- Thread starter
- #61
Im pretty sure Tau got some very nice ratings and comments after the Newport game. He played really well.
He’s got pedigree and will come good for us.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Player ratings Blackpool (h) FA Cup R4
- Thread starter DJ NOBO
- Start date
Im pretty sure Tau got some very nice ratings and comments after the Newport game. He played really well.
He’s got pedigree and will come good for us.
I'm sorry but what pedigree? Being bang average in the Belgian league? People on here slag off Trossard no end, don't think he's up to it e.t.c. but remember, he at least stood out in Belgium... Same with Jahanbaksh in the dutch league. If Tau wasn't already our player his performances in Belgium wouldn't have even put him on our radar.
Walton 4 made me nervous all the time
Veltman 7 getting to be real quality
Dunk 5 not at his best
Webster 7 assured
Burn 4 makes me nervous
Propper 5
Bissouma 8 real quality - if he could shoot like that more often he would be one hell of a player
Tau 4 - if he is the answer it is a silly question - give him time but not in first team
Macallister 7 getting better and better
Alzate 4 what went wrong, nothing like early season form
Zequiri 4 doesn’t look near the quality
Subs
Maupay 6 he needs to take chances
Trossard 4 doesn’t look near the early season player
March 7 if he could put that giant ball or shot in ...
Gross 6
Veltman 7 getting to be real quality
Dunk 5 not at his best
Webster 7 assured
Burn 4 makes me nervous
Propper 5
Bissouma 8 real quality - if he could shoot like that more often he would be one hell of a player
Tau 4 - if he is the answer it is a silly question - give him time but not in first team
Macallister 7 getting better and better
Alzate 4 what went wrong, nothing like early season form
Zequiri 4 doesn’t look near the quality
Subs
Maupay 6 he needs to take chances
Trossard 4 doesn’t look near the early season player
March 7 if he could put that giant ball or shot in ...
Gross 6
aolstudios
Well-known member
Walton - 6
Webster - 6.5
Dunk - 6
Burn - 6
Veltman - 7.5 - MoM
Bissouma - 7. 5
Propper - 6. 5
Alzate - 5.5
Tau - 5.5
Mac Allister - 7
Zeqiri - 5.5
March - 6
Maupay - 5
Trossard - 5.5
Gross - 6
Webster - 6.5
Dunk - 6
Burn - 6
Veltman - 7.5 - MoM
Bissouma - 7. 5
Propper - 6. 5
Alzate - 5.5
Tau - 5.5
Mac Allister - 7
Zeqiri - 5.5
March - 6
Maupay - 5
Trossard - 5.5
Gross - 6
blue-shifted
Banned
Agree with all of that
Milano
Well-known member
Lots bigging Veltman up, he’s ‘ok’ IMO, however for all his good work today take a look at their goal, why is bissouma having to sprint from CM to RB when Veltman is jogging in no mans land? Then when the cross comes in he’s again in a position of zero impact, not marking anyone and not cutting it out. He’s a DEFENDER first, he’s no Bruno.
All starters 6s expect Bissouma who is an 8. He’s a champions league player and I’m gutted that us fans are unlikely to see him in the flesh at the Amex again in the stripes.
Maupay a 4, an EPL striker doesn’t miss that.
As for slagging Trossard - if Maupay and Gross score, they both should, he has 2 assists within 10 minutes....
All starters 6s expect Bissouma who is an 8. He’s a champions league player and I’m gutted that us fans are unlikely to see him in the flesh at the Amex again in the stripes.
Maupay a 4, an EPL striker doesn’t miss that.
As for slagging Trossard - if Maupay and Gross score, they both should, he has 2 assists within 10 minutes....
Wardy's twin
Well-known member
- Oct 21, 2014
- 8,876
because he shoots when he can (or at least he seems to rather than pass it around)
I have not rated players today, but I am hopeful that players don't get their feedback on how they did from this forum!!! Feedback of the coach matters, not what a bunch of drunks type into the computer.
I think the frustration is that Tau's first game with us looked very very promising and he has since been going backwards instead of adjusting and going forward... He has because a proper player under Potter... struggle to control the ball and pass it back to your defender!!!! J/K mostly, but a genuine question: Does Potter sap the creativity of players and force them to conform to a strict way of playing?
The sheeps are more interested in talking about how tired his eyes look. Strange.
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,146
Walton 6: Not much to do. Good positioning for the free kick allowed him to make a decent save. Not sure whether he should have come out for the cross for the goal. Looked a bit in two minds from the replay,
Veltman 7 MOTM : Very very good - great signing
Webster 6: Solid
Dunk 6: Solid
Burn 5.5: Not solid enough. Gave away too many free kicks, some were soft, but others were from being out of position.
Bissouma 7: What a goal, that's another £5m on the asking price. The rest of the game was a walk in the park for him
Propper 6: Looking better each time I see him. some decent passes and even some attacking runs!
