Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Player Ratings... Posh v BHA
- Thread starter Trigger
- Start date
Kuipers 6 Kicking was absolute wank. Made a fantastic dave and catches were good. Roberts will play from now on.
Watson 5 ok
Mayo 4 Was at fault for second goal. Better in 2nd half.
Cullip 4 average
Butters 6 good game
Hart 5 not his best
Jones 3 shit again
Carpenter 4 didnt do a lot
Pethick 5 ok
McPhee 6 had a great shot
Knight 7 not at best but got two goals which i suppose got us a point
Wilkinson 5
Watson 5 ok
Mayo 4 Was at fault for second goal. Better in 2nd half.
Cullip 4 average
Butters 6 good game
Hart 5 not his best
Jones 3 shit again
Carpenter 4 didnt do a lot
Pethick 5 ok
McPhee 6 had a great shot
Knight 7 not at best but got two goals which i suppose got us a point
Wilkinson 5
Albion Edd
Brighton til die
Kuipers 6
Watson 5
Cullip 6
Butters 7
Mayo 5
Hart 6
Pethick 5
Carpenter 7
Jones 5
McPhee 7
Knight 9
Wilkinson 6
Watson 5
Cullip 6
Butters 7
Mayo 5
Hart 6
Pethick 5
Carpenter 7
Jones 5
McPhee 7
Knight 9
Wilkinson 6
Last edited:
Kuipers 4: One decent save in second half, but kicking an embarrasment. Needs to have his banana boots replaced.
Watson 5: Got stuck in at times, but still looks wobbly when someone runs at him
Mayo 4: Again lack of pace shows him up, distribution weak, and we looked very vulnerable on the left side all game
Butters 5: At fault for first goal as did not jump and allowed McKenzie a free header. Improved in the second half.
Cullip 5: Not his usual self, seemed jumpy at times, but given the rubbish around him not surprising.
Jones 4: Made the first goal, but was given a free run as their right back had gone AWOL. Passing appalling all game
Carpenter 5: Seems to have gone backwards this season. Even his trademark short passing skills have deserted him
Pethick 4: Anonymous
Hart 6: Ran his socks off as always, and showed a lot of commitment without ever being threatening
McPhee 6: Showed his naivety by constantly being offside, but lots of effort and a superb effort that deserved a goal
Knight 7: Very direct and received little support, took goals well and unlucky not to get a hat trick after lobbing keeper and having it cleared off the line and another effort that went just wide
Watson 5: Got stuck in at times, but still looks wobbly when someone runs at him
Mayo 4: Again lack of pace shows him up, distribution weak, and we looked very vulnerable on the left side all game
Butters 5: At fault for first goal as did not jump and allowed McKenzie a free header. Improved in the second half.
Cullip 5: Not his usual self, seemed jumpy at times, but given the rubbish around him not surprising.
Jones 4: Made the first goal, but was given a free run as their right back had gone AWOL. Passing appalling all game
Carpenter 5: Seems to have gone backwards this season. Even his trademark short passing skills have deserted him
Pethick 4: Anonymous
Hart 6: Ran his socks off as always, and showed a lot of commitment without ever being threatening
McPhee 6: Showed his naivety by constantly being offside, but lots of effort and a superb effort that deserved a goal
Knight 7: Very direct and received little support, took goals well and unlucky not to get a hat trick after lobbing keeper and having it cleared off the line and another effort that went just wide
Reading Posh
Sophisticated rhetorician
From a Posh point of view:
Kuipers 6 - I couldn't understand how he didn't save the second goal
Watson 5 - did okay
Cullip 7 - calm & confident
Butters 5 - does he always jump 6" below his great height?
Mayo 6 - okay
Hart 6 - okay
Pethick 5 - largely invisible to me
Carpenter 7 - had a great 1st half, quiet 2nd
Jones 7 - took the piss 1st half, very pleased to see him get subbed
McPhee 6 - apart from his blistering drive (great save from Tyler) did nowt for me
Knight 8 - scared me, and the Posh defence, shitless every time he got the ball
Wilkinson 6 - did okay
Overall - not the strongest side I've seen this season (based on one performance always dodgy), Knight is shining star - but a lot of god solid players - an open attacking game I thought.
