[Albion] MOST Disappointing player over the season - Poll

[chaileyjem]

I'd forgotten that.

so had i. Had a nagging feeling he had been so looked it up.

 

[MORTY]

Who the hell voted for Ryan??

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Who the hell voted for Ryan??

The resident wind up merchant.

 

[FatSuperman]

Could we at least name the thread title?

Perhaps:

Who was the least ****ing heroic of our heroes?

 

[Screaming J]

Decided not to vote. With 15 minutes to go at Goodison and in the grip of some extreme emotions, I would - if offered the choice - have voted for AK. Definitely seems to have sorted a few things out while he was suspended.

Everyone is therefore excused in the continuing miasma of post staying up euphoria.

 

[Harry Wilson's tackle]

Oh goody, another poll.

Shit thread. I'm out.

 

[Frankie]

Not quite sure how anybody could be disappointed in anybody in the squad , every time a player was needed to step in , they did , and didn't let anyone down , obviously players had the odd poor game but we're playing in the best league in the world now , to single somebody out after a season like this is plain ridiculous , obviously IMO

 

[The Andy Naylor Fan Club]

A message from Solly to those who voted for him.....

 

[This is me]

Solly March - an average championship player, not up to the top flight.
Hopefully we will cash in soon

 

[hitony]

Dreadful poll.

I'm far more disappointed in all those who voted than any of the players.

Where is the option for ALL of them? after all.......we failed to win the prem!!! As expected....clearly!

 

[Barham's tash]

Solly, Solly March (repeat to fade - like his career if he doesn’t buck his ideas up...)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Barham's tash]

IMO this thread shouldnt exsist.

Frustrating to see Knockaert and March being touted as disapointing, when clearly their roles in a team fghting to stay in the divsion are going to be a little different to roles in a team going for promotion.

Both have had to do a lot more defending this season and will have been reigned in on their attacking play. With better full backs behind them, I think we will see a lot more from them next season. Anyone who thinks they were going to smash this league were a little deluded IMO.

FWIW I voted March because in comparison to AK who started slowly, got to grips with what being a winger for us at this level means and then excelled in later games, March has gone backwards IMHO.

Yes he needs confidence but what he doesn’t have compared to our other wingers is enough pace. They can both commit themselves higher up the pitch knowing they can get back still. March can’t and that’s why unless he doubles down and works on it he won’t make it at this level.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Trevor]

Voted Knockaert . In fairness, in the final few matches he played rather well. I felt that too often his attitude seemed wrong. This poll for me is very much achievement vs expectation so there are definitely players in the list that have contributed less - but I had hoped that AK would have been ever-present barring injury or suspension and would have wanted to see him make chances in most matches - he didn't do as well as that. I hope he does next season

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

One of the most heart sinking threads on NSC for a long time.

 

[Noah All]

Reluctantly voted for Solly. Not in the sense that he let us down, no-one did that. I just expected a bit more of him.
For me the most disappointing thing was that on occasions he didn't seem to know what to do when he had the ball.

 

[oldalbiongirl]

Miserable thread . A great season. Looking forward onwards and upwards.

 

[Lush]

I'm disappointed that Sam Baldock didn't do enough in training to at least get a regular place on the bench. Was convinced that he'd get some great goals this year. Even put his name on my shirt

 

[Kaiser_Soze]

I voted Kayal.

Not because I think he was poor, just didn't kick on unlike Stephens. They were the exceptional centre mid partnership in the championship for me....

To be fair he was injured for large portions of the season which hasn't helped but Pröpper had been superb.

 

[Kalimantan Gull]

I didn't think I'd vote on this poll, as they've all been great, and as I scrolled down the list of names I was sure I wouldn't. And then I saw Solly's name. I love Solly, and I don't think he's let us down this season, I think he's done whats been asked of him and been a decent contributor. But, I thought Solly was going to be great, a premier league star, and he hasn't been and I don't think he's going to be ever. He's my biggest disappointment, but only because of my high expectations, and if you're reading Solly, you really did make a good contribution this season. If that shot against Arsenal had been a couple of inches to the left - hell you can still do it!!

 

[beorhthelm]

and who voted for Bong? arguably most improved player.