Player Ratings - Oldham?

[blue and white army]

Anyone got any for those fans that couldn't make it? How did Seb get on?

Cheers

 

[RM-Taylor]

Thought Dicker had a poor game, often losing possession and committing wayward passes. Murray also looks very lightweight under pressure from any opposing player.

Overall;

Brezovan 7
Calderon 7
Elphick 6
El-Abd 6
Painter 6
Carole 8
Crofts 6
Navarro 6
Dicker 5
Bennett 8
Murray 6

Virgo and Hart not on long enough

 

[Chesney Christ]

Elphick 6 - standard Elphick performance without any mistakes
El Abd 6 - standard El Abd performance without any mistakes

You're such a sad little man.

 

[The Wizard]

You're such a sad little man.

He can't admit that they played well, because they are DONKEYS after all!

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Very harsh abuse for TCB. What the f*** did he do to deserve that

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Totally uncalled for imo.

 

[Chesney Christ]

What?

They both play a consistent game week after week. However, both are capable of making massive cock-ups. Today they didn't. What the f*** is your problem with that?

I think its just the fact you cannot EVER give them any credit. I'm not suggesting they were brilliant today, but even when they are, your remarks are so back-handed and childish.

How did you think Elphick played against Colchester away then? Superbly, like the rest of us, or "well I suppose he didn't make any f***-ups today, 7." ?

How did you think El-Abd and Elphick played against Charlton away??

You're just someone who has made their mind up about EVERYTHING. You're pure Daily Mail. Everything is set in stone, everything is black and white and if someone is bad in their first two games, they're bad forever.

Rather than judging someone over the course of weeks, months, years... you judge them on a warm-up in a pre-season friendly.

You were totally wrong about Brezovan, you were wrong about Crofts (not that I am a particular fan of his myself) and you were totally wrong about Poyet and you are totally wrong every time we lose a match and you demand your laughable "wholesale clearouts".

 

[Chesney Christ]

Thankyou - I quite clearly wrote "5 is average" at the top of and then gave both of those players a HIGHER mark than average. How the hell am I meant to be criticising them. Looks like NF9 has a new rival in the nsc spastic stakes.

Because even when "praising" them you cannot possibly bring yourself to make a positive comment.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Trifle harsh CC

 

[Ninja Elephant]

I think its just the fact you cannot EVER give them any credit. I'm not suggesting they were brilliant today, but even when they are, your remarks are so back-handed and childish.

How did you think Elphick played against Colchester away then? Superbly, like the rest of us, or "well I suppose he didn't make any f***-ups today, 7." ?

How did you think El-Abd and Elphick played against Charlton away??

You're just someone who has made their mind up about EVERYTHING. You're pure Daily Mail. Everything is set in stone, everything is black and white and if someone is bad in their first two games, they're bad forever.

Rather than judging someone over the course of weeks, months, years... you judge them on a warm-up in a pre-season friendly.

You were totally wrong about Brezovan, you were wrong about Crofts (not that I am a particular fan of his myself) and you were totally wrong about Poyet and you are totally wrong every time we lose a match and you demand your laughable "wholesale clearouts".

A rational response to childish namecalling.

I won't argue with the Badger, though, because I didn't make the trip up there today so I can't rate the players. Much respect to those who made the trip today.

 

[Chesney Christ]

Trifle harsh CC

Yeah probably a bit.

 

[DerbyGull]

Carole: glad to see him growing in confidence, hope he builds on this.

To the guy who was ripping the shit out of Gregan, you really did make me laugh out loud.

 

[227 BHA]

Trifle harsh CC

A trifle? I wouldn't wanna be on the receiving end of him really laying in then!

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Are you on a wind-up? Read the thread from the top and see who made the first insult

He called you a sad little man. You referred to him as a spastic. Proportion?....