Kuipers 6 - I couldn't understand how he didn't save the second goal
Watson 5 - did okay
Cullip 7 - calm & confident
Butters 5 - does he always jump 6" below his great height?
Mayo 6 - okay
Hart 6 - okay
Pethick 5 - largely invisible to me
Carpenter 7 - had a great 1st half, quiet 2nd
Jones 7 - took the piss 1st half, very pleased to see him get subbed
McPhee 6 - apart from his blistering drive (great save from Tyler) did nowt for me
Knight 8 - scared me, and the Posh defence, shitless every time he got the ball
Wilkinson 6 - did okay
Overall - not the strongest side I've seen this season (based on one performance always dodgy), Knight is shining star - but a lot of god solid players - an open attacking game I thought.
Fran Hagarty
Well-known member
Kuipers 4
Watson 5
Mayo 4
Cullip 4
Butters 5
Hart 6
Jones 4
Carpenter 4
Pethick 3
McPhee 6
Knight 7
Wilkinson 5
Watson 5
Mayo 4
Cullip 4
Butters 5
Hart 6
Jones 4
Carpenter 4
Pethick 3
McPhee 6
Knight 7
Wilkinson 5
Padders
New member
Knight exceleent 8
McPhee worked hard unlucky not to score 6
The rest nowhere
McPhee worked hard unlucky not to score 6
The rest nowhere
Kneon Light
Well-known member
"Watson 5: Got stuck in at times"
"Watson 5 - did okay"
Without wishing to seem rude, which game were you watching?
Every time the left winger ran at watson he just ran backwards and didn't stop a single cross. Mayo was poor but at least he attempted to tackle. Both goals came from crosses from their left, as did the one disallowed for offside.
When Adams was in charge he made a lot about the players "keeping the shirt". I'd like to know exactly what Hinsh has done to deserve losing his place. At least he can tackle. I know his distribution is poor but surely the primary job of being a defender is to defend!!!
"Watson 5 - did okay"
Without wishing to seem rude, which game were you watching?
Every time the left winger ran at watson he just ran backwards and didn't stop a single cross. Mayo was poor but at least he attempted to tackle. Both goals came from crosses from their left, as did the one disallowed for offside.
When Adams was in charge he made a lot about the players "keeping the shirt". I'd like to know exactly what Hinsh has done to deserve losing his place. At least he can tackle. I know his distribution is poor but surely the primary job of being a defender is to defend!!!
berkshire seagull
New member
Christ some have rearly lost the plot it seems grrrrrr
Kuipers 4 kicking cost us the 2nd goal.
Watson 6 nothing wrong,defended well.
Mayo 5 distribution appalling again.
Cullip 6 distribution let him down again
Butters 6 solid and dependable,even against pace.
Hart 6 worked hard.usual.
Jones 4 did well for our first goal,otherwise 1 point
Carpenter 7 had a better game and got stuck in.
Pethick 5 solid but gave the ball away to often
McPhee 7 gives his all,unlucky with shot late on.
Knight 8 worked really hard,chasing back aswell.
Wilkinson 6 chased around and looked keen.
McGhee 8 for changing tactics and having a go.
Crowd 8 I love terracing and good day out.
Watson 6 nothing wrong,defended well.
Mayo 5 distribution appalling again.
Cullip 6 distribution let him down again
Butters 6 solid and dependable,even against pace.
Hart 6 worked hard.usual.
Jones 4 did well for our first goal,otherwise 1 point
Carpenter 7 had a better game and got stuck in.
Pethick 5 solid but gave the ball away to often
McPhee 7 gives his all,unlucky with shot late on.
Knight 8 worked really hard,chasing back aswell.
Wilkinson 6 chased around and looked keen.
McGhee 8 for changing tactics and having a go.
Crowd 8 I love terracing and good day out.
Kneon Light
Well-known member
"Watson 6 nothing wrong,defended well"
I'd hate to see him play badly then!
I'd hate to see him play badly then!