[Brighton] Mac Allister - why isn't he playing more?

[zefarelly]

fight

 

[albionalex]

Experience of playing top level football.
As I said he is arguably more experienced.


But the main factor is that Moder's primary position and his experience is all at CM - so when it comes to competing with Mac in that role he has the edge.
We've also had injuries to Biss & Mwepu this season which has given Moder the opportunity to have a few more starts.

He has been pretty decent when he's played too.

So I don't really get the argument that MAc should have been picked a head of him.


The real issue is the amount of times we have had a need to cover an attacking role, which would suit him more.
In this role, he's up against Groß/Lallana/March and the formation/Tactics Potter chooses to play.
Again he isn't the most experienced option.

He also hasn't done enough to burst in and make the starting role his yet.
I think he probably will and see him as the long-term replacement for Lallana and Groß.

But that isn't going to be this season unless he starts winning games for us when he gets his chance.

Without knowing how he performs in training, Mac deserves some starts, regardless of who it's in place of. I was using Moder as a comparison because he's has had a lot of opportunities this season and he's been ok, but could say the same thing about Gross and Lallana.

Mac's best role is probably further forward but he's done well when he's played CM for us previously and I remember there was a stat that showed he was one of the best tacklers in the PL (might have even been Europe).

Personally, I really rate Mac and think he could help us score more goals. He has attributes that most of our players don't, and given the fact we haven't won in 11, I don't see why he can't get a run of 3-4 games in the side.

 

[SeagullsoverLondon]

Our Midfield is a really strange one.
In one sense it is our strongest area with most competition for places. (Especially now that we are down to bare bones with Centre Halves).

But I am not sure GP has worked out the best combination of 3 (or 4) in the Middle of the park.

I think Mac has just got squeezed out a little. I wonder if his best position would be at the front point of a diamond, however it is not really a formation that Potter uses much.

However, I do think he should be given an extended chance to prove himself

Sent from my moto g(7) power using Tapatalk

 

[Uh_huh_him]

Without knowing how he performs in training, Mac deserves some starts, regardless of who it's in place of. I was using Moder as a comparison because he's has had a lot of opportunities this season and he's been ok, but could say the same thing about Gross and Lallana.

Mac's best role is probably further forward but he's done well when he's played CM for us previously and I remember there was a stat that showed he was one of the best tacklers in the PL (might have even been Europe).

Personally, I really rate Mac and think he could help us score more goals. He has attributes that most of our players don't, and given the fact we haven't won in 11, I don't see why he can't get a run of 3-4 games in the side.

I rate him too, and Moder and plenty of others who I think deserve more starts, but I wouldn't want GP to be trying to keep everyone happy.
I'd rather he continues to pick the players he think will be best for the next game.

 

[Sarisbury Seagull]

Our Midfield is a really strange one.
In one sense it is our strongest area with most competition for places. (Especially now that we are down to bare bones with Centre Halves).

But I am not sure GP has worked out the best combination of 3 (or 4) in the Middle of the park.

I think Mac has just got squeezed out a little. I wonder if his best position would be at the front point of a diamond, however it is not really a formation that Potter uses much.

However, I do think he should be given an extended chance to prove himself

Sent from my moto g(7) power using Tapatalk

Interesting you say that about a diamond, it is something I’ve thought would suit us for a while and would like to see us try. I thought we would more after the Luton friendly too.

With Lamptey and Cucurella at FB/WB I think we’re ideally set up for it. Bissouma at the base, Mwepu and Moder just ahead and then Mac Allister at the front of it. Lallana can alternate with any of them too. Then two of Maupay, Trossard and Webeck up front. I really think it suits the players we have.

 

[Don Tmatter]

Wasnt there rumours a few weeks back, he’s off in January?

 

[jessiejames]

Should have started instead of Mwepu.

 

[SeagullsoverLondon]

Interesting you say that about a diamond, it is something I’ve thought would suit us for a while and would like to see us try. I thought we would more after the Luton friendly too.

With Lamptey and Cucurella at FB/WB I think we’re ideally set up for it. Bissouma at the base, Mwepu and Moder just ahead and then Mac Allister at the front of it. Lallana can alternate with any of them too. Then two of Maupay, Trossard and Webeck up front. I really think it suits the players we have.

Definitely worth trying I would think. That would be a strong líne up

Sent from my moto g(7) power using Tapatalk

 

[Bodian]

And there you have it!

 

[Mackenzie]

I thought his set pieces were a big step up on anything we’ve seen this season. Very good.

 

[portslade seagull]

Seemed off the pace to me but that could be the lack of game time
Would like to add his corners were good but no one took advantage

 

[Harry Wilson's tackle]

I thought his set pieces were a big step up on anything we’ve seen this season. Very good.

Corners.

Anyway, great team performance

 

[Swansman]

Had a great game, could be his breakthrough moment.

 

[NorthstandRacoon]

Yeah me and my mates always say he's hard done by.

Will look forward to hopefully seeing more of him as he is an excellent player.

 

[KZNSeagull]

Was a decent performance, started poorly but got better. We look more dangerous with him in the team. Hope he gets to start against Chelsea to see how he plays against a better side.

 

[Nobby Cybergoat]

Clearly a proper player in there.

A bit inconsistent and occasionally loose.

You just think that if he got a run of games and stayed fit, he'll be a very good player in a year or so

 

[Billy in Bristol]

We have a lot of good midfielders but yes Ali Mc should be starting more often (just don't ask instead of who).

 

[prawnsarnies]

Grew as the game went on, great box to box performance.

 

[WhingForPresident]

Bound to be a little rusty after not playing a lot this season, started slowly but definitely grew into it. Better deliveries from set pieces than anything we have seen from Moder and Groß in the last few months.

 

[Nobby Cybergoat]

We have a lot of good midfielders but yes Ali Mc should be starting more often (just don't ask instead of who).

To me, Lallana is the one I'd be rotating in and out for MacAllister. Similar players, need to manage Adam's minutes.

Lallana obvious a level above in the centre circle, but Alexis looks like he'd have more goals in him