Tau 5: Not a good game for him. Pinging it into his feet, doesn't help. He isn't a target man.
Ally Mac 6: Had a real opportunity to stake a claim for the first 11and fluffed his lines a bit (as did the rest of the team tbf)
Alzate 6: Scored the winner.. Congrats on his first albion goal, but not much to add
Zeqiri 5: Not the answer. Regardless of the question.
Subs:
Trossard 5.5: Good and bad in equal measure.
March: 6 Solid. A couple of good crosses which were wasted on our forward line..
Maupay 5: Exactly how many gilt edged chances does he need? shockingly wasteful.
Gross: 6: Solid
Veltman 7 MOTM : Very very good - great signing
Webster 6: Solid
Dunk 6: Solid
Burn 5.5: Not solid enough. Gave away too many free kicks, some were soft, but others were from being out of position.
Bissouma 7: What a goal, that's another £5m on the asking price. The rest of the game was a walk in the park for him
Propper 6: Looking better each time I see him. some decent passes and even some attacking runs!
Tau 5: Not a good game for him. Pinging it into his feet, doesn't help. He isn't a target man.
Ally Mac 6: Had a real opportunity to stake a claim for the first 11and fluffed his lines a bit (as did the rest of the team tbf)
Alzate 6: Scored the winner.. Congrats on his first albion goal, but not much to add
Zeqiri 5: Not the answer. Regardless of the question.
Subs:
Trossard 5.5: Good and bad in equal measure.
March: 6 Solid. A couple of good crosses which were wasted on our forward line..
Maupay 5: Exactly how many gilt edged chances does he need? shockingly wasteful.
Gross: 6: Solid
Blackpool played well, and we didnt, but got the job done, either minds are on Wednesday already or the players weren't up for it, it didn't look like they were, just a bit vague with the usual lack of incisiveness
Walton : Not a busy afternoon, a decent save from the free kick and seems to have been watching Ryan in Ducking from the shot that was the goal, why don't keepers stand up?
Veltman : Good to firm
Webster : firm
Dunk : firm
Burn : soft
Bissouma : Great strike. I can't help but feel he's being held back by Potters instruction. Post match comments kind of backed that up. THere's more in there than playing as a sweeper,
Propper : Looking great, again, slow start but good in the second half, his run to the byline and cut back were superb.
Trossard : average, by his standards, perfect cross for Maupay to pass to the keeper, a few good balls, but somehow got nailed to the ground when Propper cut back to him. Or his positioning was all wrong.
Tau 5: Not a good game , too early to tell where and how he'll be best used.
Ally Mac 6: looking like the player we thought he would be all of a sudden
Alzate 6: nothing. Apart from the ball bouncing off his arse.
Zeqiri 5: Not a good day, like Tau, needs to acclimatise and equally be understood by coaching staff.
Subs:
Trossard : Good and bad in equal measure.
March: Meh, failed to beat his man several times and a shot that woke the dog up at 3am as it hit our back window.
Maupay : ****ING SHIT. Sorry, Stumpy TIm is better. Whats wrong with him? He need s a Ctrl Alt delete. I seriously think he whinged it last season and now he's been found out.
Gross: Sound, as always.
Walton : Not a busy afternoon, a decent save from the free kick and seems to have been watching Ryan in Ducking from the shot that was the goal, why don't keepers stand up?
Veltman : Good to firm
Webster : firm
Dunk : firm
Burn : soft
Bissouma : Great strike. I can't help but feel he's being held back by Potters instruction. Post match comments kind of backed that up. THere's more in there than playing as a sweeper,
Propper : Looking great, again, slow start but good in the second half, his run to the byline and cut back were superb.
Trossard : average, by his standards, perfect cross for Maupay to pass to the keeper, a few good balls, but somehow got nailed to the ground when Propper cut back to him. Or his positioning was all wrong.
Tau 5: Not a good game , too early to tell where and how he'll be best used.
Ally Mac 6: looking like the player we thought he would be all of a sudden
Alzate 6: nothing. Apart from the ball bouncing off his arse.
Zeqiri 5: Not a good day, like Tau, needs to acclimatise and equally be understood by coaching staff.
Subs:
Trossard : Good and bad in equal measure.
March: Meh, failed to beat his man several times and a shot that woke the dog up at 3am as it hit our back window.
Maupay : ****ING SHIT. Sorry, Stumpy TIm is better. Whats wrong with him? He need s a Ctrl Alt delete. I seriously think he whinged it last season and now he's been found out.
Gross: Sound, as always.
Silverhatch
Well-known member
Thought Zeqiri looked ok. Worked very hard and had 2 or 3 goes at goal. Veltman excellent.
saafend_seagull
Well-known member
Tau and zekiri should not be near our first team. Very embarrassing and exactly why we are firmly in the relegation mix.
