Mike Dean Again!

[Thunder Bolt]

Do we actually know that the linesman wasn't the one who said it was in the area?

Surely Dean would have checked via his mic?

We can't know exactly, but watch his arms. He doesn't move them at all to indicate a penalty, or even a foul.

 

[Superphil]

Do we actually know that the linesman wasn't the one who said it was in the area?

Surely Dean would have checked via his mic?

Edit; FA guidelines.

If the foul is INSIDE the penalty area
- the assistant referee should raise the flag in the same hand that will be used for the remainder of the signal and agitate/wave the flag to indicate a foul has been committed
- the flag should NOT be placed across the chest.
- where available it is recommended that the electronic beep is used and/or the‘communication system’ is used to advise “penalty, penalty, penalty” following the signal for the foul the assistant referee should make a clear physical movement along the touchline towards the corner flag post keeping alert in case the referee does not see or over-rules the flag signal
- If the referee awards the penalty the assistant referee should stand just in front of the corner flag post until the situation is calm and only then move to the standard position

Read more at http://www.surreyfa.com/news/2014/jul/new-fa-guidelines-for-awarding-a-penalty#M6hDqsKDVVylZUHC.

 

[Eric Youngs Contact Lense]

Doesn't the linesman put his flag across his chest to indicate a penalty, if he believes it is on? He didn't indicate in any way, maybe because he is competent at his job.

Maybe Dean asked if the challenge was in the area over the mic on the basis that he himself had seen the handball . That meant linesman did not flag for penalty?

 

[Sheebo]

Why did the linesman not indicate it was outside the box, he was in line with the incident and didn't flag for a penalty, he knew it wasn't, why didn't he tell Dean?

I bet he did, but The Complete And Utter Shyster is such an arrogant **** he more than likely thought the lino was wrong and decided to go with his own view.

Anyone can make a mistake but what I've just seen him do on the Channel 5 highlights is disgraceful.

The Barnsley defender complains at his utterly shithouse decision and Dean points at the lino implying he made the call. Then you see the replay and the lino actually had kept his flag down while Dean was FORTY YARDS behind play and wrongly blowing his whistle.

This nob should be reffing nothing games. He should be learning how to ref properly at the Abbey Stadium or Fratton Park, the useless tosser.

In the Leeds game the handball was obvioius but the ref should have gione to the assistant and asked if it was in or out of the area as he was directly in line as opposed to the ref being 40yds away due to a long clearance from rthe Leeds defence.

The whole incident is Bizaare? The Lino would / should be flagging vigorously if he's seen it - he clearly doesn't. Dean blows very early too - I'd say Dean gave it and Dean only. I'd also say there wasn't any communication between him and the Lino but he basically blames the Lino?! He should be going over there to have a 30 sec discussion as to whether the Lino thought it was inside or out - seems to me the Lino didn't even think it was handball. Very, very ODD!!!!

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

Can't wait for Dean to be announced as reffing Huddersfield v Albion.

 

[BBassic]

They made a good point on the Ch. 5 show that it's pretty insulting to the Championship that its ok for the PL to send their shit refs down here.

 

[BensGrandad]

Son told me he is doing our game v Newcastle not sure if that is true but what I dont understand is if he is considered niot good enough fior the Premier why nis he good enough for the Championship. He is either capable or not no half measures demotion from Premier should mean a suspension fora few weeks to rethink his ideas.

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

Son told me he is doing our game v Newcastle not sure if that is true but what I dont understand is if he is considered niot good enough fior the Premier why nis he good enough for the Championship. He is either capable or not no half measures demotion from Premier should mean a suspension fora few weeks to rethink his ideas.

The ref for Albion v Newcastle won't have been decided yet !

 

[LANGDON SEAGULL]

Son told me he is doing our game v Newcastle not sure if that is true but what I dont understand is if he is considered niot good enough fior the Premier why nis he good enough for the Championship. He is either capable or not no half measures demotion from Premier should mean a suspension fora few weeks to rethink his ideas.

Refs are not announced till the week before


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[BensGrandad]

Refs are not announced till the week before


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

He must have got it wrong then. I have written an e mail to the EFL asking if he isnt good enough for the Premier why is he good enough for The Championship. I will post any reply I get, if they reply.

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

Son told me he is doing our game v Newcastle not sure if that is true but what I dont understand is if he is considered niot good enough fior the Premier why nis he good enough for the Championship. He is either capable or not no half measures demotion from Premier should mean a suspension fora few weeks to rethink his ideas.

He'd better bloody not be! [emoji35]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[W.C.]

He's being talked about in, er, New York https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/23/...er=rss&emc=rss&smid=tw-nytimes&smtyp=cur&_r=0

 

[Steve in Japan]

He's being talked about in, er, New York https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/23/...er=rss&emc=rss&smid=tw-nytimes&smtyp=cur&_r=0

That was quite a good read, ta. As it says, he got everything else right during the game, got one thing wrong, and a shitstorm descends on him. The joy of being a ref.

And no, I can't stand him either.

 

[essbee]

He's a moron.