James Milner or Stephen Ireland

[Del Boy]

Simple poll, who would you prefer in your team? All this fuss over Milner, I'd prefer Ireland anyday! After all, he is SUPERMAN!

or

or

 

[Perkino]

I'd prefer Milner in my team although I would rather keep Ireland and the £24m instead of swapping that for Milner.

He does improve them but not hugely he is just another decent player that city have bought, but I'm still waiting for them to buy a world class player

 

[Sam Ovett]

Mancini has stated Milner is the last signing they make this transfer window. What do you think of their chances?

 

[kevtherev]

I'd prefer Milner in my team although I would rather keep Ireland and the £24m instead of swapping that for Milner.

He does improve them but not hugely he is just another decent player that city have bought, but I'm still waiting for them to buy a world class player

Agree with all of that, totaly unimpressed with the money City have spent and what they got for it. The manager will be gone by xmas as will their title hopes.

 

[Seagulls4life]

Milner has a big head

 

[Sam Ovett]

Milner has a big head

Do you mean he is arrogant, or that his head is large?

 

[Seagulls4life]

Do you mean he is arrogant, or that his head is large?

His head is large. Should have made the a little clearer

 

[Cpt. Spavil]

ireland by far

 

[Skaville]

Two of the best players to have ever graced the turf at Withdean, that's for sure.

 

[Sam Ovett]

His head is large. Should have made the a little clearer

Na, I'm just a bit dim

 

[See-Goals]

Two of the best players to have ever graced the turf at Withdean, that's for sure.

This (there goes my 'this' cherry)

Wasn't Milner about 16 when he played us on loan to Swindon? He still stands out in my memory of the game.

Ireland was one of the most composed players I've ever seen on the ball when we beat Saudi Arabia in the cup.

 

[The Terminator]

Milner is the most overrated player in the Premiership. He has good moments, he's a solid Premiership player, but I could name 30 midfielders in the Premiership I would rather have.

go on then ?

 

[Sam Ovett]

Etherington?

 

[beorhthelm]

Ireland is a good player but really, Milner is far better. its not really far to compare as they are different types of player, like asking whos better out of Tevez or Mascherano.

not sure why there are Milner haters either. top player, plays across the pitch unselfishly and happens to have taken opportunity to move to a club with bigger aspirations. personally, i think he should have moved to Liverpool or Arsenal, but they aint buying. he could have stayed, but he and his advisers obviously believe he has better prospects elsewhere.

 

[Sam Ovett]

Lampard
Malouda
Nani
Scholes
Young
Essien
Mascherano
Silva
Gerrard
Lennon
Barry
Valencia
Kalou
Cole
Arteta
Fabregas
Kuyt
Parker
Carrick
Cahill
Benayoun
Ireland
Toure
Walcott
Arshavin
Diaby
Park
Aquilani
Kranjcar
Nasri

No way!!

 

[Aldo]

If Milner wasn't English he would be worth about 10 mil

 

[KaylaRennerz]

Milner easily!

 

[Skint Gull]

Lampard
Malouda
Nani
Scholes
Young
Essien
Mascherano
Silva
Gerrard
Lennon
Barry
Valencia
Kalou
Cole
Arteta
Fabregas
Kuyt
Parker
Carrick
Cahill
Benayoun
Ireland
Toure
Walcott
Arshavin
Diaby
Park
Aquilani
Kranjcar
Nasri

Thats a pretty fair list and there's certainly no way that all of those would be 'worth' £24mil plus Ireland

 

[Agent_Torpor]

Lampard
Malouda
Nani
Scholes
Young
Essien
Mascherano
Silva
Gerrard
Lennon
Barry
Valencia
Kalou
Cole
Arteta
Fabregas
Kuyt
Parker
Carrick
Cahill
Benayoun
Ireland
Toure
Walcott
Arshavin
Diaby
Park
Aquilani
Kranjcar
Nasri

Walcott? Yer havin' a laff. Settle down, punchy. You're pulling my Niko Kranjcars.

 

[Marshy]

its a close call between Milner and Ireland for me, I do think Milner is better, but not Ireland and 16 million better, Villa have a great deal.