Zekiri is young so a loan spell to bottom half championship should be a priority.
Propper glimpses of quick passing also shows why he should be starting.
When is andone back ?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Zekiri is young so a loan spell to bottom half championship should be a priority.
Propper glimpses of quick passing also shows why he should be starting.
When is andone back ?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
maltaseagull
Well-known member
Walton 6 Did ok .
Veltman 5. Not up to his usual standard but still got forward well.
Dunk 6 ok
Webster 6 ok
Burn 6 ok
Propper 6
Bissouma 7 He got a shot on target!!!!!
Tau 4 After all the fanfare he was poor.
Macallister 6 He is going to be a regular starter but like the entire squad, needs to improve his shooting.
Alzate 5 Continues to promise more than he delivers.
Zequiri 4 nowhere near good enough for a PL place.
Subs
Maupay 4 I was hoping that the last goal would bring back his confidence. Didn't happen.
Trossard 4 Like Alzate. Promises lots, delivers little.
March 6 As always gets some good crosses in and more poor ones.
Gross 5 Not sure why he came on. Would rather have seen Moder or Khadra given a showing.
Veltman 5. Not up to his usual standard but still got forward well.
Dunk 6 ok
Webster 6 ok
Burn 6 ok
Propper 6
Bissouma 7 He got a shot on target!!!!!
Tau 4 After all the fanfare he was poor.
Macallister 6 He is going to be a regular starter but like the entire squad, needs to improve his shooting.
Alzate 5 Continues to promise more than he delivers.
Zequiri 4 nowhere near good enough for a PL place.
Subs
Maupay 4 I was hoping that the last goal would bring back his confidence. Didn't happen.
Trossard 4 Like Alzate. Promises lots, delivers little.
March 6 As always gets some good crosses in and more poor ones.
Gross 5 Not sure why he came on. Would rather have seen Moder or Khadra given a showing.
Dolph Ins
Well-known member
Lots of people shouting for Moder and Khadra to be given a chance but when GP gives Tau, Mcalli and Zequiri a chance they are binned off in seconds. Do people really think that very young players can come to a new team in a new league in a new country and even for 2 of them a new continent and not need a bit of time. Normally they would have been given a month or 2 training and maybe an u23 match but because of injuries or whatever 2 of them were thown in with very little preperation. FWIW I really liked Mcalli, great corners providing 2 good scoring opportunities and not bad all round play including an assist. Zequiri looks a problem for defenses to track and Tau looked like it was maybe too early.
He has the same number of goals in the PL this season, as Danny Ings, Marcus Rashford, Alexandre Lacazette and Ollie Watkins. More than Raheem Sterling, Sadie Mane or Tammy Abraham.
Have they all been ‘found out’ too?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/top-scorers
He has the same number of goals in the PL this season, as Danny Ings, Marcus Rashford, Alexandre Lacazette and Ollie Watkins. More than Raheem Sterling, Sadie Mane or Tammy Abraham.
Have they all been ‘found out’ too?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/top-scorers
I'm not interestd in anyone else, it's utterly irrelevant, He's missed 5 times more sitters than he's scored, and half of those were penalties. That's not very good
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
Harsh on Trossard, set up two sitters (well that’s I how saw it), are you marking him down because Maupay and Gross fluffed them?
Oh and Burn 6 and Veltman 5? Really? Must have been watching a different game to you
It isn’t at all irrelevant. Click the link. It illustrates whether your expectations are reasonable.
How would you like us to sign a striker with a better shot accuracy than Vardy, and a better goal conversion rate than Harry Kane...?
A few seasons ago Pascal Gross was rightly lauded after an excellent season. His stats for ground covered were hugely impressive and included some really tough jogs around the pitch to take corners and free kicks.
The things that have frustrated me the most about Muapay this season in general is his lack of movement in the box. It isn't always easy to judge on the TV, but there appears to be too many occasions when he is standing pointing and not making space for himself. He has three penalties in his 7 goals, I really hope that is the end of this, as the misses have been really poor.
Towards the end of the Man City game he found himself on the edge of the area, with their keeper off the line and two defenders closing in on him. He could have tried to lob the keeper, it could have been a wonder goal, a Row Z lump or a corner flag troubler. We will never know he was meekly dispossesed. Good for the stats though.
Same again this week against a tiring Blackpool defence. This time three defenders backing off. It is asking an awful lot of a striker to score from this position, I know. The outcome was another tame surrendering of the ball, good for the stats though.
I thought he started the season well and his link up play in the first couple of games was strong, but he has done nothing since and one assist hardly suggests he is sacrificing himself for the team.
I suspect that the much villified Connolly offers more long term, once he is fully fit, sadly neither of the starters on Saturday look ready to challenge for a starting place. I wonder if Maupay needs to feel a little more pressure to justify his place in the team, some players seem to thrive on this.