Player Ratings -Cardiff (A)

[Skaville]

Stockdale - 5
Bruno - 5
Dunk - 6
Goldson - 5
Calderon - 4
Stephens - 5
Crofts - 5
Sidwell - 4
Skalak - 6
Knockaert- 5
Zamora - 6

Rosenior - 6
Hemed - 5
Baldock - 5

Hughton - 4

From the telly (thankfully)

 

[sdmartin1]

Stockdale-4- Shocking today, conditions may not have helped but should have done better for the first goal imo despite poor concentration from the defence and the 2nd goal was all his own error, which makes it extremely difficult away from home- hopefully his one bad performance of the season...

Bruno-6
Goldson-5
Dunk-5
Calderon-4

Skalak-5
Stephens-5
Sidwell-4
Crofts-5
Knockaert-5

Bobby Z-5

Subs: Hemed-5
Rosenior-6
Baldock-4
Crofts-5

 

[wallyback]

Stockdale - 5
Bruno - 6
Dunk - 6
Goldson - 5
Calderon - 3
Stephens - 6
Crofts - 4
Sidwell - 4
Skalak - 6
Knockaert- 5
Zamora - 4

Rosenior - 5
Hemed - 5
Baldock - 5

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Stockdale 5 His worst performance of the season but I'm not going to lay into him, we need our goalkeeper to get his head right after a dip in standard.
Bruno 5 No impact on the game which was disappointing, a collective off day.
Dunk 4 Stuff happens.
Goldson 5 Not deserving of the criticism he's going to get from some.
Calderon 5 He did nothing wrong.
Stephens 5 No impact in the game, he's the player most in need of a rest.
Sidwell 3 Well, it'll get better.
Crofts 3 God awful, a real disappointment.
Knockaert 5 Nevermind.
Skalak 7 Our Man of the Match, which doesn't really mean anything.
Zamora 4 Oh, Bobby Zamora.

Subs
Rosenior 6 Welcome back Liam, a touch of class.
Hemed 5 Did nothing to distinguish himself.
Baldock 0 Not certain he was on the pitch.

Hughton 3 Got it all wrong today.

 

[big nuts]

Stockdale - 3
Bruno - 5
Calderon - 4
Dunk - 5.5
Goldson - 4
Stephens - 5
Sidwell - 4
Crofts - 6
Knockeart - 4
Skalak - 6.5
Zamora - 4.5

Rosenior - 5
Hemed - 5
Baldock - 5

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

6=average

Stockdale - 4
Bruno - 5
Calderon - 4
Dunk - 4
Goldson - 5
Crofts - 5
Sidwell - 4
Stephens - 6
Knockaert - 5
Skalak - 6
Zamora - 4

Hemed - 5
Rosenoir - 6
Baldock - N/A

 

[big nuts]

Stockdale 5 His worst performance of the season but I'm not going to lay into him, we need our goalkeeper to get his head right after a dip in standard.
Bruno 5 No impact on the game which was disappointing, a collective off day.
Dunk 4 Stuff happens.
Goldson 5 Not deserving of the criticism he's going to get from some.
Calderon 5 He did nothing wrong.
Stephens 5 No impact in the game, he's the player most in need of a rest.
Sidwell 3 Well, it'll get better.
Crofts 3 God awful, a real disappointment.
Knockaert 5 Nevermind.
Skalak 7 Our Man of the Match, which doesn't really mean anything.
Zamora 4 Oh, Bobby Zamora.

Subs
Rosenior 6 Welcome back Liam, a touch of class.
Hemed 5 Did nothing to distinguish himself.
Baldock 0 Not certain he was on the pitch.

Hughton 3 Got it all wrong today.

Confirmation if we needed any that you have an agenda against Baldock. Give it up, if you don't rate him fair enough but to suggest he was worse than Stockdale makes no sense to me.

