Is this the greatest indie album of the last century?
- Thread starter Brighton TID
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
spring hall convert
Well-known member
Brilliant record, as much as I love most of their subsequent material, they've not really ever got close to it again.
Unfair.
That conversation has drifted. I said that I wouldn't consider them in MY personal 'Indie' pigeon hole, and that in the PERSONAL pigeon holes of my mind, they were sorted in their own seperate Baggy / Madchester genre with the Inspiral Carpets, etc. For purposes of THIS discussion they are as valid as the other nominations of Nirvana, etc.
But to refer to The Fall as NOT indie IS mental.
This thread is an absolute joy, not just for the debate but for it's ability to recall different parts of my life!
And that call is case in point. I remember listening to that Butthole Surfers album regularly when I was living with a bunch of guys and girls in Canada in the early 90s. If I'm honest, I didn't get on with it but I can see why others did.
spring hall convert
Well-known member
Sounds about right.
red star portslade
New member
I'm away that week. Gutted!!
Trufflehound
Re-enfranchised
Aye, possibly. But it was comparative popularity I was talking about, not whether FT is any good or not...
spring hall convert
Well-known member
I knew that, just couldn't resist a dig. Do not understand what the fuss is about. Most successful music, regardless of whether I like it or not, I can understand why people do. Frank Turner, I am genuinely at a loss with.
Same for me when it comes to The Pixies. Very average band for me.
Crikey.
Albumen
Don't wait for me!
Woah!
I know, I know. I feel like I SHOULD like them. His voice is horrible, the dynamics of the music (LOUD quiet LOUD quiet) I find very dull. I like bands that are similar(ish) as well, like Nirvana, My Bloody Valentine and a few others.
I also think Sonic Youth are MASSIVELY overrated too, so this might explain it a bit more.
BadFish
Huge Member
- Oct 19, 2003
- 18,194
The pixies never did it for me either, but then Nirvana never really set the world alight for me. Loved Sonic Youth though.
Insel affe
HellBilly
Hey fella I was smack in the middle of it living in Manchester as a student at the time, admittedly my first love was Psychobilly, but the Roses were played in the same clubs and other bands and I love the album I agree with you to a point apart from the brand spanking new they sounded very much like the Bugs and other garage bands flirting with a new sound.
No doubt though a good album, but not the best
BadFish
Huge Member
- Oct 19, 2003
- 18,194
Fair point you sound like you had far more music knowledge than me. I was still at school without much knowledge of independent music. The Roses were really a first glimpse of that world for me. Although retrospectively i heard the influences. Thinking Primal Scream had ripped them off the checking the release date of Sonic Flower Groove was a particular eye opener. But like i say it came into my life at the perfect time and opened so many doors for me that it is not possible for me to be objective about them. This is why I don't call it the best but it is certainly my favourite. Exciting times, you were lucky to be amongst it in Manchester.
JamesAndTheGiantHead
Well-known member
You monster.
Sorry. Like I said, I WANT to like them. I've given them plenty of chances.
tinx
Well-known member
Lazarus was an epic anthem and still one I can listen to now.
Reminded me of another great one too.
Weekender by Flowered Up.