - He's all wrong for this team.
Ali J - 4 - Seems to be slipping back to the AJ we are used to.
Gross - 5 - See Propper. But final ball lacking.
Mooy - 6.5 - He is our best player by some distance. It's not even close.
Maupay - 6 - Unlucky not to score twice. But needs to improve the timing of his runs.

March - 5.5 - It's good to see him back from injury, but Championship is his level.
Trossard - 5.5 - Would've preferred to see him on the left. Should be starting.
Connolly - 4.5 - Struggled with Bournemouth sitting deeper.

 

[HalfaSeatOn]

something different- I'm going to rate players by what standard league they should be playing in!


Ryan - championship
Alzate - championship
Bernardo -championship
Dunk - Premier League
Webster - League 1
AJ - Persian Gulf pro league
Gross - Bundesliga 2
Stephens - Championship
Propper - Premier League
Mooy - Premier League
Maupay - Championship

Connolly - League 1
March - Championship
Trossard - Eredivisie


Potter - Championship- sorry but based on last night, you are a "championship numpty"

An interesting take on ratings. Out of interest where would you place Duffy?