 

[WhingForPresident]

Stockdale 3

Bruno 5
Goldson 4
Dunk 4
Calde 4

Knockaert 4
Sidwell 2
Crofts 3
Stephens 4
Skalak 6

Zamora 3

Rosenior 5
Baldock n/a (didn't even notice him out there)
Hemed 3

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

Stockdale 1

Bruno 3
Goldson 3
Dunk 3
Calderon 4

Knockeart 5
Crofts 2
Sidwell 1
Stephens 4
Skalak 5

Zamora 5

 

[Luke93]

Stockdale 3

Bruno 5
Dunk 4
Goldson 4
Calderon 3

Knockeart 5
Stephens 5.5
Sidwell 3
Crofts 4
Skalak 5

Zamora 5

 

[DJ NOBO]

We were sh*t. It doesn't happen often but we were today . No point dissecting it . Let's move on

 

[fleet]

Stockdale - 5
Bruno - 5
Dunk - 6
Goldson - 5
Calderon - 4
Stephens - 5
Crofts - 5
Sidwell - 4
Skalak - 6
Knockaert- 5
Zamora - 6

Rosenior - 6
Hemed - 5
Baldock - 5

Hughton - 4

From the telly (thankfully)

Take all these 6s to 5s and that's bout right

 

[Mackenzie]

Stockdale 4
Bruno 5
Dunk 5
Goodson 5
Calderon 5
Skalak 7
Stephens 6
Crofts 4
Sidwell 4
Knockaert 6
Zamora 4

Poor day at the office, Cardiff adapted better to the windy conditions. Liked the look of Skalak.

 

[sussex_guy2k2]

Stockdale 3
Bruno 5
Goldson 5
Dunk 5
Calderon 3
Knockaert 5
Stephens 5
Crofts 3
Sidwell 3
Skalak 6
Zamora 4

Baldock 5
Hemed 5
Rosenior 6

Hughton 3

 

[Bladders]

Stockdale 3
Bruno 5
Goldson 5
Dunk 5
Calderon 3
Knockaert 5
Stephens 5
Crofts 3
Sidwell 3
Skalak 6
Zamora 4

Baldock 5
Hemed 5
Rosenior 6

Hughton 3

This, though I would give Crofts a 2

 

[darkwolf666]

Stockdale 1

Bruno 3
Goldson 3
Dunk 3
Calderon 4

Knockeart 5
Crofts 2
Sidwell 1
Stephens 4
Skalak 5

Zamora 5

Those rating are just pathetic and nothing short of vindictive! How can you give a player 1 - what's the 1 for, putting his shirt on the right way round? Ridiculous...

 

[Trelford Mills Guide Dog]

Stockdale 5
Bruno 5
Dunk 5
Goldson 4
Calderon 4
Skalak 7
Stephens 5
Crofts 4
Sidwell 4
Knockaert 5
Zamora 5

Apart from the first 15 minutes a very poor performance all round.

Bizarrely the 5 in midfield left big gaps for Cardiff to exploit, and our defence stood off giving them lots of space and the opportunity to shoot.

Skalak [and our support] was the only bright spot for me.

 

[um bongo molongo]

Stockdale 3

Bruno 5
Dunk 4
Goldson 4
Calderon 3

Knockeart 5
Stephens 5.5
Sidwell 3
Crofts 4
Skalak 5

Zamora 5

I'd give skalak a 6 but otherwise I'd second these. Don't think it's any coincidence that our last poor run came when we had a glut of fixtures - worried that this run of 5 games in 16 days doesn't see us do the same. Certainly asking Calde to play tues night in hull then sat lunchtime in Cardiff looked an ask too far. Hopefully the players coming back can freshen us up (rosenior looked lively which was good to see).

 

[Sarisbury Seagull]

Stockdale - 4

Bruno - 5
Goldson - 5
Dunk - 4
Calderon - 3

Crofts - 3
Sidwell - 3
Stephens - 5

Knockeart - 5
Skalak - 7
Zamora - 5

Rosenior - 6
Hemed - 4
Baldock - n/a

Hughton - 3

 

[big nuts]

Whilst Crofts wasn't fantastic, he really put in a shift yesterday. He probably won't be with us next season but for sheer hard work and the fact he kept possession c. 90% of the time albeit sideways and back I do fee it's harsh to mark him below 5, I can only guess people marking on pre-conceived ideas rather than actually watching the game.