Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Large protest tonight Brighton!



rogersix

Well-known member
Jan 18, 2014
8,202
I thought a civil war with a higher death rate per capita of the population than WW1 essentially got my nation on the path to a parliamentary democracy?

History is definitely changing, Cromwell was a lefty and his new model army were merely protesting at Naseby.........someone better tell the Irish that Drogedha was no worse than Greenham common.

where did it start, sweetie?
 








Jan 30, 2008
31,981
Indeed BREXIT was a very good example where the government made it into a confrontational issue of us and them, victors and losers trying to alienate a large % of their population which they are supposed to represent. What's even more strange is that you and Ppf go on about democracy without understanding what it really is , nor do you understand Parliamentary democracy (which is not the same) where you elect people to make decisions on your behalf based on their interpretation of what is best. When they don't agree with you they are called traitors.

When you're constituency has voted one way and your MP decides another it could end up with said MP being kicked out :)
https://youtu.be/Oh_YKZf8aYI
Regards
DF
 






Wardy's twin

Well-known member
Oct 21, 2014
8,866
When you're constituency has voted one way and your MP decides another it could end up with said MP being kicked out :)
https://youtu.be/Oh_YKZf8aYI
Regards
DF

Agreed and that is part of the 'parliamentary democracy' chain although it has often been hijacked by both the left(momentum) and right(ERG) to have their views dominate rather than those of the man in the street and that has cost the seats for many moderates.

But if we get back to the original point of what do you do when you come up against the establishment brick wall there are basically two options , you do nothing and hope that things will change or you take more assertive action to make sure your opinion is listened to. So do i condone violence on police or indeed anyone, the answer is no but where people are left with no option then i can see how things escalate.
 


JC Footy Genius

Bringer of TRUTH
Jun 9, 2015
10,568
Indeed BREXIT was a very good example where the government made it into a confrontational issue of us and them, victors and losers trying to alienate a large % of their population which they are supposed to represent. What's even more strange is that you and Ppf go on about democracy without understanding what it really is , nor do you understand Parliamentary democracy (which is not the same) where you elect people to make decisions on your behalf based on their interpretation of what is best. When they don't agree with you they are called traitors.

Speaking of not understanding. :facepalm: Our parliamentarians, by a huge majority, voted to give us a chance to have our say on EU membership in a referendum, a democratically elected government was then elected with a manifesto commitment to hold a referendum and promised to enact that decision no matter the outcome, the government and official opposition both committed to enacting the referendum result. They delegated the choice to the people Anyone seeking to renege on their promises/manifesto commitments could justifiably be called all sorts of names ... undemocratic loons, traitors, Lib Dems etc
 


JC Footy Genius

Bringer of TRUTH
Jun 9, 2015
10,568
Agreed and that is part of the 'parliamentary democracy' chain although it has often been hijacked by both the left(momentum) and right(ERG) to have their views dominate rather than those of the man in the street and that has cost the seats for many moderates.

But if we get back to the original point of what do you do when you come up against the establishment brick wall there are basically two options , you do nothing and hope that things will change or you take more assertive action to make sure your opinion is listened to. So do i condone violence on police or indeed anyone, the answer is no but where people are left with no option then i can see how things escalate.

But (as you know) people in the Uk do have other options, lobby your democratically elected representatives, resort to law if you think a breach of the law has occurred or campaign lawfully to change policy/minds. The problem with a lot of protests these days is they go straight to direct action/breaking the law.
 




Wardy's twin

Well-known member
Oct 21, 2014
8,866
Speaking of not understanding. :facepalm: Our parliamentarians, by a huge majority, voted to give us a chance to have our say on EU membership in a referendum, a democratically elected government was then elected with a manifesto commitment to hold a referendum and promised to enact that decision no matter the outcome, the government and official opposition both committed to enacting the referendum result. They delegated the choice to the people Anyone seeking to renege on their promises/manifesto commitments could justifiably be called all sorts of names ... undemocratic loons, traitors, Lib Dems etc

People were given a referendum because the Tory party was worried it would disappear into the night as it lost its support to UKIP. The labour party under JC was also anti EU so no opposition to a vote as he saw he had nothing to lose. Most MPs agreed to let the vote happen as they thought the British people can't be that stupid as to vote to leave also giving no thought to how the use of a referendum brings into question the whole parliamentary process. They were arrogant and stupid and certainly misread the mood of the country (or 52% of it). But once they realised they had got it wrong they tried to fight it , too late and without enough purpose with party divisions weakening the remainer cause.

Note first past the post and democracy are not the same thing, democracy is about compromise and consent.

So getting back on topic , what should have happened is both the Tory & Labour MPs should have done more to represent the views of their constituents BEFORE there was any vote and they needed to try to understand why Farage was gaining votes (from both left and right) and what were the real underlying issues. In this particular instance all pressure was released by leaving the EU but let's be clear had it not happened the right wing would have been on the streets.
 


Jan 30, 2008
31,981
Agreed and that is part of the 'parliamentary democracy' chain although it has often been hijacked by both the left(momentum) and right(ERG) to have their views dominate rather than those of the man in the street and that has cost the seats for many moderates.

But if we get back to the original point of what do you do when you come up against the establishment brick wall there are basically two options , you do nothing and hope that things will change or you take more assertive action to make sure your opinion is listened to. So do i condone violence on police or indeed anyone, the answer is no but where people are left with no option then i can see how things escalate.
These demos are just a small minority being given exposure by the left orientated media I would imagine most people in this country have had enough of them
Regards
DF
 










Wardy's twin

Well-known member
Oct 21, 2014
8,866
But (as you know) people in the Uk do have other options, lobby your democratically elected representatives, resort to law if you think a breach of the law has occurred or campaign lawfully to change policy/minds. The problem with a lot of protests these days is they go straight to direct action/breaking the law.

The problem with a lot of protests these days is they go straight to direct action/breaking the law. I guess all football fans are hooligans bent on causing trouble and beating people up, perhaps fans should be banned from all games.

Not all protests are violent but this will reduce the opportunity for passive demonstration which will lead to more extreme protest.
 




The Clamp

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jan 11, 2016
26,182
West is BEST
Traitors?

B69ABDE3-D1A3-4058-B8B4-58F2D63EF7EC.jpeg
 














Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here